delicious sando on display
breakfast slice
Bigger beer selection than most pizza places
meatballs
caesar
sandwich is packed
Pepperoni for the road! Yum!
Small Caesar $7.50 Nov-23 Mmm Kale Caesar very tender, citrus vinegary vs biting garlic, delish crunchy bcrumbs, doused in Parm!
By the slice
The cookie was yum!
Cookie, Blood Orange Soda, Pepperoni, and Baller Slices.
Ceasar Salaf
Cookie and hand help pies
bagels, outside
KEVIN PEPPERONI (tomato sauce, pepperoni, mozz-provolone, grana, & Sicilian oregano)
Slice of Hot Tony and pepperoni with a Portland Cider English dry.
menu
The connecting bar (Bandit Bar) is so cute! Loved it.
Mushroom pizza
Such a great staff and walk up counter displaying all the delicious foods.
Bandit Bar adjoins Pizza Thief Opens 3pm Full Bar but they pull pints here all hours and you can dine in space before 3pm.
Hannah T.
Nov 2, 2024
Too good, forgot pictures.Got the slices of the: seasonal pie (delicata squash, pickled peppers, goat cheese, rosemary), seasonal foccacia (bomba sauce eggplant feta), hot tony and plain. Insanely delicious. Also got a thumbprint cookie and cannoli which we have yet to try. Unreal, can't believe how long I slept on this place.Update: I'd give the cannoli a miss but HOLY SH*T THE THUMBPRINT COOKIE. A sleeper hit don't skip.
Read More
Tsyria T.
Oct 31, 2024
Came here a few times for a slice of pizza and it did not disappoint! Went around lunch and there was quite a line! Slices are pretty large as well. They have a few sandwiches which I hope to try when I'm no longer pregnant too (due to the deli meats)There is plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. Order at counter and it seems like there's a mix of service - some people had numbers for table service, but we had our order called out by name. Not quite sure what the difference is; maybe it's in what you order?I enjoy the theme of Pizza Thief too! Cute interior. There is also a bar attached. Self service take out containers available as well. Clean up after yourself. Located in NW! Parking is a little challenging - street parking for the most part.
Read More
Cesar D.
Oct 27, 2024
During a work trip to the NW Montgomery Park area, found a great pizza spot. Pizza Thief, as you walk into the building you are greeted by a very friend staff. The interior is very causal and inviting, there is an attached walk way to an attached bar. To place your order, you line up and then queue to the main counter, to your left they have a large display case of the various pizza types, you can order them by slice or a whole pie. The menu board is easy to read, you really need to try the various dipping sauces, they have a small charge for them, my favorite the Ranch is amazing, enjoy the others. I ordered the Kevin Pepperoni slice, I really love the small Pepperoni, its a nice large slice of pizza, it takes a few min to heat up your pizza, they will call your name once its ready. They offer a variety of drinks both alcoholic and regular drinks. The pizza was amazing, very flavorful, cheesy and a nice crust, again the dipping sauces are a must. If you enjoy the outdoors, they have a nice covered area with bench style seating. It was very clean, bright and inviting business. I cannot wait to visit again.
Read More
John H.
Sep 6, 2024
This place connects to a bar and has plenty of seating. They have slices and an interesting menu. I saw a few sandwiches and desserts I would go back for. If you stop in around dinner time, expect a wait - even for one slice, which was all I wanted. It's "short order service" with one line to order at one register, so if a family of 6 has a big order ahead of you - it adds some time. Many options for slices, even vegan. I got the "hot tony" which lives up to its name. The toppings felt scarce for $6.50, especially for such a small slice. While tasty, it left more to be desired. I paid $4.50 for a small, glass coke - which might be the most I've paid anywhere in town for that size. I'll say the staff seemed nice, and they had a lot of people. The food seemed quality, but this is not your spot for a cheap slice.
Read More
Jennifer C.
Oct 22, 2024
Order pizza by the slice or a whole pie (though not all pizzas are available by the slice). Kevin's Pepperoni and hot Tony were basic but good. The special with the squash was really tasty and had a small kick of heat from the peppers. Crust was really good all around. Cannoli was 3/5, nothing remarkable. Small spot with limited seating but more seating outside in covered area with heaters.
Read More
Michael G.
Nov 18, 2023
How totally Portland! good thing it is up by Montgomery Park and out of the bad zone of downtown Portland. We loved being outside on a nice day. The pizza is wonderful, very tasty without the heartburn after effect. The staff is wonderfully helpful. You have an option of eating inside, or going outside. They were set up for a birthday party inside which takes up most of the seating. you can go into the bar next to it as well.
Read More
Morgan H.
Dec 16, 2023
Stopped here for a slice before going out and was not disappointed. Good price for a large slice, and exactly the kind of decadent greasy pizza you want. Was hard to choose a flavor they had so many good ones. Service was quick too.We sat outside, which was great for people watching, and it is dog friendly.
Read More
Katey M.
Oct 17, 2024
I've been several times and their pizza is excellent. I've tried the Wildwood, Sausage and Onion and The Meat Sweats. Next time I go I'm going to try their Kale Caesar Salad. Has outdoor seating.
Read More
Nithisha R.
May 25, 2024
I have been visiting this place with friends for sometime now. They always have seasonal menu. Their vegetarian pizza with kale is one of the best pizzas I ever had. Thin crust, with authentic kale flavor, marinara, and little cheese: the best pizza out there. Drinks are amazing here. I tried all their citrus drinks and some of my favorites being daisy go, two in the pink, crazy from the heat. Their salads are amazing. I am not a salad person, however, if it's from pizza thief, I could eat them any-day,anytime. Market salad, caesar salad are my favorite one's. Service is good, and a little bit slow and not properly organized maybe because this place is always crowded. Ambiance is really good with the happening bandit bar and food on the other side of bar. Overall, amazing place with best pizza's and drinks. The only reason for reducing one star is because of their menu which doesn't change often and it's the standard menu which is not elaborate and only has limited items.
Read More
Lauren N.
May 8, 2024
Was surprised when I went to Great Notion NW location, as they now have Pizza Thief making their food (instead of previously Great notion). You order at a kiosk and less than 15 minutes later your food comes to your table. They have several salads, appetizers, multiples types of Detroit-style pizza, and sandwiches. We ordered the cheese bread which was delicious and so cheesy. The Kale cesar salad was on-point! Large in size to share with the table. We ordered two pizzas. They come out and appear small but the pizza is so thick, there is a significant amount of food in that small pizza. The people were really nice and friendly, great place all around will come again!
Read More