Rustic Mountain Pizza

Great service and great pizza. Not far from our location at Hidden Valley and the people erred great and the pizza was done quickly. Thank you. We will return.

Yes the sauce is sweet, but all enjoyed the pizza. We had a pepperoni, and another with sausage, onion, and mushroom. The side of garlic sauce was delicious too - reminiscent of Papa John's garlic sauce. The subs were well wrapped in foil and were still hot after a 15 minute drive. The hot wings were definitely hot-spicy! Food was ready quickly. Bring cash.

Heart Attack pizza and sausage pizza were great picks! We also enjoyed the wings, fried mushrooms and fries. Delivery was prompt, no complaints! Food was yummy, would order from this spot again!

In some ways, this pizza was better than I expected, but it should not be mistaken for great pizza.On the up-side, the pizza is allowed to cook so that the cheese gets caramelized instead of being underdone and flabby. Also, the end crust puffs up nicely when baked, as it should. That's better than you'll get at most pizza places beyond the NY/NJ/CT pizza corridor. On the down-side, as other Yelpers have so clearly noted, that red sauce is remarkably sweet. Not sweet like long stewed ripe tomatoes. It's sweet like sugar. Trusting the Yelp community, I tried to order accordingly, and steered towards white pies and those that might be able to counter the sweetness of the sauce. The Buffalo Chicken was the clear favorite of the household. Second was the white pizza with sausage and sweet peppers. However, the sweet peppers were too sweet for some, and in the future, I'd go for another accompaniment to complement the sausage. Onions, peppers, and mushrooms had no chance of cutting through the cloying nature of the pizza sauce, but I thought the "Heart Attack" special with triple the pepperoni and parmesan cheese might do the trick. Alas, all that smokey, salty, cured meat was no match for the sugar content of the sauce. So if you're at Hidden Valley, and feel like getting pizza, bring some cash down to Rustic Mountain. Just stick to the white pies, and maybe the bread sticks. Save the sugar for dessert.

Fun place. Kind of a carnival booth/living room feel. Seemed to be family run. Pizza is top notch and reasonably priced. I would take this over the big chains any day. Sauce has a nice sweet taste to it. Service was friendly and fun. Family was all happy.No masks or covid protocols being followed if that concerns you.

We were at 7 Springs for the weekend and wanted good pizza. This is not the place. The pizza sauce tastes like tomato paste and sugar, it's so sweet it's unbearable. Very unhappy.

Awful pizza. Tasted like they put sugar on it. Sauce was all dried up. Expensive too.

OK, so if you DISLIKE pizza sauce that is on the sweet side, this pizza won't be your thing. But we absolutely love the pizza here. I'm from the DC area, and Ledo's Pizza is very comparable to this. They will cook it to order, more or less done, and the owners are very nice.Our normal go-tos are the pizza, cheese sticks and wings. The wings are perfectly fried and then sauced, no breading.I love this place! If you're in town for a weekend, or if you live here, give it a try. Cash only though.

If you like a sweeter sauce pizza it's great! If not I might recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza from here. Pizza is thicker. I've been going here for multiple years and I have always enjoyed it.

The pizza was way WAY too sweet that I actually thought they accidentally confused sugar with salt preparing it... until I read the other reviews. We got the cheese pizza and the veggie pizza. My only complaint is honestly the sweetness. I cant eat anything sweet when im hungry, so ended the night with a bag of chips, since we were already in our hotel room by the time i had a bite in of my slice (post skiing) and its 10pm. Looking forward to a savory breakfast tomorrow.