PB&J with Tay

Tried PB&J with Tay for the first time! Just have to give credit where it's due. Wife took me here for my birthday and it was the best experience. Owners were super friendly and welcoming, letting us take our time reading over the menu and was willing to help answer any questions. The atmosphere was so incredibly nostalgic. Reminded us of being back home at our grandparents house as kids having a PB&J snack after playing in the yard. I had the Make my Tay and my wife had the Pooh Bear and added strawberry jelly. Both sandwiches were a 10/10!! We will definitely be coming back for a nice little getaway and travel back in time to when things were simple with a comforting PB&J.

Eating here was delightful. I went by myself. The chalkboard menu was extensive, so I let the guy behind the counter give me advice. He suggested adding walnuts to my peanut butter and jelly sandwich with chocolate hazelnut spread, to cut the sweetness. He was so enthusiastic about the food, and I love to see it. Every meal is served on a vintage Corelle plate (if you know, you know). They toast the bread. They use top-notch ingredients. It's super cute inside. Go here.

We came here around lunch time on a Sunday and they weren't too busy. Plenty of open tables and I'd be surprised if you encountered too long of a wait. The staff were super friendly and gave great suggestions on what to order!I can't believe this idea isn't a thing in more places. If you're a peanut butter lover or even just have a sweet tooth this place is an absolute must go if you're in reasonable proximity of San Antonio. I had the double decker with strawberry and blackberry jalapeño jam and see why it's so highly recommended. I appreciate that the menu is a small step below state fare food in terms of craziness and the vibe is way more cozy family hangout. I am sure I'll be back here and can only hope it will be sooner rather than later

Made the trip for peanut butter. lolI'll considered, it was worth the trip. We got the double-decker delight and another sandwich, I forget what it was called. Both were exceptional. I recommend bacon and peanut butter with cream cheese wholeheartedly. The place is a little rustic, a little homey, but well worth the visit.

Just a quick review of our first ever visit to a gourmet (but casual!) Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwich shop!It is located upstairs at the end of a nice area, with shops in old rail cars to two story music buildings. It doesn't look it from the outside, but when you get inside, it kind of feels like an old house. It's a nice vibe. Even nicer was the owner and team, as they chatted with us (even finding some military music commonalities!) and helped us pick. I had an outstanding "Elvis." Peanut butter, banana, bacon and a choice of jelly (I got jalapeño strawberry, lol!). Wife got a "Rocky Road" and our son got a custom job with... coconut shavings! Ah... that's my boy!Bottom line... we loved it! We'll be coming back when we need that comfort food, taken to the next level!

The best pb&j sandwich you will ever have. Service was amazing and owner is super friendly. Love the down home feel. Highly recommend.

PB & J on steroids!!! Tasty ingredients and the staff was extremely welcome and helpful.

I didn't go in but my son did. Said was a nice little place very friendly. Ordered MAKE MY TAY DOUBLE DECKER DELIGHT. Brought that baby home to share and I am like OMG! That was so delicious. I am not a PB & J fan but this was not ur ordinary PB & J . The strawberry jalapeño jelly LAWD! Loved it and was just the right amount of heat mixed with the cream cheese and bacon. Did not disappoint at all and will be returning to try another menu item. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!

If you enjoy supporting a local business with super friendly folks and great food this is the place for you! Owner could not have been friendlier and the place is just fun. There are a dozen different sandwiches to choose from and endless ways to customize on top of that. Don't snooze on the banana pudding either!

I love peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and I have been wanting to come here for a while now. Best pb&j I've had without a doubt. Place is upstairs a little hidden but It's nice inside and the owner was super polite and made sure we were taken care of . He recommended us to try the jalapeño jelly and I loved it . Was thinking about leaving with a jar of jelly lol. Would definitely come back to try a different sandwich. We had the double decker I believe with a cup of almond milk . Come check it out if you haven't yet!