a whole pizza on a serving tray
a plate of spaghetti and meat
The Alexander Pizza w/extra cheese
Chicken Pesto Pasta
menu, ramen and noodles
Original box.
1/2 haystack 1/2 alexander
Blue moon on Tap!!! What's Pizza without a beer!
Difficult "salad"
outside
Half The Haystack/Half The Alexander
Greek Salad
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
Puddle of pizza
B. Calzone with Salami and Pepperoni
Very yummy combo
Half combination, and half pepperoni and sausage. Amazing!!
Chicken Cordon Bleu
The Haystack Pizza!!!
pizza
Veal
steak, food
food
Alice O.
Dec 31, 2024
Stalwart good food restaurant with excellent service in Noe Valley. Best rendition of a New York pizza
Read MoreSteve R.
Feb 26, 2025
Listen - haystack is an institution. They've been around since before the dinosaurs, a noe valley staple.I'll be blunt, the pizza is very underwhelming. I suggest you come here if you want a nice cozy place to sit, you and your friend order two personal pizzas, or a medium, whatever, drink some coke, talk. I love the interior it feels like a family restaurant (and it is!) Cannot reccomend the sandwiches, or really anything else on the menu, and I've tried a lot. Know what you're getting when you come in and just chill, it'll be fine.
Read MoreGregorio I.
Jan 4, 2025
Haystack pizza wheel wagon sucks Today I got my last pizza Today's date 01/04/2025
Read MoreElaine Y.
Feb 3, 2025
As much as I love local pizzas, this last time will be the last time we order from here. The veal was inedible as it was too salty. The pizzas were a soggy mess. Pizzas were incorrectly made. We waited over an hour over the promised time. I'm wondering if owners/cooks were switched.
Read MoreCrosby M.
Dec 29, 2024
Service was friendly and quick, pizza was great! So glad Haystack is still part of Noe Valley :-)
Read MoreWilliam B.
Oct 20, 2023
This another of my adventures of going to a different Pizza place which is called Haystack Pizza...I have never been to this pizza place before until when I was invited to come here for my Cousins Birthday Dinner Pizza Party & My Most favorite pizza slice is the Alexander Pizza AKA Meatza Meatza Slice & Lelani Hawaiian AKA Canadien Bacon & Pineapple Slice.....
Read MoreCoolio V.
Feb 9, 2025
The food is good as ever. The review is on the service.We were a group of 6, My friend and I both ordered the Veal Scalapini the others ordered pizzas. The pizzas came out in a very timely manner however the veal took 2.5 hours to come. Apparently the piece of paper the order was on fell in the kitchen. This is unexusable. I could go on about how horrible Tina was but I wont. Get rid of Tina and everything will be great again.
Read MoreOwen M.
Feb 21, 2025
Ordered take out. Picked up when they told us to come and the pizza was soggy and inedible. Take out cheese was old and smelled moldy. Unfortunately would not come back.
Read MoreMike K.
Oct 8, 2024
Ordered an eggplant parmesan sandwich just because we could. Delivered and, while the amount of actual eggplant was prodigious (which was good, but unusual) the top and bottom were absolutely burned!That the kitchen let this out in this state for delivery to a long-time customer is an absolute tragedy.Goodbye Haystack; I can say I knew ya when.
Read MoreEugene L.
Jan 19, 2025
I ate here for 30 years. The Alexander all meat pizza use to be great. I always ordered the extra large wagon wheel and recommended others to do the same. Past year they have gone downhill. The sauce is not as good and they skimp on the toppings. They need to get back to their old recipe and quality or they will lose more customers.
Read More