Carmelo's

I typically don't like to knock restaurants based on service (a food-only critique is optimal), but the service here was unsatisfactory. There was only one server (I could hear her to other tables that the manager was on vacation as the reason they were short staffed). Nearly the whole restaurant was waiting for long, and I honestly tip my hat to the server because she held her cool in the midst of every single person in the joint being dissatisfied.Otherwise, it was overpriced generic pasta.I wish I would have ordered the ravioli, then I could have tried their fresh pasta and perhaps had a better experience.

The best restaurant in St Paul by far. Great atmosphere, fantastic food. The stuffed steaks are the bomb. A real hidden gem.

Lovely traditional Italian restaurant in St Paul. We had Arancini, salads, fresh baked bread, Spaghetti and Meatballs, and Sundried Tomato Pesto pasta. The dining room is nice and cozy. Service was friendly and attentive. We had reservations at 5pm and the restaurant filled up quickly and stayed full the entire time we were there.

I am always looking for a great serving of carbonara and have wandered all over the Twin Cities seeking it. Imagine my joy and chagrin to find it nearly in my own neighborhood! I called for my take away order because the website wouldn't let me order through it but the person on the phone was very polite and professional. They bring the food out the back into a small lot off the alley. There's a spot reserved for their pick ups. It was that simple. It came to with a nice little side salad I hadn't expected but did enjoy. The carbonara serving was abundant. Even though I'm trying to gain weight, it turned out to be two servings for me. I'm delighted with the whole process and the meal. I will glean the menu and see what I want next.

dinnerLive in Highland decided to take grand daughter to dinner for birthday . The jazz overhead was Tony Bennett all the way to Frank and Billie Holiday. Decor was lovely calming...owner was very pleasant and even sent me home with some homemade bread....it was really a nice night.. but Carmelo's food took the starring role. All homemade.. great service. We had Bruschetta made like the real deal...half my plate was fabulous chicken and capers. My Grand daughter's eyes widened at the size and taste of meatball and spaghetti and a side of spaghetti served with every entree.Caesar salad perfect...this one you don't want to miss. Had to go back with friends again this week. They loved the food , the service.... Just a perfect night to eat and catch up. I wish I had found this restaurant sooner. I'll be back again.It looks like they did a redecorating project recently! It's small and cozy so be sure to make a reservation!

Oh my! My husband and I went to Carmelo's last night for the first time. Shelly was our waitress and was so friendly and engaging- and the food- well, we felt like we were in Italy all over again! It's absolutely amazing. Hand made pasta and ravioli, along with the most fresh bruschetta I've ever had along with delectable salads and bread. We've lived in Highland Park 6 years and this was a huge miss on our part! Don't ignore! Go and enjoy! You won't be sorry!

Excellent food! Great service! Ambience is rather relaxing. I had the Carmelo Chicken dish which was rich, well balanced and best of all delicious. My party had chicken parm, one of the steak dishes and artichoke pasta. We all tried out dishes and we all agree that this is one of the few delicious Italian restaurants in the area. I liked the fact that their menu has elements from all parts of Italy. Regional cuisine is very unique and they beautifully replicate the food palette of Italy. Make reservations not a walk in place. Service is helpful, kind and quick!

This is my wife and mines go to spot for going out with family and date nights. The food is always hot, service always excellent and soooo delicious! It's an amazing cozy atmosphere to enjoy! Def make reservations, be a courteous patron and try different dishes to find your fave (mines the Shrimp Macalester!).

An absolute GEM in St. Paul!!I've lived in St. Paul my entire life and I can't honestly say there is a better Italian restaurant within the city limits.The ambiance is perfect, service is amazing and the food is definitely something to brag about!!

FANTASTIC Find, took friend to dinner - new place to both of us...and we both agree Best Italian foods we've had in years! Service Great and SO realistically priced..Quaint, old style comfortable place - True GEM!