Mr Pizza

Mr. Pizza is the bee's knees,The Wednesday special of Meat Ball Hoagie and drink for 3.35 is possibly the best deal in New Castle. The pizza isn't going to make you a believer in God but it's still really good and for the price you almost feel like you should pay more. Downside is the cups they give you to drink are small and you have to constantly go back up to the counter if you want more pop and if you're like old Chappy you can knock down several medium size cups of Diet Pepsi.Chappy

Best pizza, soup and subs in New castle! they've been open for as long as they have been for a reason, always consistent and great.

Honestly. This is the worst pizza in town. They let it set out all day and heat the slices when ordered. No sauce taste, it was very dry and crust was like cardboard. Now I haven't had any of their other menu items so cannot comment on that. Back in the 90's their pizza was really good. This place needs better management.

The meatball sub and the pizza is always delicious. The employees are always polite and friendly. Overall there's nothing to complain about about this place. Plus the food isn't that expensive either. an 8 cut pizza or a meatball sub is less than 16 bucks.

A "hidden gem"! Definitely get your moneys worth, the portions are large, the price is affordable. Staff is helpful and friendly. Quick service also. Great allAround.

While their crust is amazing but they have screwed up my order the last three times. This last time they screwed it up twice. First had the wrong toppings and was barely baked and the replacement was raw in the center. We called to talk to a manager and we could hear someone in the kitchen "what's wrong with that one?" when they found out they were talking to us again.They did offer a refund for the pizza the screwed up twice but I didn't feel like waiting for them to come back again to pick it up. If they got their act together they would be amazing but as it stands it is time for us to find a new pizza place.

Pretty solid pizza. I would say it's one of the better tasting pizzas in the city of New Castle. Not real cheesy, but the sauce is incredible and it tastes great. They have a nice dining area.

Brought my pizza out to me, was happy that it was 10 minutes less than what they said, only to find out that they had literally taken it out of the oven, threw it in a box, and walked it out to me. This isn't a good thing when you place the pizza in the passenger seat and realize all of the toppings are sliding off of the pizza and pool in the corners of the box.

I love this place one of the best pizza places in town I love to pick up orders here from door dash and I like to pick up a few slices for myself or a big pizza for my family. Also I believe they have a picture of my dog on their advertisement board.

I ordered my sandwich extra crispy, it was delivered burnt-out the point the bread was black.I called and talked to the manager on 5/18/2024 around 11pm. The MANAGER told me that I ordered is extra crispy and that was a fine line between crispy and burnt.The manager was so arrogant, rude and dismissive that I just said...I guess I will not order again. Unbelievably rude, bad food and terrible service. It was very sad since this used to be a great place. The service is worse than the food.An apology can go a long way, just a suggestion.