Sirena Pizza

Absolutely love this pizza. The original when I went to as a youngster was in Leechburg, PA.The Sicilian Pizza is just fantastic. I love their sauce and cheese. I actually order extra sauce- it has plenty but the more the merrier. I ate 3 pieces during the 35min ride home- I couldn't stop. So I have no pictures. My wife and kids enjoy the New York style (thin) crust too.The variety of food here is amazing and tastes just as amazing. The staff here is also very friendly. Adding a bar at the front of this establishment is the icing on the cake.

I'm sorry to say that our recent visit to Sirena was INCREDIBLY disappointing. We ordered the stuffed meat pizza, the appetizer sampler with chicken fingers, cheese balls and mozzarella sticks and a philly steak sandwich.All of this totaled about $50 and it wasn't even CLOSE to being worth it. The only thing that was decent was the appetizer sampler.The stuffed meat pizza was swimming in an alarming pool of grease. I understand that there's a lot of meat in it, but the last time we got this pizza it wasn't this greasy.The philly steak sandwich was the biggest insult. Asked for no mushrooms, got a ton of mushroom and the bread was a soggy goopy mess. I've included pictures of the offensive items. The pile in the takeout container is the steak, onions and peppers that I tried to salvage to put on some crusty bread of my own. The other pile of stuff with the bread is the mushrooms, tomatoes and lettuce that were incredibly soggy.We'd ordered all of these items previously and enjoyed them, so I don't know what happened to this place since the last time we visited but we definitely won't be back. I'd rather just go to Subway and spend less for a sandwich that is (sadly) more edible.

Friendly atmosphere with lots of TVs the best part we're the $2.00 pizza slices. The pizza is made right in front of you and was some of the best I've had in the area. The place was really clean and the staff super friendly

Subs and pizza's are super delicious.. Have visited this business for 3 years. Give them a try if in Kittanning Area.

Though still reeling from Shaymarie F's 1-star review, Sirena Pizza has decided to remain open. Management knew her ironic assertion "I think there absolute idiots..." and her stance that "They need to shut this place down", would be hard to recover from, but the difficult decision was made to carry on, and I'm thankful they did. It's a little hole-in-the-wall type place and they only take cash, but they have the best pizza in the area. My only complaint is that the toppings don't seem to be of the highest quality. Not bad, just average. They do deliver and I've always had a good experience with the employees. Definitely recommended if you're looking for pizza in Kittanning.

Great pizza! Great hoagies! Awesome deals, iffy service. The service is hit or miss and I don't recommend delivery because there is always a long wait.

Possibly the most inconsistent restaurant I've eaten at. Sometimes my family orders it and it's amazing, other times it's unedible. I think this place has very poor staff for that to happen. Prices are much higher here than other places too. In my opinion it's not worth the risk, just buy a pizza from Aldi's for quarter the price.

I've been a patron of Sirena's for over 40 years. It was always the best in the area, in my opinion. However, after the pizza we had tonight, my opinion has definitely changed! I haven't ordered for a while and they obviously changed ingredients. The pizza was so wet on top & the crust was very soggy. I am a cheese LOVER! However the cheese on this pizza was awful! It wouldn't even melt! It was chunky, yet gritty and looked like cooked rice.. The texture was bad enough, but the taste was terrible as well. I actually took it off of my pizza. I tried to eat the remainder of the soggy crust, but I just couldn't do it. My husband will eat anything, and he couldn't even eat it. We threw away an entire 16 cut pizza. PLEASE go back to the original cheese!! I honestly don't think I will ever order from here again, which really saddens me. I loved Sirena pizza! I love a good pizza! I tried to take pictures to show the cheese, but the picture does not do it justice.

The stuffed steak pizza is delicious and their subs look good.... that's what I want to try next!!!

The food was absolutely phenomenal. The portions are massive along with decent pricing! Excellent service! 10/10 will go back!