Jimmy's Pizza

From the outside, Jimmy's isn't much to look at, but it's what is made inside that counts. The workers were friendly. The pizza was a thin crust akin to Carbone's. Almost as good as Carbone's, but not quite. The crackery like crust was good and kept its crisp, but was just a bit off. The sauce and toppings were excellent. This is great "lake" pizza. Order some for the lake, baked or unbaked. The kids will like them. It was very busy on Friday night. They had four people making pizza and at least 10 pizzas on the rack waiting to be baked.

We love Jimmy's Pizza and usually order from them at least twice a month. We change it up between the hand tossed or the original (thin) crust. Our pizza is always excellent. We also get a side of cheese bread with our pizza. 9/10 it is perfect. But we have gotten it couple times where there was not a lot of cheese or over cooked. We still ate it though. Their boxes have a tear away that if you collect 10 you get a free order of cheese sticks. They offer delivery or take out. Delivery time can sometimes be up to two hours. We typically just pick ours up. They are the only pizza delivery place in Annandale so they are busy basically always.Support small businesses!

Actually super good and well made despite being in such a small town. Be aware though that the area near it is a speed trap for lil baby cops.

The pizza was ok. It's good if your drunk and really hungry.They said that they wouldn't deliver to our location but we saw one of their cars with the name of the shop slapped on top drive past our cabin.

I called for a delivery to my house. I ordered one pizza. They said they wouldn't deliver to me even though they delivered it to me multiple times before. They said I was too far. I said OK then I'm going to make it a pick up they said sounds good see you in 15 minutes. I sent my mom to pick it up for me because my vehicles out of commission. My mom gets there and asks for my pizza and they say it's on its way in delivery. My mom then tells them that " my daughter just got off the phone with me she said you guys wouldn't deliver it that is why I'm here." So then they had to turn around and bring the pizza back to my mom. She said they were all just sitting there on the tables fiddling with their thumbs and it looked like a middle school lunchroom. I do not recommend this place I really wish there was a manager there. I'm quite nervous to be honest. Because I have a gluten allergy and I asked for the gluten-free crust and I'm scared they don't know where it was and they just ignored it. Because they're all new.

we have typically had good service. we ordered $72 worth of Pizzas for pickup and they made a mistake on one of them. When I called the store and asked them to deliver the pizza they didn't get right, they refused. No apology, just said they could give me a refund or I could drive back and get a new one. the pizza that was wrong was a glueten free pizza. they continued to tell me the difference between a glueten free and regular pizza was "obvious ". I couldn't tell so I asked if I could text a picture, only to be told, "we don't give out employees cell numbers. awesome. Thanks

When my family and I took a weekend trip to South Haven, we ordered from Jimmy's. Ordering on the Slice app was easy, and delivery was pretty quick. I got a large 2-topping stuffed crust, a small margherita, an apple dessert pizza (which was the surprise hit of the meal), and some chicken wings on the side. In total, it was a bit more expensive than I would have expected, because it is more or less a bar style pizza, but the flavors were good and we were all satisfied! While we did keep it easy, we were definitely tempted to try out some of the more out-there flavors, so if we're ever back in the area we'll be sure to do that next time! For a weekend trip, we were happy to try out the small local business and overall it was happy smiles and full stomachs all around!

Best thin crust and cheesy bread I've had in a long time!! Great customer service! Ready in 10 minutes!

Amazing Pizza!! And we eat a lot of pizza. Everyone in the family loved it and they have great specials.

Typical middle of the road pizza. When you leave chicago, you get middle of the road pizza. Wisconsin, Minnesota, Florida, etc. I specifically said to cook the pizza well done...and it arrives like every middle of the road, away from chicago pizza....under cooked. Took an hour and a half to deliver on a summer Tuesday night