New Sheffield Cafe

Saw this place on DoorDash so decided to give it a try. Food came fast and for delivery it was really good. Well packaged also.Huge portions here. I got a large steak salad but should have gotten a small. Steak was great. Real pieces of steak...not nasty steakums. Cubed cheese was a nice option. Ranch tasted homemade.My son got a custom burger with fries. He said it was good. The fries are those crispy seasoned kind.Also got a buffalo chicken wrap but saving that for lunch tomorrow. It does look and smell delicious though.Will definitely order from here again to try more items. Glad I took the chance on this place.

Food is amazing!! I worked here for just a few months and i fell in love with the staff and the people. Id recommend this place to everyone.

I have been eating at the New Sheffield Cafe my whole entire life! It is in a new location on Brodhead Road. I probably have only gotten three or four things until my last time there...wanted to venture out. The new location has a great size bar upstairs, and one downstairs too, as well as two rooms of low tables and some high tops table in the bar area. The last time there my husband and I both got a cup of clam chowder soup that was pretty good and shared a basket of friend shrimp, fries, and cole slaw. The shrimp were great as well as their fries. We normally get the steak salad or steak bowl...both always wonderful with sweet and sour dressing...a must

Ordered a chicken tender salad this evening. Very disappointed. 3 olives, 8 pieces of cheese and chicken that would feed a child.

I really enjoyed my steak salad from New Sheffield cafe. I do wish I got a large instead of a regular, however it is nice they offer two different sized! The steak was perfectly cooked and a good variety of veggies was in the bowl. Can't wait to go back soon

Just had the #6 Triple. 3 eggs, hash browns or home fries, toast and meat. $11.19. It was really good. Over easy eggs cooked perfectly. I requested crispy bacon and that's what I got. Texas toast toasted perfectly. I could eat this every day if my cardiologist would let me! Lots of crispy hash browns. Very good breakfast. They were busy so my meal took a while but it was worth the wait. I eat there all the time and I've never been disappointed.

The food is always good here. The daily specials are great and the prices are very reasonable considering the size of the portions. The wait staff are friendly and the place is clean. Great for take out or sit down. The meatloaf is excellent - it's my favorite!

The service is absolutely fantastic. Buckshot and the crew are the best. Highly recommend the New Sheffield Cafe

Beer Batter Fish Platter was delicious. Steve is fantastic, even remembered my cocktail and haven't had him as a server for a while. Steve always gives the best service!!

HelloI ordered shrimp salad ($20) and received a steak saladWhen I called I was told by Brittany that I could bring the salad back ( this was my lunch from work) I asked for a door dash or refund and was told no they can't and won't do that. i have a picture of my receipt and the food I received. I then asked for a manager and was told Brett would not be in until this evening .Very poor customer service! I will never order from here again. I guess my money and time are not important. What happened to integrity and standing behind your service ?