the Paia Pie
The Screamin Tomato
the outside of the restaurant
the interior of a restaurant
interior
extreme outside view
large half hawaiian and half combo
Paia Pie & Railroad Grade
Menu 9/2023
Yard sale
Hawaiian!!
Railroad Grade & Paia Pie
Pesto pizza small delicious
Half yard sale & Hawaiian
Ordered 2 pizzas for my nephews 1st bday.
interior
Paia Pie / Hanoi Fever
pizza, food
Pepperoni pizza with hardly any pepperoni!
Pandora's box with a bite already
pizza, food
Paia pie
8" Indee Classic Pepperoni Pizza Side Caesar Salad 1/2 Dozen Spicy Buffalo Wings
pizza, food
Daniel H.
Dec 19, 2024
The nostalgic Extreme Pizza!!!How many years has it been now? I still remember when Extreme Pizza opened in Fillmore! It was clearly different from other chain pizza places or the typical neighborhood pizzerias. The restaurant was always packed with customers, and you had to wait over an hour for takeout orders. With that kind of popularity, Extreme Pizza expanded to many locations, becoming one of the best in its time!But what happened? Many of the locations have closed, and now there are only a few left... It feels like so much has disappeared, just like the once-glorious San Francisco!Today, I had lunch at an Extreme Pizza. It wasn't the same vibe as before, but it was still nice to taste that familiar flavor. Yet, part of me feels sad, almost like the current state of San Francisco.
Read More
Darwin P.
Jan 18, 2025
our pizza night at Extreme was great and satisfactory. the boys and i ordered a large pizza, half cheese, half sausage / green pepper. the service was good, the ambiance was nice and smooth at night, and with TVs showing the sports, we were more than comfortable enjoying our elite pizza
Read More
Bernard R.
Jan 12, 2025
Good service , good pizza They made it exaclty the way i asked them to. It was done in a timely fashion.
Read More
Julie C.
Aug 18, 2024
I came in and the person at the front was helpful and friendly. They have daily lunch specials which are a good price. I came later than lunch and ordered a small pesto pizza. The size was perfect, good for the price and delicious. I definitely recommend this place.
Read More
Crystal H.
Oct 13, 2024
Owners are kind and pizza is great with a wide variety of flavors! I was surprised to see some of the bad reviews, and I would like to encourage those interested in trying out a new pizza place to give this one a try or another chance. They have basic flavors and a whole bunch of homemade newer flavors that you wouldn't normally see at a pizza restaurant. In terms of pricing, some choices are pricier but they also have some really good deals if you're trying to eat some good/unique pizza on a budget. I would personally recommend the Mr Pestado Head pizza, which pleasantly surprised me with potatoes on a pizza BUT ITS EVERYTHING I COULD EVER WANT TO EAT ON A PIZZA. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed plus it's never too busy so you won't get a headache trying to find a table or waiting a long time for your order to get ready!
Read More
Stacey J.
Sep 17, 2024
We did takeout and had a great experience! Good customer service. Pizzas were made on time. They have sweet deals with their coupons. Ordered an XL pizza and got a free medium size cheese pizza--GREAT deal! I really enjoyed their unique pizza flavors. The ghost pepper pizza had a nice kick but the honey on the crust was a yummy sweet balance. Would order here again!
Read More
Linda L.
Mar 31, 2024
This Xtreme is close to my house than the one on Folsom. But I some times go to the one on Folsom as it's close to my moms work when I pick her up. My family and I order from here ALL THE TIME. Even during the pandemic, we did just so, every 3-4 months. During the pandemic, they also changed owners. As many stated, the new owner doesn't know how to run the place and ripped people off, skimped on toppings and such. I did not have that problem. Today, as usually, we got half yard sale & Hawaiian. Buffalo wings & mozzarella pepperoni bread sticks. Order on the phone, picked it up within 15 minutes and it was all ready. I literally live 10 minutes away. Pizza is delicious as always. The wings were .. tinier than usually but flavor pack, tender and crispy-ish on the edge. Breadsticks were chewy and cheesy, but there was a really strong aroma of alcohol which I believe is from the yeast.
Read More
Juan V.
Sep 6, 2023
The chain of Extreme Pizza have a consistent taste . The flavor of the pizza was good. I like that it is thin slices. The service was good.
Read More
John C.
Mar 23, 2024
Live close, but this is a good place since new (old) mgmt took over again - food tastes better. Pizza was way too oily before but it's good now. Pizza slice special and a beer is like 12-13 bucks. Good deal. Eat here prolly 2x a qtr.
Read More
Anna S.
Dec 29, 2023
Don't let the sleepy location fool you. They have great pizza and friendly service. I have always liked Extreme Pizza but it has been a while since having it. This time did not disappoint. They have a lot of exotic flavor combinations for pizza as well as your standard toppings for pizza. We got the Kicken Chicken (Thai inspired pizza with peanut sauce, a little spicy) and Yard Sale (standard combination pizza with sausage, pepperoni and bell peppers etc.) as a half half pizza. The crust was even good and edible so the entire slice was eaten. We enjoyed it.
Read More