Nicky's Pizzeria

Youngstown is known for great pizza and this is some of the best. Anybody that says this pizza is mid is smoking crack...

Far more average than good. Youngstown area pizza by in large IS NOT GOOD, but this is better than a lot of other places, but so is frozen pizza when considering what Youngstown has to offer. Parking is okay, place has easy to find. I'd eat it again, but not worth traveling from far to.

Pizza is very good. To the guy in his review who said most Youngstown pizza is not good obviously doesn't know good pizza

Highly recommend for delivery or take out. Despite what Yelp says, it's open on Sundays.

LISTEN LINDA, YOU CANNOT BEAT THIS PIZZA. The picture explains it all. First of all, the people that own this are fantastic. They are genuine people who care about their community and give back. The bread and sauce is made by them so it's all homemade. It is 100% a must have. Everyone around here knows Nicky's is the best! Nothing beats good food made by good people

Great Pizza. It has the flavor of the pizza I had as a little girl in the 1960s. Dont ever change!

BEST PIZZA. Best sauce, best toppings, best crust. All around the best I've ever had! I don't understand the issues with calling and asking what they have to offer if the menu isn't online? But most Nicky's fans know what they want because they're regulars. ‍ Definitely recommend this place to anyone I know!

Don't understand how people say this pizza is good,the dough is fat and soft thought I was eating a soggy loaf of bread.

I thought I was well-versed in Youngstown pizza but just had this for the first time and can't believe what I've been missing! Every bite was loaded with a delicious proportion of sauce, toppings and cheese, and the flavors and ingredients were top notch. Cannot wait to come back next time I'm in town!

FAVORITE pizza place of all time. My family and I have been eating at Nicky's for years. Not only is the pizza delicious, but also their wings. Next time in town must stop by to try!