Milk & Sugar Creamery

Okay. So we wandered in here in a Saturday afternoon and the place was empty. Mind you, we picked an ofd hour and it was a colder cloudy day. The place was clean, and we were impressed by the ambiance, vibe and character the place has. My husband and I ordered a flight to share and sample (chocolate, vanilla, coffee and the kitchen sink) and my little sister ordered a milkshake. While I paid, she wandered over to the little toy ice cream cart they have and played with my daughter there while we waited for our order. The ice cream was phenomenal, the selection was impressive (they do offer samples) but what had me most excited? They use Strauss Organic as the base for their ice creams. For those of you who don't know.... Strauss is all I will buy and keep in the freezer at home. Why? It's limited ingredient. (They typically have 7/8 ingredients all of which you can pronounce) Clean ingredients. They also have dairy free and gluten free options on the menus. As a Mama in her health journey, and striving for a healthier future for my daughter, I'm excited to find a place that keeps that in mind while we indulge! We'll certainly be back next time we need a sweet treat, and I'm looking forward to trying some of their coffee drinks and other desserts soon.

Milk & Sugar Creamery is hands down our favorite locally family-owned ice cream spot in Tracy! We absolutely love supporting businesses like this, and they make it so easy with their incredible offerings. The flavors are super unique and always delicious--there's something for everyone to enjoy. The staff is so friendly and welcoming, making every visit a treat. It's also a great place to bring the little ones; they have games on the wall that our friends and kids had a blast with. If you're looking for a special spot for amazing ice cream and a fun atmosphere, this is it!

I wanted something sweet after my meal and it was really hot outside. This place did not disappoint. The service was really good, I got greeted by the staff as soon as I walked in the establishment. She offered my friend and I tasting samples to compare the different flavors. The ambiance was really nice, inside was clean and where they displayed the selection of ice cream were well organized and the names of each flavor were written very neatly and eye appealing.The ice cream I ended up trying was the non- dairy matcha flavored ice cream. If you did not tell me if was non-dairy I would have never guessed it. The matcha flavor was very delicious and the matcha tasted very good and sweet and not bland.I give this establishment a solid 4/5 stars and definitely recommend this establishment for ice cream. Will be coming back to try the seasonal flavors!

When I tell you that their ice cream SMACKS... it literally DOES. Quite frankly, this is one of my favorite ice cream spots in Tracy every time I come. It has been a while since I came to this particular ice cream shop, so I wanted to give it another try. The one thing that blew me away was the variety of non-dairy and dairy ice cream they had. I was craving some cinnamon and velvety, and right away they recommended us a sample of Horchata and lavender honey ice cream for us to taste. Not only was it super creamy, but we ended up getting double scoops of them.They were really quick to serve us, and was really helpful in answering questions that we had about the ice cream. in addition, the ice cream shop was kept really clean, and I really liked the environment, as it wasn't too crowded. Neither was it too cold. If you want an ice cream shop to stop by after shopping at West Valley Mall, this is one of the spots in Tracy that you wouldn't want to miss!

Milk & Sugar creamery is such a gem ice cream spot! They offer a wide variety of flavors that rotate often. Some flavors are ones you don't see at any regular ice cream shop so they are really unique. Staff are friendly and helpful with any questions you may have regarding the ice creams. I always recommend to my friends when they cone visit me to stop here to satisfy their sweet tooth!

Since moving to Tracy, this has become my favorite ice cream spot. The service is excellent, and the staff is incredibly patient while I sample different flavors before making my decision. Right now, I'm obsessed with the Rose Pistachio and Taro Mochi--they slap hard, especially in this heat wave. The outdoor seating area is a great place to enjoy your ice cream. Give this place a try; you won't be disappointed.

Best ice cream in Tracy! It's awesome that they make all of their flavors in-house, including many vegan options as well. They offer so many different flavor options to choose from and some rotate while others are always available.I've been to Milk & Sugar quite a number of times now and the quality and great customer service is always consistent. At first I thought their pricing was a bit high but I think it all makes sense for the quality they're serving. Their scoops are large and their toppings are generous when you order a sundae. Some of their flavors are more icy than creamy, but other flavors are very creamy and decadent. I like to try the flavors first and decide that way. A couple of my favorite flavors so far have been their cookie dough and their cookie butter - both really creamy and the cookie dough has many large pieces of dough in it.I noticed the last time that they've added new sauce pumps and offer caramel, peanut butter, and hot fudge sauce options - which I think the peanut butter is a new addition.We typically get their two-scoop sundae which comes with a topping and sauce of your choice and then whipped cream and a maraschino cherry. They used to display their toppings right on top of the ice cream display case, but I didn't see it last time. We typically get their Oreo and rainbow sprinkles toppings. They have a few more to choose from as well.Last time we went and my father-in-law got one of their newest menu items, an affogato with cookie dough ice cream. He loved it!

Tracy was the halfway point for my cousins from Stockton to meet for lunch, and we got Milk & Sugar Creamery for dessert. My oh my this long held bookmark was worth the wait. I think I would drive 28 minutes no traffic to visit again LOL. The flavors are super potent and you get unlimited samples! I got the taro with mochi and horchata (single split scoop) after sampling them, and I wish I sampled more!! Mochi bits were still soft, and I loved the strong cinnamon flavor in the horchata. I tried my sister's sakura ice cream and it was a little too floral for me, but she liked it the more she ate it. You can purchase pints and pre-scooped ice cream to go as well! The games are fun to play since the boards are stuck on the wall and the pieces are magnetic, so it doesn't get too chaotic. I was obsessed with their floor that looks like marble ice cream lol. Service was cheerful, patient, and friendly. Next time I will try the cookie butter and honeydew!

The food here is great, got myself a double sundae with hot fudge and the ice cream was milk tea. It was great and unique flavoring as well. The service was fast, polite, and accurate. The ambiance is nice and chill, they even have games to play with friends and family if you hang out there. They even have a kids table for children to sit and enjoy their treats. I highly recommend this place.

I just stocked our freezer with No Sugar Added Fudgsicles, Drumstick "dairy dessert" cones, and Keto ice cream, but I'm not craving any of that right now. I'm craving natural sugar in fruity, floral, lovely Lavender Blueberry ice cream from Milk & Sugar Creamery! We tried this place a few weeks ago, and I was thoroughly satisfied with half a scoop of Lavender Blueberry and half a scoop of Raspberry Chocolate Chip to fit in their single cup. Both flavors are dairy-free and divine.My sister thought her coffee ice cream was okay, nothing spectacular. I'm only removing one star because the place could use some cleaning on the counters, walls, and games that are on the wall. It would also be great if they had outdoor seating with umbrellas. The pleasant and friendly worker helped me choose the Lavender Blueberry ice cream. I'll be making the 30-minute drive back out there this summer.