Creekside Supper Club & Lounge

Like to start off by letting my waiter MJ know you rock & added me on IG yo_grlkei if you ever make over to Okinawa look for Annie Bell's soul food & bar truck your first meal & drink are on the house! The food was absolutely amazing! We ordered the prime rib dinner and chicken cordon bleu, along with delicious popovers. For drinks, we had the Part-Time Lover cocktail and Castle Danger Cream Ale--both excellent choices. We finished the meal with a perfectly executed vanilla crème brûlée. Every bite was outstanding--easily a 10/10 dining experience!

My partner chose this place for dinner last weekend. We enjoy trying new places, and never heard anything about this place. The entrance and area was decorated cute and all, but what hit me in the face like a ton of bricks was the musty smell - like a damp basement. The few hosts were very welcoming and pleasant and brought us to our table. Nothing really too positive to say about our server. He was very impersonal and seemed put off at our questions on the menu. I overheard him waiting on surrounding tables and he seemed eager to answer other tables questions. He did check in once on how the food was at least. We ordered an old fashioned and non alcoholic punch and paired it with the chicken sandwich and a double Rodeo burger. We split our sandwiches to try both. The chicken sandwich must have had a brine. It was pretty tasty. Wasn't a fan of the burger. I actually had a few bites and didn't finish it. I don't think I haven't ever finished a burger. For two drinks (1 alcoholic and one non alcoholic) and two sandwich meals it was about $70 before tip. Overall I wasn't impressed and think it is overpriced.

Atmosphere and service were excellent. They were decorated for valentines day. However I thought the food was average at best. We had a 8:00 pm reservation which I do not recommend taking this time or any later as we were told the kitchen closes at 9:00 pm. We went to enjoy our night out but felt rushed.Started with the French onion soup which was extremely thick but the flavor was good. Then had prime rib and my wife had the wedge burger which was over salty even for my taste and the prime rib was ok but you could tell we were at the end of the night.Don't think we will go back as I was expecting a different supper club experience.

Love the vintage supper club vibes-this is a relatively newer restaurant but it looks like it's been around for ages. We went for a Valentines pop up, and loved the decor. Service was prompt, and the food was definitely solid. Love that they gave us a relish plate and absolutely love the cocktail sauce that came with the shrimp (don't skip it!) we didn't try the cocktails but they looked pretty.

Very nice spot I'd recommend. Took the ol lady out a week before Valentine's Day so the decor was decked out as you see in the photos. Crab stuffed walleye 5/5. Salmon 5/5. Had better potatoes elsewhere but the main dish was so tasty I can look past that. Service was excellent. Definitely an experience I will not forget. Thanks for having me out

Came here for the holiday pop up. Our server was the best! The cheese curds were amazing, I ate maybe the whole basket-- & I'm lactose intolerant! The cocktails were great & creative. Great stop for a spontaneous girls night out. Christmas ambiance was perf

One almost perfect experience. Great vibe. Someone asked me what makes it a Supper Club?! The pine paneling? The pickles and beets served? The fancy customer of the eat staff?Drinks were great. Popovers excellent...and $2 for HH! Great service. Food was served hot. Burger was excelled!Ice cream drinks were too much.

Fun fancy traditional supper club! Service was lovely, so was the ambiance. It is so thoughtfully decorated and takes you back in time to a swanky WI dining experience. The menu was hard to pick from. Our table got cheese curds to share- a classic must. The fish fry was perfection as were the short ribs. Street parking available!

First time at Creekside- went to see the holiday decorations. Very cool traditional supper club look with the wood panel walls and the holiday decorations made it a really cool experience. Started with the popovers and they were really good. We both ordered steaks and they were both cooked a perfect medium rare. The au gratin was a little disappointing and didn't have much flavor which is why I brought it down from 5. It was very busy but our waiter was great and food came out relatively quickly.

Some friends and I came here for our annual Christmas get together/gift exchange. This was definitely the place to do it as it was decked out in Christmas decor. I wouldn't say it's a "hip" place (or whatever the kids say). It's mostly families and older folks (like me I guess....crap). Our server was great. Very attentive but not overly. I got the fish and chips which was decent. I honestly can't say if I'd ever come back but I'm glad I tried it.