Italian Pie Shoppe
Italian Pie Shoppe
Cheese on cheese! Grilled cheese and tots with beer cheese!
Bacon Cheeseburger
Buffalo chicken salad split in two...
Pizza and drinks
Grilled cheese basket!
Bacon Cheeseburger
Small Deep Dish Meat Lover's Pizza
Hawaiian pizza
Thin crust Special 6... Yum!
outside
Andre H.
Jun 17, 2023
Ordered a pie to go late at night. It was pretty decent. Nothing to rave about but I'll be back to try more.
Read More
Hannah G.
May 24, 2022
We tried the Italian Pie Shoppe for the first time on Saturday night. Calling in to place our to-go order was quick and easy. Pizza was ready in 20 minutes, and our thin crust Hawaiian pizza was hot and delicious when we got it home! Overall, a good local spot that we would order from again.
Read More
Kim K.
Apr 10, 2023
Best tots and beer cheese! Grilled cheese with cheese on cheese! Everything and everyone here is amazing!
Read More
Dennis A.
Mar 3, 2023
A lot of people like this pizza spot, as evidenced by many favorable reviews. But I have to say, I was disappointed when I tried the thin crust at the New Hope location today. The crust was blah and chewy, tough. The sauce tasted like canned tomato sauce. Ordered mine with ground beef, mushrooms and black olives. The meat was really just hamburger crumbles. The mushrooms tasted like canned mushrooms. The black olives were, well, black olives like you'd expect -- but skimpy. They do have a bare bones dining area and the advantage of being collocated with a bowling alley, which is a nice combination, but with so many pizza options out there I won't be back.
Read More
Jim M.
Jan 12, 2022
I believe that this is the most meat I have ever seen on a pizza!!! This is too much pizza for just one person to eat!! The sauce has an extra "zing" to it that lifts this pizza above the rest! This is a special secret in the Northwest suburbs@
Read More
Troy B.
Jun 7, 2022
I have had their food a few times in the past year especially after getting home from work. Nothing beats biting into a few slices of pizza, especially after a hard day of work. What I like is seeing the colorful array of toppings on pizza. Not only that, but it tastes just as good. Biting into piping slice of pizza is a real treat, especially since it was made from scratch, using what seems to be fresh ingredients. It does not matter whether it was a veggie pizza or bbq chicken. It doesn't matter whether it was deep dish or thin crust the crust always seems to have depth it it. I would like to go back there, as they have a variety of options like salads, sandwiches, and even fries.
Read More
Joshua K.
Apr 12, 2022
Food is delicious, some of the best pizza, burgers, and chicken strips in town. Good always comes out fresh and timely! I would recommend for sure!
Read More
Phoebe E.
May 1, 2019
A few times recently when I mention that we live in New Hope, friends and strangers alike ask if I've tried the Italian Pie Shoppe. I don't know why we waited so long! Don't let the bowling alley location fool you. This is a Ma and Pop, old fashion pizza shop with checkered floors, ice cream by the scoop, and fantastic pizza! No, it's not fancy, but it isn't meant to be... It's attached to a bowling alley, after all! We ordered a thin crust Special 6 to-go and it didn't disappoint. Lots of cheese but not greasy, just the right amount of toppings, and the sauce had a little zip. Yum! We'll definitely be back. I can't believe this place doesn't have more reviews! Hidden gem, for sure.
Read More
Cathryn K.
Feb 26, 2024
Bought a 6 inch sausage pizza requesting extra cheese. It was over cooked and had no extra cheese. The crust was like eating a piece of cardboard. The crust was burnt with the little cheese on it burnt as well. Never been disappointed with any food orders before so this one was a real letdown.
Read More
