a piece of bread and a pickle
February 5, 2018 article in New Castle News!
Incredible, just incredible Reuben!!!! Delicious.
a half eaten pizza in a box
Italian mini on a garlic knot
Order area
The pitt panther: breaded chicken, thousand island, Cole slaw, and mozzarella cheese
The Bulldog and The Golden Gator.
Pepperoni Pizza!
The fire department
Chicken Parmesan heaven.
Meatball Sub was very good
Assorted sub
Cannot beat a pizza this good for $5.50
Hot express...yessss!!
Banh mi
outside
food, pizza
food
food
food
interior, sushi and sashimi
Tyler P.
Dec 7, 2023
I look forward to eating here when I visit home. Buffalo chicken hoagie with slaw, cheddar, and olives is my order and it smacks everytime. Glad to see this place still open and killing it! Not to mention the owner and employees are always so nice.
Read More
Joanne R.
Sep 22, 2023
We had a steak hoagie. The roll was delicious. Little skimpy on the meat. We picked the super Philly. Next time I would probably do a build your own. If it's the same skimpy filling I won't be back. The inside of the place could be beautiful. But no one really seems to care. Beautiful Tin ceilings.
Read More
S R.
Dec 18, 2021
First review in 6 years ... you deserve it PA Sandwich Co. Don't bother, not worth your time or money. Spiteful workers that give you one strip of bacon on a whole sub after you call out their mistake of not adding bacon to the first sub. I went back to talk to the owner and he told me "that is the way we do it." I asked him again if it was normal to have a single strip of thin sliced, skinny bacon down the center of a whole sub, giving him another chance to redeem himself and his establishment. He continued by saying "some break it up and spread it out." Laughable.Don't believe the fake news awards on their wall.
Read More
Bryan R.
Jun 19, 2019
Traveling and first time here. This is a nice spot but kinda on the expensive side. However, the subs we had were large with good quality items. I would recommend a try.
Read More
Lee S.
Feb 5, 2021
I am so disappointed with myself that I have lived this close to this little jem and never been there before this week. I'll give it five stars for the combination of food and better than exceptional service. My daughter and I walked in for just some sandwiches. We drooled over the menu for 10 minutes before we decided to split two things then walked up to the counter to order and saw they had a display case of premade pinwheels and small sandwiches and they look so good we had to get those instead of what we took so long to order. We also ordered a brownie and a cookie the owner said "oh I over cooked those cookies a bit please don't judge me on them. Actually I can't charge you for them and threw in two huge cookies for free". We got 2 pinwheels, 2 small sandwiches, 2 drinks, a brownie and 2 chocolate chip cookies for less than 12.00. All of the food was 4-5 stars. The service by all theee employees was so great! Friendly. Talkative but not at all bothersome. Both my teenager and I love it and will certainly be back very soon!
Read More
Ky D.
Sep 8, 2022
This is the best sub place in Meadville. They have other things too, like pizza or pasta but I love the subs. Always fresh. Great taste. Quick service & friendly staff!
Read More
Ana A.
Sep 15, 2018
I've come here time and time again, and I have yet to have a bad experience. Yesterday, I went to order some subs for my roommate and I, and they turned out great. Service is fast, and they have a ton of subs to choose from (or you can build your own). Prices are cheap, and the food is always consistent. They also have a small case of garlic knots, pizza, and some other good looking Italian things. The only downside I see to this place is that they don't have a parking lot, so you'll have to find street parking somewhere. That obviously wouldn't stop me from going here to get a sub though because it's worth it.
Read More
Caleb M.
Jan 6, 2022
Actually really really good, one of the best turnovers I've had in my life. Was really unsure about coming here and it blew me away! You have to check this place out.
Read More
Jenni M.
Apr 7, 2024
This place was GREAT! The staff cares and the food was delicious! Just like Tyler said a year ago, this place SMACKS! Venue is old school. Creaky wood floors, cool Tin ceilings and the bathroom was clean.
Read More
Douglas M.
Nov 18, 2023
Ate there for the first time today. Had the gyro, it was huge and it was excellent. The service was quick and the food was fresh and flavorful. Will hopefully be returning again soon.
Read More