a man holding a pizza box
a group of people watching a movie
a group of people watching a movie
Right in the middle of Reedsville, WV. You can't miss us!
a crowd of people standing on a train track
a billiards table in the middle of the room
the front of the building
a pool table and a pool table
the dining area
outside
outside
outside, pizza
interior
interior
outside
menu
menu
Peggy D.
May 14, 2022
The pizza is great. They care about what they are doing. It's a great place to relax, have a slice, and enjoy a drink. Highly recommend.
Read MoreWill S.
Oct 5, 2021
Has messed up my order several times so I don't prefer to go to this pizzeriaIt's pretty pricey for the mistakes the people that they do so I do not recommend eating at this place because they also don't put enough sauce or cheese on the pizza
Read MoreHaylee H.
May 11, 2024
I got TERRIBLE food poisoning from eating a pepperoni roll here. The disappointing part is that it tasted really good, but the next day I woke up and the pain and everything I had to go through that day was awful. I came up here with my husband for a work trip of his and ended up having to spend half of my time in the bathroom thinking I was dying. To anyone who's thinking about eating here, I promise you don't want to have to endure the pain I went through that day. And to the owners, DO BETTER. I know running a small business is hard but to put people in danger over pure laziness or attention to detail is crazy. You are serving humans, so be a decent human and make sure everything you're serving is up to date and fresh.
Read MoreJJ N.
Sep 17, 2023
It's not very good, overpriced, and 6/7 people in my crew got food poisoning. The place is not very clean as well.
Read MoreCeltie S.
Jan 14, 2023
The service is so nice and it just feels homey and the food was great as well I definitely enjoyed it
Read MoreAlicia D.
Dec 26, 2020
I've lost count of how many times I've called or stopped by Old School Pizzeria during their posted hours and they weren't open.
Read MoreKathy A.
Feb 8, 2020
We ordered our first pizza here yesterday. It was delicious. The sauce was exactly the way we like it and there was plenty of cheese. Also, the crust was just the right thickness and texture. So happy to have this place so close to home. Can't wait to go back!
Read MoreB B.
Jan 17, 2020
I won't go back it was super thin and sauce was way to sweet I like thin crust but you could not pick it up
Read More