New York Super Subs - Squirrel Hill

Best meatball sub I've had in years, you can tell they're made in house. Go with a friend and split the two footer... Wish I lived closer

I decided I was in the mood for an Italian hero and checked Yelp and decided on New York Super Subs.The location is not much to speak of one small table basically only take out.I ordered an Italian sandwich regular size.The service was excellent and the gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and very helpful.As far as Italian sandwich's go it was just ok nothing special.I did not care for the bread that much and the meat was just ok.I probably would not go again at least not for an Italian hero.The food would get 2 stars in my opinion but the service was 5 stars all the way.Overall I have to give it 3 stars as the food itself was just ok.

A little pricey, but a great quick takeout lunch option. Service is usually pretty good. They have a place you can sit inside or outside, but definitely prefer takeout here. 2 foot long sandwich??? Wild!

Good place to get a quality satisfying sandwich. I believe there was a location in Fox Chapel, but when I visited, it was closed. The Squirrel Hill location has many of the classic sandwiches, like Ruebens, Cheese, chicken Florentine, meatball, among others. I decided to try their cheesesteak sandwich (not the sub), their eclair, and the cannoli.I thought the sandwich was good, but a bit pricy. Their cheesesteak sub is probably a better deal, and you can get in a 1 ft or 2 ft (super) size. The meat was a good texture, but I would have liked a bit more cheese. The bun was nice and fluffy, soaked with steak juice on the bottom. Good amount of tasty mushrooms. You can also get the sandwich on a croissant. It was served with a tiny portion of coleslaw, which was tasty but way too minuscule. I also ordered a pickle wedge as one of my sides, but did not receive it.They have an in-house bakery from what I am aware of. They pride themselves on their cannolis, but I found the vanilla to be very average. It was not a very crispy shell. The filling was bland and just vaguely sweet. It tasted almost like whipped cream. Nothing special.The eclair was similarly only okay. The filling on the inside (custard) was very good. But, the chocolate topping was not thick enough. And, the eclair dough was standard, almost cakey. Probably not worth $4; I've had better at the Oakmont Bakery. This place also makes cookies, brownies, shortcakes, and other desserts.All in all, New York Super Subs probably can't compare to the New York delis. They make fairly good sandwiches, and they may be a good food stop if you like big sandwich (and are willing to pay the price). Their baked goods aren't anything special.

I ordered a burger with sides of potato salad and a pickle wedge. The cook who made my meal said he "made it with love" and I felt it haha. Just a really good, cheap, late lunch.

If you're looking for tasty sandwiches, this is a good spot. They have a pretty classic selection -- Italian hoagies, ruebens, turkey clubs, meatball subs, BLTs, everything you would expect -- plus a few interesting offerings like the buffalo chicken sandwich. Everything was good. If you're sticker shocked when you look at the prices, don't worry -- you do get plenty of sub for the cost. Their "whole" hoagies are two foot longs, and their "half" is a regular footlong. So keep that in mind when ordering!

New York Super Subs was good. The quality of the pastrami doesn't compare to the kosher cuts you can get in the New York area, but I still really enjoyed my sandwich. The pickle was good, and the coleslaw was a generic, mayonnaise based slaw.I will eat at New York Super Subs again! Head over for solid sandwich options.

Always fast and good. Their Hot Sausage sub is fantastic.

Only stopped in briefly to pick up food for a friend. While I waited the cheesecake caught my eye as it's one of my wife's personal favorites. Slice of cheesecake will set you back about $4 bucks, but texture and taste were spot on! Not too heavy and they were generous with the strawberries in syrup. Plenty more on the menu that I'd like to try.

Huge portions, fresh ingredients, and friendly servicesveggie and cheesesteak subs are great