The Best "Real Pizza" in the Youngstown area !
a menu for a restaurant
This is the plain pizza... It comes with lots of cheese and green peppers without having ordered a topping.
Wing Dings! Who else says wing dings!? Hahaha
April 2016 75th anniversary menu specials
Pizza with pepperoni, sausage & the green peppers that comes automatically with every Elmton pizza. Taken on my August, 2015 visit.
Menu Spring 2017
people sitting at a bar
a menu for a pizza restaurant
a menu for a pizza restaurant
Elmton bar area
Elmton pizza in struthers ohio. had not eaten here in a year. This Crust is crispy, perfect amount sauce and cheese.
8 Inch White Pizza with Pepperoni and Mushroom
The Broasted fish, size of the plate. Hot!
Fish dinner with mac and cheese meatball splash with frnch fries
The Elmton - Real Pizza!
BBQ breasted chicken
Wednesday special three piece Broasted chicken dinner, Broasted SEASONED fries, and a side of chicken gravy.
Stuffed cabbage
A slice of pizza & a piece of delicious broasted chicken, last night was really good.
16 in. Pepperoni pizza
interior
First course
3 piece Broasted chicken & the broasted potatoes always on my list
Tom S.
Feb 1, 2025
A local legendary restaurant that never disappoints! Best chicken around. Awesome vintage atmosphere. One of the Yo's treasures...and one of the unique pizzas in the area.
Read More
Joe O.
Sep 27, 2023
The waitstaff is great! The pizza is terrible! People say the owner is hard to get along with. Bellaria has much,much better pizza.
Read More
Robert S.
Feb 20, 2025
Been coming here since high school in the late 60's Lived out of the area and recently returned. Went in yesterday with a group of 3. Our waitress got the order wrong, then forgot to bring an item, not once but twice. The pizza was not the same, very dry and we ordered extra cheese. We got jammed in the bar area with a large group and it was just a mess. The bill was 65.00 not counting tip for a pizza, hamburger and a hoagie {at least it was good). The Cole slaw was great but the pizza was terrible. Oh well I won't be back just sorry to see what has happened to this great place of my youth. As they say you can never go home again !
Read More
Tim T.
Feb 14, 2025
Stopped there this afternoon got a 16inch pizza to go for dinner.Pizza was excellent, cooked perfect, couldn't been any better, always have gotten great pizza here for years.
Read More
Steve R.
Nov 28, 2024
The best "Real Pizza " in the Youngstown area. Definitely a great place to go for truly authentic pizza.
Read More
Dave R.
Nov 27, 2024
Food is always good. Been going there for over 50 years. Went there a year ago and service was terrible forget what the excuses were. Went to try it again after about a year a couple weeks ago. Once again terrible service excuse this time "mix up in the kitchen ". Will try again next year just because of memories. Don't know if I have any friends left that will be willing to join us though.
Read More
Laura M.
Nov 27, 2024
I love the pizza and broasted potatoes. My husband loves the chicken too. It's a true gem and glad it's still around.
Read More
Patti H.
Jun 23, 2024
The broasted chicken & pizza are still delicious ‼ they have a convenient takeout area located on the side of the restaurant.
Read More
David S.
Nov 11, 2024
I have been a lifelong customer of elmton pizza ! i recently purchased a 12-inch pizza, a grilled chicken salad, & broasted chicken dinner ! the order was on-time & correct, the food was incredible, & carry -out staff friendly & personable! i would rate elmton pizza as one of the best pizza & food restaurants in the area!
Read More
David D.
Mar 20, 2024
I have been a lifetime Struthers resident and a lifelong Elmton customer and fan. Until today. I called to get a couple of chicken dinners. The staff called back with some confusion (again, it's only two dinners). No problem, I clarified what we ordered. They called back again about two minutes later because they were confused again. (Really?!? - it seriously was only two dinners). I canceled the order due to a lack of intelligence on their part. I asked to talk to the owner, and when he got on, he hung up on me mid sentence as I was explaining the problem.It would have been nice if he had made an attempt to diffuse the situation. I have heard from multiple people how much of an a$$hat Jack can be. I got to experience it firsthand today. I will make sure I let everyone I know how he values his customers.
Read More