Sugar & Spice

Sweet little ice cream shop. Nice staff. Had a variety of flavors. Clean inside eating area but didn't realize the door is on the side. Cute little picnic area to sit and enjoy the day. Didn't try the candy but I'm sure they are good. On my list of things to get when I go the the burgh.

Sugar & Spice has been a part of my life since it was located off of Brownsville Road. It's such a great little local ice cream place. We love the homemade ice cream. We wanted a treat after dinner today so decided to go to Sugar & Spice since it's so close to home. It's been awhile since we've been there, but it's just as delicious as I remember. They have such a great menu that can accommodate everyone's preferences and I appreciate the size options. Everyone is friendly & the prices are reasonable.

Great homemade ice cream shoppe! Staff is very friendly. They serve soft serve as well as hard ice cream. I love the decor! They also have a cute little candy store and sell ice cream cakes as well! Very affordable compared to the other ice cream places.

This place has some truly delicious ice cream! I am nearly never in the area. But, I'm sure this place is a classic for the Baldwin/Brentwood/Whitehall community. The vibe it gives is like one of those old school ice cream shops. Local, family owned, and amazing.I tried the peanut butter milkshake. Super simple, but very good. The number one greatest thing about this place is probably the value. You get a ginormous shake for under $5. And, it was far larger than I have tried in nearly any other place. This sort of value is just incredible.The flavor is also quite good. I thought it was a little vanilla-y for a peanut butter shake, but still great. You can taste it's homemade, not just Hershey's or some other brand. They also have numerous other standard flavor (chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and more). They even have frozen yogurt, no sugar added flavors, sundaes, and more.I'll have to try out some of the more unique flavors sometime; my review would probably be 5 stars by the time I do that. They do close early though (but they are also open year round. Yes, even in the winter). Would love to come back.

I can't believe I haven't stopped here before! Delicious, homemade hard serve ice cream is a must! They had so many unique combinations to choose from, it was hard to decide. We ended up ordering brownie sundaes, and wow wow wow... delicious! The service was great; and I appreciated the girls being so patient with us while we took 10 minutes to decide, and took our time with samples. The parlor was so cute, old school diner feel and very clean. Can't wait to come back!

Fantastic place! Not super expensive but quality ingredients cost more. Variety of baked goods daily, all of them incredibly delicious! Don't miss this special, tasty place!

If you're looking for a delicious and affordable ice cream shop in the area, look no further than Sugar and Spice! The ice cream here is some of the best I've ever had, and the prices are very reasonable.I highly recommend the banana split, it's so good! The service is also great, the staff is always friendly and helpful. Overall, Sugar and Spice is a great ice cream shop that I would highly recommend to anyone in the area.

Great place and delicious ice cream! One of the few places I've found that still does a walnut sundae! Friendly staff made our visit an all around great experience.

Anything we get there is always delicious from ice cream cones, ice cream sandwiches, slushies, floats, shakes, or sundaes.

Wonderful little place, they have great ice cream and the staff is always great! The soda shop is so nostalgic! Take home a pint!