A Slice of New York

Excellent service and awesome food!Ordered three personal pizzas to go: 2 City and 1 Bensonhurst.Perfectly hot at pickup and still warm 25 minutes later when eating at homeThank you SONY for serving the best pizza in our county!

This has been our family favorite for 10+ years. I've been coming here for over 15 years and the consistency is amazing. I wish I had pictures but it doesn't matter. Everything we have had is always just right and never had any complaints. Highly recommend all the pizzas. We especially love the Sicilian which is light and fluffy with crispy edges. Fantastic!We will return here again and again.

My husband and I have been wanting to try this place out- finally made it. So so glad we came- the crust was thin and chewy, the different flavors amazing. We also tried the Sicilian style - thicker pizza. We were surprised there was a special today- with 2 slices - you get a soda( lots of nice flavors- we tried the dark cherry and root beer). The staff was super super friendly. Decor had a nice vibe. We definitely want to bring our kids when they come home.

If you're craving pizza but can't finish an entire box by yourself, you should check out A Slice of New York for authentic pizza (they also sell by the box). There's plenty of seating area which is great and I've heard tons of friends from New York say this is the best New York style pizza in the Bay Area.

WOWWWW this pizza is down right amazing. When we first walked in and saw the slices on display, visually we weren't impressed at all, but we weren't going to judge it until after we tasted. Once they threw it in the oven and served it to us, the first bite changed everything. This was everything you could want in a quality slice of pizza -- so light and crispy, flavor packed toppings and piping hot just how I like it. The ambiance was also inviting , with bigger tables for parties and nice cartoon designs on the walls. 100% must try this pizza, easy 5 stars awarded!

Friendly and active staff will introduce you to which one has vegetarian options and which one has non-vegetarian options. Their vegetarian pizza is delicious. I recommend trying it; if you are a fan of meat, you can add more toppings, which is a great idea. The knot tastes ok too, and it's not dried. We would come back to try the other flavor!!!!!!

Absolute bomb of an amazing experience. Was craving pizza and seeing the Yelp reviews for this place I knew I had to come here.The friendliest of employees I've ever seen so passionate in helping out their customers - and at a pizza place at that too!The lady was so kind and took time explaining to us how much we should order, what type of pizza there are, and reminded us the garlic knots here are to die for. And they were!We basically got three slices of pizza she recommended and she even offered to cut the slices in half for me and my friend even before we asked. Every single pizza was amazing and I can't wait to try more options!!I love the chill vibez here as well. One of my favorite places in the bay. :)))

3.5 starsHonestly I was not expecting such a high rating from fellow Yelpers but I gave my rating based on 2 major reasons: 1. I'm just not a fan of pizza or anything heavy carb; 2. They are a bit pricey compared to other places. I was not planning to come here but my carbnivol child suggested this place after some Google search. I read further online and was even more discouraged. Nevertheless, we came. The plaza was a bit small and we almost missed the entrance. And this place is at the further side of the lot, which I thought would limit it's foot traffic. However, when I came in, I was a bit surprised at how elaborate and loaded of effort the decoration is. I mean, it looks messy and it's a lot of stuff, nd on top of that, there are warning signs, old pages of pizza thieves and unwanted guests, but it's interesting. I read online that seating was limited but it's not the case in the store. They even have a smaller room for more seating and seemed to have more a/c. I was hoping the menu would have non-bread items like chicken wings. But the staff told me they made their bread and dough from scratch and they are really good and they are proud of it. So everything is breaded on the menu, if it's not pizza, then it's garlic knot, calzone, pannini, etc, you get the idea. So we decided to go for a half and half, small. They only have personal, small and large sizes. Large is really large. Small is just as big as a medium. We got half Bensonhurst (chicken) and half Times Square which is a vegge pizza, and a small one costed $43! They said there are extra topping costs, but anyhow, an equivalent of medium size pizza somewhere else is probably sub 30, so $43 seems pricey for us. The pizza is thin but saucy. The toppings are wet and warm and nice enough to not making the pizza overly doughy. I did feel a bit sleepy right afterwards because of the heavy carb, but overall it is a tasty pizza. It means quite a bit from someone who just doesn't like pizza. Service was impeccable. I was expecting a lazy tired and cold staff behind the ordering counter, but they all sounded so friendly and energetic and caring. Pizza was delivered to our table and the staff kindly pointed out where we could get our napkins. She came to collect the tray at the end and checked on us again. I felt the service was way above and beyond any other pizza joints. So I can't give them a 4 star just because I don't like pizza that much, but with that condition, they earn a 3.5 star with losing half a star to price. I think they did pretty good overall.

5 Stars because I think it's worth visiting. The pizza was good quality. Good price. I'm not a fan of pickled jalapeño, but I still enjoyed it. I would go again.

We had a great experience here! My friends and I dined in this past Friday. The garlic knots are a must order! These are probably the best garlic knots in the Bay Area. I ordered the Rockefeller Pizza. Loved the sliced meatballs on top. This is a pizza for the meat lovers like myself. The place was extremely busy, but the crew was on top of everything and gave us great customer service. This is a great place to grab a slice of pizza.