Newcastle Pizzeria

My favorite spot to eat Pizza! Family owned and operated, awesome service and great atmosphere. The place is always busy. This tells you they are doing something right. We have gone several times and the food is consistent and always tastes amazing.

Peach salad was fantastic but I would request it be lightly dressed Meatballs were good. My husband liked them more than me. Pizza was ok and I would skip chicken wings if you want any crisp exterior.

Love having such a great neighborhood spot nearby. The BEST pizza, service, beer selection, and all around great vibes. Can't wait to go back next week!

Don't leave many reviews, but this place deserves one! We stopped in on Valentines day (I even got a rose) and I absolutely recommend this place, you're missing out if you don't go! We ordered two pepperoni pizzas, one Newcastle Firefighters Favorite, Jeans Chee-zee garlic bread and half order of wings. Everything was fantastic as was the service. We will definitely be back when we pass through the area again.

Great crust, wood fire oven. Quality ingredients. We have never been disappointed going here. Best pizza in the area hands down.

Stopped randomly on our way home from Nevada to Bay Area. Reviews were solid so I was looking forward to trying it, plus it was my birthday. Inside was packed so we sat outside on the cute patio. Service was efficient. Food was ok., beer selection terrific. The Beet Salad looked good but dressing was a little bitter. Pizzas were good, crust was thin and toppings made it a bit soggy. Still tasted good.

Pizza was delicious!!! We ordered half and half. Waitress was working by herself I think and she was doing a great job. Would definitely go back.

One of the local favs serving up some amazing wood fire pizza. Friendly staff and a must have

I made a Yelp account just so I could applaud my experience at Newcastle Pizzeria. Great food and service! Although he wasn't our server - I couldn't help but smile listening as Truman, one of the servers, worked and interacted with other tables. He has such a charismatic personality and great service, we couldn't help but notice him going above and beyond to assist tables and how he would interact and cater to younger ones. 10/10

Good pizza- only 1 size but very tasty. There are several options. Very quaint little place in downtown Newcastle. I know there's also pasta and other menu items but I always go for the pizza. Beer & wine available also I believe.