Rockaway Pizzeria

Rockaway Pizza is hands down the best New York-style pizza in the Pittsburgh area, if not the best pizza in the city altogether. We always go for the margherita, and it's perfect every time--authentic, flavorful, and with that signature thin crust that's crispy yet chewy in all the right places.While their White Oak location is currently closed as they relocate to Regent Square, we can't wait for them to reopen. If you're a fan of true New York-style pizza, keep an eye out for Rockaway Pizza's new spot--it's well worth the wait!

A friend told us to try this pizza. I was pleasantly surprised, I like Sicilian pizza. Pepperonis a little zippy but for some Iam sure it's great. I really liked the meatball hoagie, great meatballs, lots of cheese and not a sloppy with sauce, just the right amount. The sausage hoagie is good, I like link sausage but the slices really didn't bother me. Highly recommend!! We will order again.

This place is a hit every single time! The food is simply amazing. Great ingredients perfect amounts and always fresh. Service is impeccable always greeted with a smile and a good word. It is small but there is dining area that's always clean and available. My only complaint is they run out of dough to often on the weekends so get you order in early like i do and don't miss out.

My husband watched a show called "Pittsburgh Today Live" and in this show a dining critic from the Pittsburgh Post Gazette - Hal B. Klein reported that Rockaway was finalist runner up for best pizza in Pittsburgh; raving about their pizza. Being that my husband is a self proclaimed pizza connoisseur, he took this on as a challenge and just had to give Rockaway Pizzeria a try. Husband called at 5pm and was told to pick up his pizza order in about 50-55 minutes. My husband arrived at 6pm, 1 hour later and had to wait another 20 minutes more once he arrived. He ordered a regular round pepperoni and a square Carsosa pizza. We enjoyed both pizzas. We probably should have gotten a bit of variety. Husband went crazy and ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas. Pizza sauce was good and sauce flavorful. Was not overly oily or heavy. Crust had a nice bite on both. I preferred the square cut and I would have had my husband order a plain next time. Tastes a little like Napolis in Miracle Mile in Monroeville. We came and we tried. It was good. 4.

Rockaway pizza is extraordinary! The doh, the toppings, the cheese are all top quality and brought together with perfect execution. Not your average PA pizza, very little grease on the bottom of the box ;)I would drive an hour and a half for this pizza!

At this point I can pretty much say I've had everything on the menu. I can also say it's all perfect.I will continue to drive out from the city on a regular basis for this crazy good pizza.

I had many people proclaim this to be the best pizza in the area, so I was super-eager to try it out. I got there when they first opened and they only had 2 pies out of the oven, so I opted for two slices of pepperoni. I will say that the crust was darn-near perfect. But the sauce was lackluster, and the cheese and pepperoni didn't wow me like I was expecting. Overall, a disappointment, but I'd be willing to give them another try, maybe a whole pie next time.

Had the White Pizza and it was so good! The girl that helped me was sweet and went out of her way to help even though she was busy taking phone orders. It has a few tables but mainly is a takeout place. I definitely will be back when in Pittsburgh. Go there you won't be sorry!!!!

First visit ever I ordered the Mamma's Pie with Pepperoni. I can see why Rockaway is so highly rated. This is excellent pizza, with the highest quality ingredients. Definitely going back.

Whoever cooked this has no clue how the crust is supposed to be on a pizza. Burnt as hell! Was very excited to try this place since it got an 8.2 review from the barstool guy. I would rate it a 6.2 at best due to the crust. Extremely disappointed. Unlikely to ever come back here.