Peggy's Diner

Very nice place. Service is great. Food is delicious. Place is very clean. Def coming back.

Very, very friendly service. My coworker got a club sandwich which she said was delicious. I had the meatloaf special which was hard and not very flavorful. My Pepsi was completely flat and tasted ... unlike Pepsi. I asked for a to-go cup of coffee which I wasn't charged for since I barely touched my Pepsi (yay - thanks :-) but the coffee tasted old and burnt. I suspect Peggy's has amazing breakfast but we went for lunch. I threatened to come for breakfast this morning but they don't open until 8am. Wth? So I just ate breakfast at the hotel. I'm really sorry my experience was so lackluster but, unless in town and I have time for breakfast after 8am, I prolly won't come back.

I'm impressed. We got exactly what we were looking for. We wanted a traditional diner. That's what this little gem is. Our waitress was no nonsense, food was great, best crab cake I've had in years. Coffee was hot and delicious. Too full to try the out but I'm sure it would've been great.

Peggy's is a landmark in the area, providing quality food and service for over 50 years! Best pies in the area!

Alright so I think I might have jumped the gun on my last review... Peggys is a blast from the past but the food quality and the cleanliness has gone way way way down hill.. I had the opportunity to eat here two more times since the last post (Just to really get a feel), and wow... I misjudged this by a long shot.. I sadly will not be returning... This is a diner that needs some serious help.... Sad.

Most of the food is pretty good. The breakfast is very good. The stuffed pork chop dinner is very good. The service is excellent and the prices are very reasonable. Do not order a steak unless you like them well done because it is the only way they cook them . Overall it is a decent place for the money.

Very disappointed. We had visited this diner previously to shop for souvenirs. But this time on our way back home from Vegas we were looking forward to having Brunch. We checked out at 10 am of our hotel and drove over two hours just anxious to eat. When we got there, we asked the host to sit us. And she responded that the restaurant was self-sitting and we are to find an empty table. After going through a maze and continuing to ask for help we get to the very back and the lady tells us that area is only for pizza and has been cancelled/closed off.. We come back into the diner and noticed that clients began to guard tables and wait for people to get up so that they can obtain a table. We approached a leaving party and as they left we sat down. The waitress then approached us and asked us to get up and go back to the host and put our name on the newly created list. She refused to serve us or even clean the table. Not only that, my daughter had found another table on a different side of the restaurant and was being asked to get up on put her name on the list. By this time had been in the restaurant at least 15 min. The other parties did not get asked to get up. We go back to the front of the restaurant and now the list was about 10 parties long. We asked to speak to the manager and she simply responded that our name should be put on this magical list. I left the restaurant as i had no intention on dining in but when i aske my family to come to the car. They remained in the restaurant and wanted to be served. Finally, we got sat down and the food wasn't the best. They no longer was serving pancakes/french toast or waffles but the bacon wasnt fresh. It didn't feel crisp. The whole experience was not what we expected. Your signs are very visible and go on for hours but the service and food fall short of your big signs. The staff never apologized, they never put us on the top of the list they just were rude. I won't be going back there again!

Pretty average rural PA diner. We ordered the western omelet with bacon and a sausage bagel sandwich with hashbrowns. The omelet was thick. The hashbrowns are deep fried tater tots. Soft drinks are no refills unless you get a large and then you get one refill. The food is what you could make yourself at home minus the deep fryer. Everything was yummy and had the grease of a griddle that hasn't been cleaned thoroughly in some time. You know, diner delicious, like a well-seasoned cast iron pan.The staff was apathetic, doing just enough and complaining about the state of the restaurant in earshot of all customers. BUT, they were quick. Again, typical rural PA diner.

This is our stop every time we venture from Lancaster to western PA. The breakfast is better than any diner I've ever visited. The lunch & dinner menu is perfect. However, the winner is the Sunday lunch special(s). We try to time our return to coincide with the Sunday lunch crowd. It will remind of you of an episode of Alice, and Mel's Diner. I'm old.You don't find many town diners like this anymore. The waitresses have been working there for years...sassy, sexy, and smart! They'll remember your name if you're a one time per year customer.I'm only giving it 4 stars instead of 5 because I've never bought a winning scratch-off lottery ticket in that place. I don't trust the guy with the thick mustache. He reminds me of a Gambino. He's up to something, but it makes me come back.

Breakfast is very good and cheap, but be aware that they only take cash! Their spaghetti dinner is by the best, but for the price, it certainly can fill someone up. The atmosphere is comfortable for being an old diner.