May's DO-Nuts

We have decided to try different donut places in the area and added May's to list a few weeks ago. Thankfully their New Castle location is near a relatives house. My parents were driving past today so stopped to get me a dozen. I can't speak of the actual bakery, but the donuts that they brought me had a great variety and tasted like homemade. Not bakery homemade, but like in a home kitchen, made with lots of love homemade. I loved that they were generous with their filling, icing and other toppings. I also like that they have been around for so many years and are a staple of the community!

Very good donuts! The donuts are fresh and the service is always fast! Way better than Dunkin who's donuts are nothing but dry.

I can't really review b/c I was trying to find a donut shop and Yelp! led me to their old (empty) location. I just wanted to save someone else a wasted trip. Their new location is 1214 Butler Ave (Rigotti Plaza).

Service sucks and the lady that gets donuts is a bitch at the Neshannock one...I quit going there because of her too many OTHER donut places where they are NICE when they are taking your $$

I used to be dedicated customer years ago. Now the last 4 times I have bought the donuts I am finding them with a rancid taste and odor.. Judging by other peoples reviews elsewhere I am alone on this. I do not drink alcohol or do I smoke cigs.so my taste buds and mind are clear on this. I am done with patronizing the owners of this place.

May's Donuts has the best donuts in the world. They had some issues at thier old locations but they recently open in Neshannock and the donuts are the best they ever have been. They are the donut shop in town that still makes everything from scratch every morning.