Supremo's Pizzeria

Pretty solid pizza! My friend suggested getting the extra pepperoni and I'm glad she did! It's the good pepperoni that curls up and gets crunchy! Great stuff!

Pizza delivered to the door is always tricky business. No longer is it 'hot from the oven' with the cheese and topping at peak perfection. Delivery pizza is judged by far different standards and for me, the leading standard is the crust. I love a yeasty crust that hasn't been worked to a point of toughness (pizza makers...stop overworking that crust!). It doesn't have to be piping hot. It does have to have good flavor. It can't be overcooked (aka burned or charred) and it absolutely cannot be soggy. We ordered four pies: a cheese with no sauce, a pepperoni and a veggie on regular crust and a ham&pineapple sicilian. The cheese and pepperoni pizzas were solid. Nice crust a tad overworked with a nice amount of cheese. The ham and pineapple had that thick crust and four corners. The dough did not knock us out though. The veggie was a bust. The crust was way undercooked and the toppings slid off as we tried to pull a slice to eat. We tried to cook it a bit more but it remained a kind of gooey mess. The toppings were good so our disappointment was high. Maybe the veggies weren't drained enough or the pizza just didn't get to stay in the oven long enough. Either way, we would not order it again.

Supremo's on Mars Evens City is very good. However, 228 Mars is not so good. Why I tried them again is my own fault.

Just tried some Supremo's for the first time today for lunch. I am not too familiar with the pizza competition in Mars, or any restaurants in this area for that matter, so I can't say how it compares to other local spots. However, based on the other places I've eaten at near the Pittsburgh area, their pizza is just very average.Location is somewhat small and in a plaza. I decided to try out the classic cheese pizza (because if you can't nail a delicious cheese pie, you won't nail the more sophisticated pies). The prices are pretty awesome, I will say that. You can get a personal sized pie for just $6, and there is a way to order online from them directly. But, flavor-wise, the food is still pretty mediocre. They have a somewhat thick crust, cheese that's only average, and not enough tomato sauce in my opinion. Nothing stood out, but it wasn't bad. It did have a slightly stale flavor as well.There are a few interesting items I found on the menu, but didn't order this time. They have nice desserts like the Cookie Bash (tons of chocolate and Oreo) as well as a Mississippi Mudslide Pie (not offered at most pizza places). Plus, the portion for the cinnamon bites is great and it's a great deal! All in all, this is an alright option for a quick snack, cheap dinner, or event when you need tons of pizza. They are a solid choice for catering or fundraising in the area (if you want cheap pizza, that is). Really good option in terms of prices!

Tried takeout for the first time and was really good! Simple order of Cheese pizza and buffalo wings and both were great. Pizza sauce cheese and dough were very tasty and possibly the best pizza we've had in the cranberry area. Wings were crispy and buffalo sauce very tasty with just the right amount of heat. Looking forward to trying more of their menu.

Usually this supremos is pretty good. I had just picked up an order from the callery location. Ordered a detroit style pizza and some apps. I have to say if people in Detroit eat pizza like this I feel real bad for them. First off the cheese in the center of the pizza was stuck to the lid. Then the slices are all dough. In all fairness i did not contact them because I am about half hour away when I opened the box. Just going to take this one as a loss. Edit to this review. After posting this review I recieved a call from Supremos (i apologize for not remembering name). The had apologized for quality and asssured me that they will make it right. Now that right there is something I value more then the price of the pizza itself. Caring about the customer. Thank you

Consistently good pizza and hoagies Pittsburgh style. Always on time and friendly service.

Even with the special it was overpriced and hate to say not as good as expected. For the price it'd be nice not to skimp on the cheese

This place has great pizza! We tried it out a few days ago and were very pleased with both the food and the service. Returned today with a larger order for my birthday. Can't wait to try some hoagies from here!

BestHoagie in Mars..... season fry's are great and don't forget the cookie. so so good. delivery is very fast as well. It's not DoorDash they have drivers.