Pumpkin drop
Steeler sugar cookie
Sugar crystal cookie
Inside case
two cupcakes on a glass plate
a birthday cake with flowers on it
a cupcake in a box
a variety of cakes and pastries
New Year's Pretzel
food
food
Cookies
Delicious fall themed cookies
food
Cute
Paczki
Happy customer once again!
My sister's german chocolate b-day cake!
Goodies!
Happy Birthday Dad!
St Patrick's Day birthday cake. Chocolate and white cake with strawberry filling.
food
Storefront
interior
Sara I.
Aug 23, 2024
5/5 for delicious donuts, a little crispy and over done ladylocks, and the worlds best brownies!! The front desk lady was a little snippy and short with me.
Read More
Jenee S.
Apr 2, 2023
This is my second time coming here this year. Quality and taste have gone way downhill.I ordered a cheese danish, frog, and a hot cross bun.The bun was so dry and fruit didn't have flavor.There was hardly any cheese in the danish and tasted fake.The frog was okay but not like others I've had before.Service depends on who you get. One lady was really nice and the other didn't want to be there and was rude.I went to another local bakery and ordered another danish. It was night and day how much better the other was.This is so close to our home but isn't worth it
Read More
Dan K.
Mar 4, 2023
Simply amazing! Our family has been trying different bakeries for birthday cakes in the south hills area ever since our bakery we used for years had new ownership. Potomac Bakery is the place to go! They are so accommodating to whatever you are looking for and as you can see by the picture, they decorate their cakes beautifully. We couldn't get over how perfect and thin the lettering is on the cake and how detailed the flowers are. This is a butter cream cake with a raspberry layer of filling in the middle that was very light and delicious. We are so excited that we found our new spot to get all of our family cakes and baked goods!
Read More
Seth D.
Jan 7, 2024
I love there pastries, service is pretty good, not the best I've seen in Dormont though, nice and little shop, at least 2 other locations and sure, I request it.-Written by Finley Dubin
Read More
Patty N.
Dec 31, 2023
I ordered a small pretzel for New Years. I thought it seemed dry and after taking a small piece, it was so dry and tasteless that I threw the remainder away. What a waste. I wish Mt Lebanon Bakery was still in this location. Potomac Bakery is a very poor replacement.Oops. I mean Graham Bakery!
Read More
Alyssa R.
Sep 24, 2023
Went around 12ish on a Saturday. I went in and there was 1 person in front of me, and about 5 people came in after me. One thing I should note is they should have a ticket system. The store isn't big enough to fit people waiting so you have to trust people not to cut in front of you when you're waiting since you can't form a a true line. 1 think I need to note is it's the Slowest service ever. There was about 6 workers 3 in the Bali bf area and 4 or 4 by the counter. I person was doing cake pickups and the other 2 I'm not sure. There was 1 person taking orders and it took about 15 minutes with 1 person in front of me to order. The person I front of me barley got anything. A different worker came over to help me. The workers had no pep in there step, now maybe it was just a rough day, but everyone was just really really taking there time. I got a chocolate chip muffins that just seemed to be missing something in it, it just tasted slightly off. The cookies were good, but nothing great. Overall, I don't think I would go back unless I have an hour to kill. But like I said, maybe it was just a bad day.
Read More
Jason T.
Aug 25, 2023
Good enough baked goods albeit dry. Service is adequate or below average. Maybe have the workers wear gloves? My big issue here. The business does not show prices in store and not sure anyone there knows how much things cost. Made similar purchases two weeks in a row with very different amounts paid. Won't be going back.
Read More
Sarah Y.
Jul 20, 2023
Very friendly and helpful staff. The cases were clean and very well organized. The kids loved the PAC-Man cookies. The cinnamon rolls are huge and the donuts are definitely fresh.
Read More
Elle D.
Dec 2, 2024
Thanksgiving pumpkin and pecan pies were delicious!! Always the best pies at Potomac Bakery.
Read More
Natalie R.
Sep 4, 2024
First time and will never go back! $33.00 for a half and half birthday cake and this is what it looks like. I said the writing is so small and they did nothing. Smelled like cleaning solution when you walked in and the place is dumpy. Choices were minimal.
Read More