Johnny's Pizza Shop

Pizzas, Calzones, Stromboli, Bread sticks, salads...Thus far I've had the pizza, Stromboli and calzone. Stromboli is my favorite, it has a good ratio of ingredients to dough combination. Equal amount of each in every bite. Ask for extra sauce if you try it.Pizza was also good, well topped with ingredients and a nice tasting dough.Update 4/9/14The last couple of times my strombolis have had a large end piece that was all dough (so much for my previous comment about ingredients in every bite). I also tried their Caesar salad...it would have tarred good if it had Caesar dressing on it. They must have forgotten to put it on the salad (it was dry!)I won't hold this against them unless it starts to become the norm.

I went there week ago and pizza slice was great. I went back on 5/12/22 at 730 pm and some you g kid was locking the door and wasn't very nice I won't go back again who closes restaurants at 730

Stopped here because the line was too long at Burger King! This gem is so much better than a fast food option at this travel stop. So drive by the fast food spots and go to the plaza by dogtopia and grab some great local pizza, bread sticks, salad and Stromboli's. This will be our go to stop in this area when traveling :)

Used go frequently. The they stopped curbside pick up and they don't wear masks. Doubt I will go back!

Pizza was cold and terrible. Not very friendly staff. The pizza had been sitting there for a very long time. The cheese was hard. They take the slice and try to warm it back up. This only works if the pizza is somewhat fresh. This one wasn't. I took it out to the car and threw it away. We will never go back.

If I could leave zero stars I would. This place is a DISASTER!! A serious, serious health violation is at large. I went to grab a bite to eat with a few friends and when we got home, we all noticed a disgusting smell on our clothes and in our hair. Something is not right in that place, DO NOT GO!!

Not always open got coupons and every time I try to order they're not open. I think it might just be the weekends though. I did call once and was told there were always open so not sure what's happening.

Stopped in for pizza by the slice, will be back. Delicious crust, light sauce and plenty of options. Will be back!

So after having eaten here a few times I have decided to update my rating. It's one of the best NY style pizza in the area and while their slice prices are a little high, get a whole pie and enjoy. If you do their 1 topping large pie, it's only $15. I highly recommend it for anyone from NY/NJ that miss good pizza. It definitely hits the spot

GO HERE IF YOU ARE LOOKING FOR A DELICIOUS AND LOW PRICE MEAL! I can't even begin to explain how much I love this pizza shop. Staff is always so friendly, and food is delicious. It has that "mom and pop" vibe inside and feels like a hallmark movie. The lunch combos are to die for! The pizza is so delectable and the breadsticks are some of my top favorites of all time!