Old Town Bagels

Came Sat Dec 28th at 12:30pmAlways a good time when I go there. They have Amazing bagels.. Tremendous Coffee and Yumny sweet treats This time jst for some mint ice cream to settle stomach from eating somewhere else. But LOVE ur workers there always a friendly smiles and nods. Always fast service and such a Great place to spend an afternoon catching up w friends. And so close to Central park.. love this place

This place rocks! Kind staff, high quality bagels- I had the open face chicken bacon ranch and it was super good. Also the COLD BREW was top notch. Lots of seating. Local Newspapers. Family friendly! Good times!

Not much to delve in in this sleepy winters town. Everything is on its own schedule. Bagels are good but not as crispy on the outside as much as I would like. The first time is got a bagel was with smoked salmon and it was a different salmon, not the traditional NY smoked cured sliced salmon. But a chunk of salmon that has been smoked. Not what I was expecting. Still good.Only thing that stuck in my craw is that the people who work here aren't the most friendly. They seem overwhelmed, tired, and irritable. The bagels themselves are pretty good a bit on the soft side, not really crispy. The everything bagel which they call it "everything but the sink" IMO reeks too much of sesame seeds. Otherwise palatable soft, hearty, tasty. Good round bread.

Delicious bagels. Great flavor options. Ambiance is open and fun. However, check your order before you leave. I've learned this the hard way but today...I was victorious. I checked my 6 pack (6 sliced bagels plus cream cheese) to make sure they were actually sliced this time. (It's an upcharge). Alas, they were but no cream cheese in sight. I popped up to the counter and told the man I didn't get my cream cheese. I said I would've been mad if I had made it all the way home and noticed it. He replied, "Well, we wouldn't want that." So, prepare yourself for some snarky sarcasm and condescending witty banter. Enjoy!

As a Chicagoan & bagel fanatic - I'm always a little skeptical of small town bagel shops, but this place is the real deal!We stopped here since we were in town for a wedding and needed a hearty breakfast - plus it came highly recommended. The shop itself is larger than I thought from the outside, but gives the small-town homey vibes that you're looking for in a bagel & coffee joint. Important to note that it's also an ice cream shop serves Maggie Moo's. Even though it was a busy Saturday morning, the line went fast and they still has most things in stock. The woman working the register was efficient and kind. I started with a cold brew with almond milk and sugar-free vanilla syrup. I originally wanted to try the nitro butterscotch, but they ran out of nitro. However, I wasn't disappointed! This was some of the best cold brew coffee I've ever had - sweet and creamy without the weird artificial sugar free taste. If I lived here I would stop by every morning. The bagel sandwich was also top tier! The kitchen sink bagel was a delicious "everything" bagel - mine was a little heavy on the salt but I didn't mind. The garden veggie lite cream cheese was the perfect pairing with the egg, bacon and tomato. I almost never finish a bagel sandwich but I scarfed this down!Overall, wish this was closer to my home in the Twin Cities! Will definitely be back the morning after the wedding for a second round.

I stop here most mornings for breakfast, never disappointed. Wether its for a plain bagel with one of their multitudes of flavored cream cheese, or one of the variety of other flavored bagels, muffins, desserts, ice cream or sandwiches, this place has it all! Always friendly and helpful service. This is a busy place in the center of town for good reason. Everything is delicious and prices are fair.

I'm updating my review to point out the great job Old Town Bagels is providing great food and service during the Covid-19 outbreak, in a way that offers the least possible risk.Place your order online or call it in and you'll be given a time to arrive, The door will be open, so no need to touch it. You scan your own card and pick up the order marked with your name. The tables and chairs are pushed against the walls, so there is a large open area to maintain a distance from other customers.Even prior to the health scare this place has been part of my lunch routine, At least twice a week I stop in for take out soup, bagel sandwich, or both, Each morning they post their soup options on Instagram. The soup is always very good, There's a large variety of excellent bagels, One of my favorite sandwiches is the burrito bagel, or anything made on a kitchen sink bagel. This place is a lunchtime must,

Would be a great place to eat bagels if they actually served bagels all through their open hours. This is the second time that we have come to eat bagels and there weren't any bagels.

Food was good service was not good! Lady was hecka rude played black Jack while waiting and food filled me up so good but workers seemed like they hated working here

The best bagels with a good lunch selection. The blueberry crusted sugar bagel is one of the best.