Seattle Bay Creamery -- Homemade Ice Cream

We ended up heading here to get some ice cream on a nice sunny day. The line was long, but well worth the wait. We tried the cotton candy ice cream, vanilla bean ice cream and the Huckleberry ice cream. They were all fantastic and we will be back.

Butterfinger with a sugar cone was my jam. We walked up and I was instantly greeted by a cheery gal, they have 12 flavors and three different cones that you can pick from. The case was very well cleaned and ice cream presented well. I ordered a butterfinger cone (sugar cone) which was delish. I also got a cup of reeces for the my two sons to share . They loved it ! Completely devoured ! They accept card here or cash. Thank you for the quick service and yummy ice cream

I get that fees to be right on the pier are probably pretty high, but if I'm paying $16 for two single scoop cones, I'm expecting some pretty great ice cream - this was edible, pretty average. I could get better quality from a grocery store pint.

This is not homemade. It's so artificial. The strawberry was bland and so fake tasting and the peanut butter chocolate had no real chocolate flavor and the peanut butter was little weird pebbles and tasted nothing like peanut butter. The cone was hard hard. Just skip it

Eh, the flavor is only so-so. The scoops are large so one is plenty to share. Personally I would prefer a smaller scoop of higher quality ice cream.

It was a beautiful day, and the seattle bay creamery was the highlight of the day. The service was excellent , staff answers all of your questions they had a variety of delicious treats. There is seating around that offer beautiful views and the chance to people watch.

Aesthetic lemonade, looks amazing right !!NOOO, it was so bitter that it didn't taste like nothing, water down and very sour. Don't buy it each one like 8$Don't get the lemonade it's terrible, I had to throw it away.

The ice cream was so good and not too sweet. The shop is very clean and always has friendly staff. We will definitely get ice cream here again.

The perfect combo of overpriced and not good at all. "Butterfinger heaven" tasted like frozen sugar water and had zero butterfinger in it. Two single scoop cones was over $20. Save your money and go somewhere better

I had cookies and cream and my friend had the Carmel coffee. Both did not taste like the actual flavors and they were both crystallize. overall not good at all would not recommend coming here.