Lucy's Cake Shop

Lucy's Cake was recommended to me and boy what a recommendation. Upon searching for a cake place in San Antonio to make a cake for my mother's 85th birthday party on Thanksgiving weekend. I reside in Houston and contacted Lucy's cake and spoke to Dawn. Dawn was exceptional, kind, and easy to coordinate. I emailed her a picture that I wanted on the cake, the flavor, and the type of frosting. Not gonna lie I was nervous because I didn't get to see the finish product Lucy's Cake outdid themselves. The cake came out perfect that it was the talk of the evening and happy to say it was not dry. Thank you Dawn for your assistance and professionalism. I will be ordering more cakes from Lucy's.

We've been ordering cakes from Lucy's for decades! We've ordered birthday cakes, holiday cakes, wedding cakes, baptism cakes and graduation cakes and all their designs are beautiful. Their buttercream icing is the BEST! Their cake is always very moist and their strawberry filling pairs very well with either their chocolate or vanilla cake.

Amazing cakes. Was able to order three hours in advance on a Saturday. Service was so helpful with directions about how to keep a cake fresh for 24 hours. The location is a tiny bit tricky to get to, but if you follow GoogleMaps, you'll be fine. Inside the store is pretty sparse and spacious--lots of cake decorations for sale, as well as cupcakes and refrigerated parfaits.

Oh my god I can't believe I hadn't reviewed this place yet. I needed to get a cake for my wife's birthday this past October and of course I waited until the last minute. I had a big family dinner at the melting pot set up and I hadn't ordered the cake yet. I went ahead at my sister's recommendation called Lucy's. We live in Blanco, Texas so my sister lives in San Antonio and offered to pick it up. I called and I will say the order takers over the phone do not have much of a bed side manner. They are very matter of fact and do not have time for niceties but they are efficient and get the job done and correct. They asked how I wanted it to be decorated and I just advised use Fall colors and have it say "Happy Birthday Alyssa" those were the only instructions. The cake I got was beyond my expectations. The end product was phenomenal. I then for my daughter's birthday a few week later ordered the cake from there as well and it was worth the one hour drive from our house in Blanco, Texas. My daughter has a tendency to ask for obscure heroes or characters this year it was Batgirl and thanks to Lucy's she had her most favorite cake yet. OH and if I haven't mentioned it yet the cake is moist and delicious and can do all different fillings. I have chosen both times the custardy cream and it has been so yummy that we will always get our cakes from here. Like I said do not be put off by their nonchalant straight to business demeanor they get the job done how you want and it is the most delicious cake you will ever have so it is worth the price and the drive.

This place used to be the go to for cakes. It has gone down in customer service. People are rude and we showed a lady a picture of what we wanted and instead of offering options she said she had no idea what Tetris was. It was a simple small cake. Will have to find a new cake shop.

My wife and I bought a cake from here for a gender reveal and we are disappointed with the outcome of the cake. We asked for a pink filling and they put a thin layer of a really light pink filling that no one could see. Everyone was confused digging in the cake trying to see what the color was. The front desk girl that took our order was in bad mood or something and didn't ask any questions for the details of the cake. Everything she wrote down was what she wanted. Of course when we go to talk to them about what happened "there's nothing they can do" it's upsetting and they don't put their customers first. Our moment was ruined because of this. The cakes aren't cheap and then for them to not do it correctly and not want to make it right is ridiculous!! Yes you're a business and supplies and paying your employees ain't cheap but it also costs me my hard earned money. Don't recommend!!

Consistently delish cakes.Have used for all family events for over 20 years.Everyone loves and expects Lucy's from us!

Lucy's never fails when it comes to cakes. They have been around for as long as I can remember. I have bought many baby shower and birthday cakes from them. The cakes are always soft, fluffy and tasty. The prices aren't outrageous either. I haven't had the first person tell that they didn't like the cakes from here This time I decided to try their cake balls with Bavarian filling. Yum! Definitely worth the calories. The staff is always friendly and you can order via phone.

Lucy's cake shop on 410 is where my family has always gotten our special occasion cakes. Just ordered my daughter's wedding cake!

I have been a Lucy's customer for some 40 years and for my birthday this year I wanted an 8" round cake and my husband, who was gracious enough to accommodate my request, brought home the moistest, tastiest and most beautifully decorated cake I've had since the last time I had Lucy's some 6 years ago. Bottom line is Lucy's continues to be consistently the best in town. My only takeaway was the boxing up of cake that was slightly smashed on one side and price for an 8" round cake was slightly high, however, I was 100% satisfied with the flavor, quality and appearance of cake. Lucy's is still the best!