Tomatoes II Pizzeria

Awesome little pizza place in Carnegie. We recently moved out of the city and it's hard to find a good pizza place and honestly Tomatoes II might be one of my favorites now. We usually get the White Pizza, hot pepper cheese balls, and another app (varies). I think the White Pizza is amazing! The flavors you get when biting into the first slice are out of this world! I would take this pizza over any other any day. I normally order on Yelp because it's easier. Our first time ordering on Yelp took a very very long time. I had to reach out to Yelp after an hour to figure out where our food was and the owner called me and apologized and our food showed up shortly after. No real issues but they're not far from us so I didn't expect it to take as long as it did.I would recommend this place to anyone looking for something different to try. I say get one of the gourmet pizzas because you can get a cheese & pepperoni pizza anywhere. Great little find for us!

This place is under new management. I love their thin crust pepperoni pizza. It is totally delicious the sauce tastes amazing it has a bite of a kick to it. Great blend of cheeses makes it taste fantastic. This my new favorite place to get pepperoni pizza. Best in Pittsburgh. My wife and kids love the pizza as well!!! I've been here 4 days out of 7 just for the pizza yummy

Sorry but this place is a huge disappointment. I don't know why they show those pepperoni puffs on their main page, because that is NOT what you get. They are ok, but just plain, dry dough balls with cheese and pepperoni in them, not covered in cheese and parsley as shown at all. They also come with a very small container of horrible sauce that tastes like old ketchup. I also got a steak hoagie, that had two very dry pieces of what tasted like an old steak-um covered in some spicy seasoning that tasted very old and bitter. The French fries tasted very greasy and old also. The front door of this place had its glass broken and replaced by a large piece of plywood, that should have been a sign to stay away!

With all the pizza options, it was hard to decide where to get delivery. But I came across this one and I just had to try it because of the good reviews. We ordered a combo of pizza with one topping, wings (Asian zing flavor and a 2 litter soda. I was pleasantly surprised that it had more wings than I had expected. The pizza was good but I wasn't a big fan of the amount of cheese, it was a bit too much with the flavor. We really liked the wings! They were big and crispy with a good amount of sauce. Give this place a try, you might be pleasantly surprised!

Ordered via Eat24 for pick-up and found that our pizza was on time and still looked fresh out of the oven.We went for the chicken and spinach which also came with thinly sliced tomatoes and bacon. We also subbed white sauce since it seemed more apt for these toppings...Great choice! Toppings weren't very heavy handed but we still found the flavors spot on. In regards to service, we found the staff to be very friendly when we walked in. When we asked for a few plates, the lady behind the counter neatly bagged us a few heavy duty plates and napkins. I actually only expected a few paper plates to be handed to me.The only thing that could have been better was if the crust was just a bit more crisp.

I get takeout from Tomatoes II all the time. The crust is on the softer side and is quite yummy. I usually get medium size pizza to avoid a case of the droopies (is that a word - spell check say "no"). I just don't like droopy pizza.My go-to favorites are the meat and taco. The meat pizza is as you would expect, a carnivore's dream. The taco pizza is topped with taco meat, cheddar cheese, followed by crushed tortilla chips, fresh lettuce, and tomato. The chips provide a texture change which I really like.Small Pizza base price is under $10 so you can get a really good pizza at a great price. Delivery is fast if you are in the area.

Pizza was horrible! Sauce seemed liked jar NO FLAVOR & the cheese MADE ME ILL - I now see they use Italian cheeses so the pizza smelled like feet and flavor again was bland Pasta Carbonara - pasta was cooked to perfection -AL DENTA! Lovely - sauce was thin and bland Wish I had better to report Ordered online quick and easy with text message updates on timeframe of delivery and they were right on time

Ordered a Sicilian pizza and a meatball hoagie. Both were abysmal. Sicilian was essentially a flatbread with little to no cheese or toppings. Meatball hoagie was all bun with 3 (HALF) meatballs with little to no sauce. Strongly recommend against this establishment

Their chicken bacon ranch is amazing. Closest place for pick up and would be worth it at double the distance.

Typical, average Pittsburgh Pizzeria. it amazes me how so many average pizzerias are in and around Carnegie are able to stay in business. So pick what's good. The wings are A+, pizza in general a B, salads B, sandwiches range from B to D. Lets start with the bad, steak & cheese and anything chicken hold a solid D to the meatball which is a B. Can someone tell me where to get a good steak and cheese please! I wish I could post a pic of my latest S&cheese from here, dried up steak with a slice of provolone on an over cooked roll. Not exactly the Philly style S&C I was hoping for.