Pasquale's Neighborhood Pizzeria

It is not cheap at all, which is what you pay for being close to the prestige. But honestly, this is great pizza! You can actually taste the basil on their basic and peperoni pies. And, it's actually an independent local shop. The slice of cheesecake I added on was not worth $9, so skip the desserts even if your eyes are tempted.

Went there again, and their Pizza is still so very yummy. Husband and I ordered the following assortment: Bianca, Arugula Salad, Midwest, and Buffalo Chicken slices in addition to Ricotta Calzone and Spinach Strumboli. Surprisingly the Arugula Salad pizza and the Bianca Pizza were the best ones. We both loved Bianca so much that we ordered a piece to go so we can enjoy it with the rest of the leftovers. If you're ever in Rochester, this place should be on your list to visit.

Always impressed with the exceptional food and service at Pasquales Neighborhood Pizza! The service, the fantastic, authentic NY pizza, and the sparkling clean restaurant - they do it right!

Loved it! Friendly staff. Good food. Cool atmosphere. We'll definitely be back. This place has so much more than just pizza!

Service was good. The pizza was bland. Toppings had very little flavor. Lacked seasoning. The mushrooms were cut too big and lacked any flavor. For a $50 pizza, we expected more.

Pizza was absolutely delicious, but maybe even more divine was the leadership. The manager here goes above and beyond to provide an amazing experience to diners. Highly, highly recommend this establishment and look forward to supporting again in the future. PS - thank you for the garlic knots! Dad and I will be back!

Ambiance: Safe, quaint location. Plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. Great for families. Service: everyone was pleasant and ordering is efficient with food coming out quick. Food: Pizza was great. I loved the sauce and ended up purchasing a few jars to go. The choices of appetizers and desserts were vast. We ordered the mozz sticks, breaded mushrooms and eggplant and all were delicious. Cannoli, ice cream and chocolate mousse were all great as well.Overall a great experience, pleasant staff that all seemed to work very good together and all with a smile and genuine greeting and thanks for visiting their restaurant.

Can't say enough about Pasquale's The Eggplant Parmesan is the best I've ever had!The bagels are really fresh. Homey atmosphere and friendly, cheerful staff who are interested in your dining experience!

We recently tried ordering pizza from Pasquale's and ended up having to make it edible at home. First problem is their online ordering system if you need change anything about the order it is nearly impossible to do. Half the pizza was missing cheese. The order was not ready and had to wait for it to be ready...but it was ready they had just misplaced it. Called the store after getting home they said it was "made correctly." Not going there again for poor service or poorly made pizza. Customer service...huge let down.

Visited yesterday and ordered a couple of slices of NY style pizza and meatball hoagie. Both were really poor quality. But first the location is convenient, the restaurant is clean and well lit with lots of room and the bathrooms were emasculate. The meatballs tasted like straw. Wife agreed. They were dry, poorly seasoned and just blah. The bread did not hold the sauce. The cheese was subpar and the sauce no better. The slices were bland. The cheese was largely tasteless, the sauce totally bland. The mozzarella sticks were fine but not sure they were made in-house because the sauce that accompanied the was very poor. So, something had to change. The flour, the cheese, the management, the chef? The pizza slices that were sold at their storefront in front of St Mary's were GREAT!