I Love Pie Bakeshop

Found this pie shop via Yelp, located inside the Milagro Centre on Fair Oaks in Carmichael. It's located past the gelato stand. Did not order ahead, and took a chance walking in a few days after the Thanksgiving holiday to pick up a pie or two for Friendsgiving dinner. Seems like a one-woman run business, and for a Saturday afternoon there were still some good selections in the display case available for purchase and not already spoken for (smaller 6-inch and larger 8-inch pies), including apple (I forget if it was classic or salted caramel dutch), bourbon pecan, chocolate cream, and banana cream. Other seasonal flavors are pumpkin, sweet potato, eggnog custard, and red velvet chess. I got one 8-inch banana cream and one 8-inch chocolate cream ($28 each). The crust is all-butter, and the heart-shaped decorations on each pie are cute and very fitting of the bakeshop's name. Between the two, the banana cream pie was by far the favorite. The chocolate cream was also very good. I'm curious to try their fruit pies and other offerings (chicken pot pie, hand pies, pie pops) in the future!

Yummy! Thick, buttery crusts, the perfect mint of sweetness, and fresh ingredients make this bakeshop so fantastic.We tried pumpkin, apple, pecan, and custard and everyone loved the apple most! It's different from the usual, with syrupy sweet apple filling.I second another persons review that the crust could be baked just a few minutes less, so it has a softer, pure butter flavor rather than a hint of burn to it. But the texture is perfect as is.I'd definitely return and try all their other flavors.

We stopped by and decided to try their pies, including the key lime pie. First off, the pies are absolutely adorable--they're almost too cute to eat! The key lime pie was delicious and had that tangy citrus flavor you'd expect, but we did find it to be on the sweeter side, which might not be for everyone. If you love desserts that lean toward extra sweet, this will probably hit the spot perfectly.Overall, it's a charming little spot with tasty treats. While we wish the sweetness was a bit more balanced, it's still worth a visit for the presentation and flavors. Would love to come back and try other options next time!

My wife was hankering for sweets. He had these guys before but at the old location. The new location is the easiest to find but it's tucked inside next to the ice cream place. But that whole complex is an awesome video. Restaurants and dessert/coffee options.I got there pretty late so there wasn't a huge selection, but that's on me. They had multiple types of apple pie - Dutch, Carmel, crumble. We went with banana cream. It was exactly what we needed. Perfect creamy but not overly sweet. Plus a super flakey crust. We will be back!

I love the banana cream pie here but the last few times we got it either the crust was burnt so it gave a slightly bitter taste or there was more whip cream than filling. Unfortunately this week we got the combo of both burnt crust and barely there banana cream. If I'm going to pay almost $30 for a pie, I don't want a burnt crust and barely there banana cream filling. Hopefully they'll do better quality control checks on these pies. I hate that I still love them though!

The crust one theses pies are perfect! I hate when pie crust gets soggy and these don't get old and gross even after they are cut.

Absolutely love this place! If you're looking for a pie shop with delicious pies and a huge variety to choose from, this is the place! I drive all the way from Elk Grove to get my hands on these pies. Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, and Salted Caramel Dutch Apple are a few of our favorites.

I have been coming to I LOVE PIE for years! I've had many pies, cookies, hand pies and special pies. I will not go anywhere else! Chocolate cream and banana cream are superior here. The even balance of flavor and not overwhelming in one flavor. The whip cream piping is just beautiful and perfect amount! The owner and workers are so kind and caring if you have an allergy they listen right away. I've turned friends and family to I love pie. Plus they do too good to go!!! Thank you for the best pies I've had!

Drove over 1/2 hour from Roseville, was totally disappointed. Cute name, but that's about it.. Because I really love pies. Super difficult to find within the shopping center. Walked up to the shop a minuscule selection, probably only 7 or 8 pies. With limited choices, decided on a chocolate crust berry pie which I'd never heard of before asked if we could sit in one of the seats over with a cute little table, and workers behind the counter said no. Even if we went to the common area with tables, they couldn't even provide us with forks. Went to the gelato place 5 stars amazing. Take the pie home and could not consume as the chocolate crusted barry was not very delicious. Sorry about that guys. Can't imagine anyone giving this pie location 5 stars? Thank you.

We drove from Roseville with high expectation. They did not have a variety of choices. We ordered the strawberry pie. It was expensive.They had a sitting area but we were told, that we could sit at that area. We were so disappointed with the chocolate crust strawberry pie. The crust was hard and the strawberry was not fresh. No comparison to Marie Callender strawberry pie and Rick's Dessert Sacramento.