Pizza Man's Pizza

Came here for a theater party and the food is amazing, but I feel bad for the workers because kids suck and don't shut up

Had lunch here today, and it was fantastic. Got half of the italian hoagie and a cup of chicken and rice soup. The staff was excellent, and it was more food than I could eat for around $10. Highly recommend this place.

Pros:*Cheese Pizza*Buffalo Chicken Pizza*Good prices*Friendly StaffCons:*Pepperoni Pizza

I have ordered food their on my own and with a bunch of the guys from work... Went their for lunch a few times this place doesn't disappoint food was excellent every time... The waitresses and waiters were on top of everything and very nice and accommodating...

OLD SCHOOL JOINT DONE RIGHTThere's a reason why the telephone won't stop ringing. People love the pizza here. And so do I.The pizza is delicious. And so are the sides. Sure they may not be aesthetic works of art, but the somewhat sweet of this pizza always takes me to a special place. 5/5 stars for food.4/5 starts for service (they are short staffed given the pandemic)4/5 aesthetic (a bit outdated furniture but love the old school feel).6/5 on prices and value. Overall? Well-worth it.

While dining for dinner, we noticed a customer returning a pizza, not sure why he was returning it. The employees took the pizza out of the box and discussed it. One employee picked a few pepperoni off the pizza with her bare fingers, they then placed the pizza on the rack where they take individual slices for sale. Not sure if this is even legal since the pizza had already left the restaurant.

Poor experience from start to the upset-stomach finish. Order was placed in advance for pickup. At pickup, came to the counter & was ignored by 3 different staff members moving in & out around the counter for about 3-4 minutes. Order was a medium pizza, garlic parm fries, fried ravioli, deluxe steak & cheese, & stromboli. Had to recite the order top-to-bottom for the staff member who finally came to assist me. Brought food home. The deluxe steak and cheese was anything but deluxe. Lots of bread, barely any meat, and no cheese. The Garlic Parm fries did not appear cooked and were just soaked in oil -literally a quarter inch of oil in the bottom of the tin- if you bit the fries it was just an explosion of oil. The chicken & cheese melted on top was dry and greasy. The fried ravioli was dry and tasteless. The pizza was "OK," but also wet and greasy. The stromboli was "OK," but the sauce was very very bad. When I tried to call to report these problems, phone rang & then disconnected without a person answering. Will never ever recommend or return again.

Really poor take out experience on Thursday. Called in an order for a pierogie pizza and a Stromboli for takeout and was told it would be ready in 30-35 minutes. Arrived 30 minutes later and paid and the counter and was told my order was still in the oven and would be ready in a few minutes. About 5 minutes later I watch the young kid who they were calling, Zach make a pierogie pizza and put it in the oven, but didn't think much of it because it is a popular item. However, after stand there for 15 -20 minutes and then watching someone remove the pizza and box it, I realized that was my pizza. A few minutes later Zach puts a Stromboli in the oven so I ask the girl who rang me up if that was my Stromboli that just went into the oven. She said it wasn't and that my order was being boxed up and then she went and said something out of earshot to another lady who then said something to Zach and he just shrugged. Needless to say I spent over a half hour just at the restaurant waiting and it was over an hour from the time I placed the order til the time I got my food. They tried to rush the Stromboli so it wasn't even cooked in the middle. If the food is going to take an hour tell me on the phone, don't make me drive there and stand around and keep lying about the status of my order. Poor customer service!

Quick !!!! Fire !!!!! Authentic!!! And they do slices!!! Def hit up Pizza Man!!!! No need to go elsewhere in Jtown

Have ordered pizza here for a few years now. Quality is normally ok to good but at times it is inconsistent with uneven crust thickness and varying topping amounts from week to week. Having said that, tonight was a total disaster and likely a game ender for me. I called and ordered 2 X-Large pepperoni pizzas for pickup, gave my name and phone number, was given the price with tax, and was told 35-40 minutes they would be ready. That was at 4:48PM. My wife went to pick up the pizzas at 5:30PM and was told there was no order there under our name. She was told they had no record of the order. She came home and told me and I was livid. We were all hungry and tired and wanted supper. I called back to complain and was told the same thing, until the person then realized she misheard my name and wrote it wrong and our pizzas were there and I could come get them. I said no and wanted 2 fresh pizzas as it was already over a half an hour they must have been sitting there. After much arguing I was told they would make me 2 fresh pizzas and it would be 30-45 minutes and hung up on me. I called back immediately and said I would be over in 15 minutes for my FRESH pizzas. This was at 5:52PM per my call logs. I went over at 6:20 to pick them up. I was given two "fresh" pizzas that were on top of the HOT ovens. If these were two fresh pizzas, they must have gone from the ovens to the fridge and back as the grease and cheese was already congealing. Needless to say, I was in no position to refuse the pizzas right then as they were our supper for tonight. I reluctantly paid for them (wasn't comped or even offered a discount for their screwup) and went home to eat my cold "fresh" pizzas. Cripe, I had to nuke my slices to make them palatable. It is very unlikely we will be buying any pizza or other food from Pizza Man's Pizza for a very long time, if ever again. There are just too many other pizzerias in the neighboring area that offer quality product and superior customer service to spend my hard-earned money here again.