Eagle Pizzeria

I was super impressed with Eagle Pizzeria. We got a takeout pizza from here, but we also had the chance to check out the inside while we waited. The owner is really nice, I called ahead and he answered all of my questions about dietary restrictions. Ordering over the phone was a snap, and the pizza was ready when promised. We got there a little early, so we had the chance to check out the inside. It has a very family pizzeria feel, something you don't find much anymore, and even has some amenities for kids like a play kitchen. There's quite few local beers in cans and on tap too. The pizza itself was really tasty; the crust was great and the toppings were generous. Prices are reasonable for SF. We will definitely be back the next time we are in town!

It's too hard to choose a single favorite pizza so I have a few, depending on what I'm in the mood for. And Eagle Pizzaria had now moved onto my list. I want to order another one now just thinking about it. I'm not vegan but I avoid dairy so we ordered a pizza with vegan pesto and cheese that was the best I've ever eaten. The crust was chewy and crisp, the toppings were the perfect marriage of flavors. We also ordered a regular (non-vegan) sausage and pepperoni that the family liked. The house salad was good and shareable for 3 people. They were busy when we arrived with a boisterous soccer party and another on the way, but the server double checked the number of seats they needed and accommodated us at a table in the front window. He was super busy but not acting stressed about it. He took care of us and the throng of kids and parents. I loved the classic pizza parlor aesthetic with red checkered table cloths and interesting wall art. I will definitely come back the next time we are in the neighborhood

Neighborhood locals have told me that they make a solid pie for years. Coming to this block on a regular basis (weekly), I never tried their food. Until now.I decided to order our Saturday family dinner from here, placing a phone order shortly after they opened. I asked for a 5:30 pm pickup so the pie would still be warm when I got home.We started with the Eagle special pizza, extra large (https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=Nyzv7uWN1n0BRn5Zv6-Kyw&userid=saJuyv784apZzH--psHZ3Q) which consists of mushrooms, green bell pepper, green onion, black olive, sausage, and pepperoni. The mix of toppings were well balanced with no flavor dominating the others. The crust is old school with a crusty thick edge while the body was medium thick and not too doughy. I had several slices in the next week for breakfast and my mom had it for lunch a few times. We also shared a garden salad, side, with Caesar's dressing (https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=d0zhQDMX1ZuE_0L_hEwTVg&userid=saJuyv784apZzH--psHZ3Q); this is spring mix, tomato, cucumber, red onion, and shredded carrots. We enjoyed this mix of ingredients especially that it wasn't your typical iceberg lettuce variety. The Caesars dressing was not particularly appealing. I also got a classic meat lasagna (https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=jE5e6Re4D-Ue6Ba-YA43Pg&userid=saJuyv784apZzH--psHZ3Q) for later in the week. Made with a slightly sweet marinara sauce, this is an interesting (good way) take. Besides the noodles and ricotta cheese layers, I found ground beef mixed with sliced mushrooms. You know me and my mushrooms. This came with a few small slices of cheese garlic bread (https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=4C3G38irBYyFjJYu1aWpJw&userid=saJuyv784apZzH--psHZ3Q) which were perfect for sopping up the sauce. The portion is generous as I reheated half for lunch and had the rest a couple days later.When I arrived at 5:30 pm, several neighborhood locals made their way to a large table on the right. I wandered towards the back, looking for the cashier counter. Two ladies manning the front asked me how they could help me. I gave them my name and pickup time and was told my food was almost ready. I waited to the left by the large TV screen showing the Dodger Giants game. A short while later, a young guy brought my food out and took my credit card after asking whether I needed cheese and pepper packets (yes, please). In less than a minute, I was walking to my car. Thank you, Eagle, for joining my list of meal places for my family. And it was nice talking to one lady about her fur baby and doggy parks.*** Due note that they are temporarily closed till 7/17/24.

First time I stopped in for a slice of pie... absolutely one of the BEST pizzas I've tasted.I'm originally from Chicago and I've lived in SF close to 30 years (I've definitely had good pizza to compare).HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!

First time being at the Eagle and I thought the atmosphere was very cute and cozy. We ordered the Vegetarian Pizza and the ingredients were fresh and tasty. Also the guy at the counter was quite funny and kind, definitely will return again ^_^

incredible vibes here at eagle pizzeria!! we came into the restaurant 5 minutes after closing for 7 people and the owner still let us sit down. the pizzas we got were named after his daughter and wife, and they were both delicious! such a classic pizza place with great food and wonderful people. when the top keyword is "owner", you know he's truly a gem

4.5 stars* (wish yelp would allow half stars)Super cute family pizzeria! We ordered margherita, Amy E pizza and I forgot the last one . I didn't try the margherita but the Amy Pizza was really good. The fresh pesto sauce balanced well with the tangy bbq chicken, I would give 4.5 stars. The other pizza was solid, but nothing extraordinary. I liked how both pizzas weren't greasy and prices were very reasonable. The service was also really great and the owner was very kind in letting us sit down when it was almost closing time.Pizza - 4 starsService - 5 stars

Pizza, Burrata, Cesar were all excellent!! This place was great and Ken was so wonderful. If you're looking for a nostalgic, family owned place for great food and to catch a niners or giants game on the TV, this is a must. Support small businesses! 10/10

Best pizza ever. The crust and filling are the best!! My children and grandchildren look forward to having Eagle pizza all the time.

It's been 10 years since my first review of Eagle Pizzeria. I love the pizza and still love the crust. This pizzeria is my go-to joint. I never had a bad pizza.