Slice on Broadway

Friendly chefs the moment you walk in the door. Authentic by the slice, brick pizza oven experience. It's all a touch pricey, but great value for what you're getting.This food is diabolically good. The pizza by itself is probably the best slice you'll have in Pittsburgh. Only rivaled by Pizza Parma in terms of thin crust slices. At Slice on Broadway they also offer a seasoning that I look forward to using every time I go. Their garlic knots are a great texture and don't give your mouth the "too much garlic" sting. If you have a couple extra bucks to shill out or a special occasion coming around, get something from these folks cause it tastes awesome. (Also it tastes like Pizza My Heart for my California friends)

2/14/25Ate List:Slice of Cheese - 6.4Slice of Pepperoni - 6.7A local pizza chain clearly in a "NY pizza spot cosplay."The slices would not measure up to those truly from NYC. However, as an affordable spot and one that actually serves slices, not just full pies, it's not the worst option.In a pinch, this is a good option for bang for your buck and I think is cheaper and better than some of the other "fast food" options locally.

As a New Yorker this is my favorite pizza in Pittsburgh. They also have solid pepperoni rolls and garlic knots. Service is solid and have diner in before. Ambiance is good for a pizza joint.

A very nice NYC style pie!! Just the way I like my pizza to be. Definitely is a place I recommend!

How in the world does this place ONLY have a 3 1/2 / 5 ? This place was, by far, one of the TOP PIZZA places I have ever had (1) & in Pittsburgh (2). Outside of Mineo's, this was one place I felt so happy to eat at !!!! My sister ordered us the margherita. The slice portions were VERY generous, and the fresh basil alongside mozzarella cheese was the RIGHT combo. I will be back and hope you all give this place a raving review. Definitely underrated!

I haven't been to the one in Carnegie in a long time, but that is where I first got hooked on the green monster. This is the only thing that I order from them and for good reason. It has just the right vegetables on it and all around flavor combinations. The pesto, the spinach, the artichokes, roaster red peppers(oh come on now!), lastly but certainly not least the ricotta that melts in your mouth and brings it to the next level. I went in there and got a small and the small is not small for one person. It is a ton of pizza really and especially with all of the ingredients. Anyways, this monster is to die for. As I told the pizza maker, I can't understand why anyone would want anything other than the green monster! Ha!

Ordered delivery from Slice on Broadway recently for an intern party at work. I was quoted an hour for 3 pies -- two cheeses and a pepperoni -- and they were at my door in 30 minutes flat during lunch rush. Excellent service.The pizzas themselves were a hit with everyone in the office, as well as my boss who grew up in NYC. Good flavor, and good crisp, chewy crust. If you're looking for a good New York style pizza in Pittsburgh, Slice on Broadway is a great option for a treat yourself night at home or a larger party or work function.

Very average experience ordering from here. They are best known for their NY style, thin crust pizza. But, they also sell other things, like pepperoni rolls, calzones, and desserts such as cheesecake. The cheesecake is from Junior's in NY, I believe.I ordered the classic, plain cheese calzone. It was decent, nothing special really. The size was fine but I've had better deals. I would have liked it to be baked a little longer for the crisp. Not too doughy though.They use an adequate amount of cheese. It's mostly mozzarella, very little ricotta. The inside is a bit greasier than at most place. No sauce on the inside to keep it from being soggy. The little tomato sauce container served on the side was pretty tasty but cold.All in all, solid option for a calzone but just not impressive in any way. I think their pizza might be better than the calzone. May come back to give that a try.

The food here is tasty. Pizza slices are large! The biggest hurdle is finding convenient parking. I love pizza shops that sell slices. I will be returning.

slice of pizza was blah, the spinach rolls looked like they were cooked last week so yes they looked really old and tasted old.stop making so much food and leaving it to sell for the next day.