New York Pizzaria

Great pizza, great toppings, great pizza place. I'd highly recommend you try their pizza!

We had this delivered for dinner. Large pepperoni pizza with an order of potato wedges and an order of wings. They gave us a ton of ranch which was the best because some places are stingy. The food was delicious! I am sometimes picky on pizza but this was so good. I only wish the slices were bigger so that you could fold the pizza when dipping and eating it. The potato wedges and wings were good as well! I was worried the wings would be too hot but they weren't - I felt it was perfect. I would absolutely order from here again!! Yum!

Consistently the best pizza in the area! The crust is especially superior to any other pizza purveyor in town. Don't waste your time ordering from a chain. There is a time and a place for some of the other places in Redlands, but for delicious pizza, friendly ownership, and consistently delicious food and good service from a family owned small business, this is the place every single time.

New York Pizzaria is predominately a takeout place, but still has quick service. Since they are located on the street side of the building, parking on the street is the most efficient, but there is parking in the rear. You can see inside pics, but keep in mind it's a place. You can see my pic of the menu and see the limited selection, yet it has a diverse representation of Italian food. Also note that cash is welcomed here - there is a 3.75% surcharge for non-cash payments.We were offered water, and you can see what we received. Nowhere else in town does one get their own pitcher of water - great for us! We started with the antipasto salad - it was straight-forward. It had all the main ingredients, see pic. The Italian salad dressing was okay. The greens were fresh. The processed meats and artichoke heart were somewhat bland.We split a 4 slice (individual) pepperoni and sausage pizza. It has a thin crust, which holds up quite well. The exposed crust around the edge was quite flavorful and crunchy without being over cooked. The sauce was tangy and rich. The pepperoni and sausage were a bit flavorless.

Pepperoni pizza was delicious Mozzarella sticks were ok and the salad had too much mushroom not enough lettuce Service was fast! I wish they had music playing or something it was way too quiet but besides that this place is worth a try!! PS we just placed our mozz sticks next to the pizza

My husband and I are on a mission to find our favorite pizza place in Redlands and decided to try this place since we always see it when we get a sandwich from Saverinos. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza which was around $18 and a calzone to go. Not worth the price and the pizza reminded me of a lunchable pizza flavor. My husband said he felt like he can taste what their fridge smells like and it ruined it for him. The calzone was okay. Definitely not like NY pizza and neither of us liked it so we won't be going back but at least we got to try it. Uncle Howies is still our #1 pizza place in Redlands but we still have a few more places to try.

We had a ham and cheese calzone and a sausage, pepperoni and cheese calzone both were delicious

I ordered takeout from here through Grubhub. It arrived quickly and hot. The potatoes were packaged well so they stayed hot. This pizza was thin and delicious! The sauce was great and the cook on the pizza was just right. I'll definitely order again!

I'm from the OC and originally from Chicago and know what an authentic deep dish pizza should taste like! The deep dish pizza was like eating some semi ok toppings (tasteless) on very very dry bread for $45!! We literally threw it away This owner should go to Tony's Little Italy in Placentia and taste a real deep dish pizza and then do all he can to duplicate it.I'll never order from here again unless he does. Most of the restaurants in Banning/Beaumont area are not worth going to. That's why everyone that lives here goes to PS or Redlands to dine out. Take my advice...go to Tony's...change your pizza and watch the crowds appear. You COULD become the ONLY good pizza place in town!

Small mom & pop place. Ordered the 14 inch sausage, peppers & pineapple. The pizza was very good!! Will definitely return.