Tavern on the Square

Delicious food, delightful waitress. The Thai curry bowl is wonderful, but the added chicken was dry. The chicken was definitely not worth the extra charge. The basic curry was great though!The salmon pizza was excellentThe menus in this yelp entry are all incorrect as of 10/27/2024 - I think it's under new ownership. See this link for the current menu: https://thetavernonthesquare.com/pages/menu

Our server was fantastic, food was good. Prices outrageously high!!!!I had the catch of the day which was grouper, with the fish I received 1 side all for the price of $60!!!! My fault for not asking the price before I ordered Will not go back and do not recommend as there are many restaurants in the Western PA/Eastern Ohio with excellent food at a much more reasonable price.

What a find! Beautiful building, great service, great ambiance. My wife and I came here for a Valentine's Day lunch. Get the chicken and biscuit! It was awesome! Cant wait to back!

We went as for a family gathering before my daughter's wedding. The service is exceptional, as good as any New York restaurant. Wonderful, relaxed atmosphere in this old local home. The drinks are inventive and amazing while the food is absolutely top notch. My wife had the pepperoni pizza, my daughter the ancient grains bowl and I had the curry bowl. Such wonderful flavors perfectly balanced.

What a beautiful restaurant! Our entire experience was incredible. We shared the flaky biscuits with summery butter and honey . We each had the steak and fries. The steak was grilled to perfection. The fries were crispy and seasoned so well, huge portion too! Can't wait to come back to try the fried chicken.

Holy crap, this is the best restaurant in the TriState area. I want to tell everyone, but I also want no one to know so I can come any time I want. Every detail is thoughtful and perfect. I am so happy.

We were in town for a local event and made early reservations for an early dinner. We arrived on time, but still took 10 minutes to get seated even though the restaurant was empty since it was a 3:30pm reservation. The waitress was slow to get our drink orders, and even slower to follow up on getting our orders placed. Once our orders were eventually placed it took 45 minutes to get our salads and appetizers. When told the waitress that we were now getting pressed for time since our salads had just arrived to the table, she assured us that our dinners would arrive momentarily, 20 minutes later after our food still had not be received. We again asked about our entrees, and again assured it was on its way. Another 10-15 minutes later our burgers arrived just in time for us to put them in a to go box.The meal and quality of the food was good, however the service was horrible and we were not even able to eat our meals until we got home later that evening after our event.

I rarely leave reviews. Honestly, I don't think I have ever left a Yelp review, certainly not a good one. However, as I planned my meal for tonight, I decided to check out the Taverns Yelp page to scroll some photos and saw all of the negative reviews and I was DISGUSTED with all of the negative ones! I need to actually breathe and sort through my thoughts:#1 The food is amazing! My husband and I have been by over a handful of times since the renovation and have not once had a bad meal! #2 Speaking of the renovation, they did amazing! The place looks better than ever! I saw someone in the comments complaining about the upstairs bathroom being closed to the public due to a private party up there-- hey guess what, that bathroom wasn't ever open to the public before! Be grateful it exists at all! Also- they literally spent god knows how much INSTALLING AN ELEVATOR, and you want to go cry accessibility?? As someone that actually does have a disability, this renovation has been amazing for me. Go to your chain restaurant, eat your subpar meal, and complain to someone else. #3 Rude owners? Unbelievable. The husband and wife have both greeted my husband and myself on separate occasions to check on us, our food, our experience. I could tell you so much about them, where they are from, why they opened this place, how the renovations went, it's honestly wild. I went to the old tavern a million times in my life and I have no idea who owned that place.. the owner actually brought my mother-in-law out homemade brown butter cookies on her birthday (along with her birthday dessert) to take home for later for free! I mean, come on. Maybe you all should just be nicer. #4 Who complains about young servers? A wait at a restaurant? My servers have been so sweet and always made the best recommendations to ensure our meal was fantastic. Anything from "you have to try that with this sauce" or "I will get you some extra sauce to go with that, you'll need it!". You could easily say- going the extra mile. We have never waited once, but have always made a reservation. Who wouldn't? A new and popular restaurant, seems logical? #5 The price tag on a fantastic farm-to-table meal with an ever-changing seasonal menu, that supports the local farmers/fisherman/etc., PLUS the ambiance of a Joanna Gaines masterpiece. But yes, it's just too much. Ok. That was a long rant. But this place deserves to be 5-stars all the way. Please enjoy the photos of my 5-star meals that I remembered to take pictures of!

Followed the rebuilding, very impressive. We wanted it to be good. Unfortunately the food and the service was more than disappointing. The prices are above every restaurant in a 25 mile area. May try again someday.

I ordered a caesar salad and added a chicken breast. The chicken was great, however, the plate had so many croutons and Parmesan shaves that it was wasteful. The romaine lettuce was wilted and soggy. I would not recommend this dish. However, the ambiance was great. the table was sat at was perfect. the waitress only came back once which was the only downside to service. I would go back to give it a second go. If it does not impress then I would never go back due the cost not equaling the quality.