Sofia's Pizzeria - Evans
Sofia's Pizzeria - Evans
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Rolls
Sofias pie
Pepperoni and mushroom small pizza
Sophia's calzone. Huge!! My hand to compare the size!!
Dining room
Margarita pizza
Pizza
Wings!!! You will not be disappointed!!
Margarita pizza
Pepperoni bites
Menu 1
Sofi's Calzone - half was soggy and it had no flavor. Terrible. Wouldn't order again.
Glob of cheese just coming off like nothing
I asked for light sauce...scared to know what extra sauce is.
Garlic knots cheesy
The cowboy with a slice taken
Sofia's calzone
Sofia's Calzone
food, pizza
Burned to a crisp. How does anyone let this out the door to a customer?
Worst pizza ever.
Small pizza
Gary R.
Jan 25, 2025
If you ever had pizza in NYC, you will have the same experience here, but with nicer people. :-)Service is quick especially if you order a slice of what's already made. Ambiance is what you'd expect for a basic pizza joint but they've added some nice murals on the wall. All in all, a great place for quality NY style pizza.
Read More
Chris T.
Dec 26, 2024
We have been wanting to try this pizzeria because it is literally in our neighborhood. We ordered a pizza on a Saturday evening and was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. We were driving across town and arrived 20 minutes and it was ready in a warming drawer. We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom small pizza. It was $20 for a small pizza. This is pricer compared to other pizza places, but it was very high quality ingredients with fresh mushrooms. The pizza crust was chewy and had nice char marks and just a great flavor. The toppings were the right amount of cheese to topping.
Read More
Dan P.
Dec 23, 2024
We've been curious about Sofia's Pizzeria because it is near our subdivision. On Saturday evening, we ordered a small pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Phone service was prompt. Pizza was promised in 20 minutes, and when we arrived it was waiting for us in a warming cabinet. Quality of pizza: above average with excellent crust and fresh mushroomsValue: pricier than most pizzas ($20 with tip for a small pizza) but quality ingredients.
Read More
Eric B.
Dec 8, 2024
Very small Pizza business with some great calzones and wings too. No telephone signal or wifi in the place so i recommend ordering to go. They have two small tables that seat 4 each. If you're looking for a tasty pie and some delicious calzones and wing, Sophia's is your place. Give them a try, ya won't be disappointed.
Read More
Jody B.
Sep 17, 2024
We found Sofia's when we first moved to the neighborhood, we tried it out and we love it. The pepperoni rolls are so good. We have also ordered the calzones, which are big and stuffed with tons of toppings (these are our favorite). Our kids love the cheese pizza and ask for it often. We can't wait to try their dessert pizzas. The workers are always friendly and keep us informed when we get there about how long it will take to be ready. They do have a rewards program and it is worth it to sign up, free pizza after your first order.
Read More
Scott R.
Dec 28, 2024
Be ready to pay top prices for pretty good food. That's it. The value proposition is definitely out of whack but you can't complain about good pizza and a nice salad.
Read More
Frankie M.
Dec 24, 2023
Stopped by this place due to driving by and noticed their sign. Went inside and ordered a small cheese/pepperoni pizza and a drink. The cashier explained their menu because I wanted a pizza not too large for one person and he made me one just right. There are about four to five tables with about four chairs each. Meant to take a before and after photo of the pizza but I was so hungry and the pizza looked and smelled so good that I just went to take a bite to eat and didn't realize that I was done with my pizza! In review, it was so good that I was only able to get an after photo of the fate of such tasty and hot pizza!
Read More
Fernanda S.
Dec 12, 2023
Unfortunately, I was not impressed with my first experience eating the pizza. I ordered a Margherita for delivery and instructed to not ring the bell or knock, and to just leave it at the door. The doorbell rang. It seems petty, but for someone with a sleeping baby, it was enough to get a mention. Overall the pizza was bland. The best part was the crust, to be honest and at least the basil was fresh. The toppings (cheese and tomatoes) would just fall off in huge chunks so it was frustrating to eat. The cheese didn't stretch like melted cheese but it was rubbery. Really a bummer because I am still looking for a go to pizza place, and thought I'd give them a try since the recently opened. Hope they can do better but it would take a lot for me to eat from here again.
Read More
Shannon J.
Jan 28, 2024
Wasn't impressed and probably won't order again. Went on a Sunday around 5 and only one person was working. Took forever to get our order placed and for the pizza to be made. The Sofi's Calzone was terrible and I definitely wouldn't recommend it. Half of it was soggy and it was so bland and watery. I had to add a ton of parmesan to make it semi edible, and even then, it was just gross. We also ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, and the center was soggy. Again, not much flavor and just nothing to write home about.
Read More
Erik F.
Mar 9, 2024
Front end is not well trained, poor gal on the register just didn't know what she was doing. However I will say she was nice and polite. The pizza, the sauce which I like sweet was spot on and probably the best part of the pizza. Too much cheese and a bit under cooked made it very floppy and greasy. If they just added less cheese and cooked it to get a bit of a crunch it would greatly improve the pie.
Read More
