The Fudgery

Paid $13 for a dry haystack. Half a pound of strawberries is 17.99. The blonde woman running this stand was upset I didn't want to purchase and made nasty faces at us. So rude. Don't buy from this stand. Overpriced and staff that can't regulate their own emotions.

$16 for 1/2 pound just one type of fudge they won't cut it in half I've been to many fudge shops variety is the spice of life other stores weigh by the ounce they let you get as many different types as you want. You're not stuck with just one kind but that price I'm not gonna spend $32 for two pieces of fudge! I have a feeling they would sell a lot more if they would cut it into a quarter slice so you can get for different types

Terrible caramel apple! I bought a gourmet apple for $15. I took it home, same day, and cut it. The caramel was crystallized and soupy which caused all the chocolate to fall off when cutting. Total waste of money, especially when we walked in Trish's Chocolate at the other end of the pier caramel apples were $10-13, they offered to cut it for you and the caramel was much better.We also bought a chocolate covered marshmallow for $10 from Fudgery. At Trish's, chocolate covered marshmallows were $3! STAY AWAY from this place.

I used to love coming to this place on my visits. Without fail, I would go home with six slices of fudge. This time the fudge was hard, as though it had been out for weeks. I asked the young female employee how long it had been out and she said, "not long." She was rude and unhelpful, as was the man who was making the fudge. Rude, stale, and overpriced. I will never retuen.

For the employees who were closing up on Friday (5/21/2021), thank you so much! You didn't need to invite me in to get a caramel apple or two, and I really appreciate the kindness! I'm sorry it ended up with you guys getting a number more people seeing then asking for after-hours, last minute purchases as well.Really appreciate the little things. It's fun they have individual boxes for the apples. We were traveling at the time, so this was really appreciated. And the spray they did to the bottom of the box to prevent the apple from sticking was also a pleasant detail. My purely caramel apple still stuck to the side of the box in a way that the premium one covered in nuts didn't, but a night in the fridge before cutting means they caramel is easier to separate and cut while also not sticking in the crevices of your teeth quite as much. It was an excellent apple. A bit pricey, but that's to be expected of the location. I was also awed by the open candy/chocolate kitchen. Don't know if they're still doing fudge and chocolate making displays at this time, but the potential that they will in the future is nice.Most everyone was closing down at 7:30-ish, and The Fudgery has these big wall to ceiling windows so you can see everything inside. Including the display of fudge and rows of caramel apples. Ever since the Milpitas Rock Mountain Factory closed down, I haven't had a caramel apple. I wanted one, but I honestly was doing the whole dramatic, forlorn, arms-reaching-out thing to get a laugh out of my family. The staff saw though and invited me in out of pity, so I did end up getting two apples for my family and myself. It was great and I appreciate how friendly everyone was as we chatted.

Fantastic caramel apples with peanuts. I'm always on the hunt for caramel apples with peanuts that have crisp apples and delicious caramel smothered in peanuts and I found just that at the fudgery. Y'all should bring one to L.A.

This place is a sweets-lover's dream! The homemade fudge is outstanding, although pricey. There are flavors for everyone. They sell the flavors only in half pound increments. If you get 3 half pound flavors, you get a fourth for free. Also, they let you taste one flavor. Everyone we tried was great.

The caramel sauce on the apples was soggy and definitely not worth the price wouldn't recommend

I was there on Saturday Oct 12, 2024 during Fleetweek. I paid $12.00 for a slice of the Rocky Road Fudge which was hard and dry. I can't believe they had the guts to sell something like that to unsuspecting customers! You are a disgrace. Avoid this place at all cost.

$18 for one almond turtle! Hell No! They had so many people walk up to look and walk away - this place is way too expensive. Plus they were overflowing with treats meaning - NO ONE is buying and if you do it will be stale/old. I guarantee they will be out of business soon