No sauce
Raw
Undercooked, it's more miss than hit here.
Menu
NEWEST MENU
Mama Pepinos West Newton Menu Front
a menu for a sandwich
a menu for a restaurant
Menu
menu, sandwiches
Now these fish sandwiches aren't bad ! Well, not EXTREMELY great . But functional .( sorry guys, but I have had much better )
Mama Pepinos West Newton Menu 2nd Page
menu
Mama Pepinos West Newton Menu 3rd Page
menu
Mama Pepinos West Newton Menu 1st Page
Menu
Matt B.
Jan 21, 2024
I kept trying them but it's more miss that hit. Foxes or Pizza House are all that's left. $50 for two medium special pizzas that were not good. They are in consistent one out of four tries were good. I'm done.
Read MoreTherese B.
Jul 4, 2024
Food is good. Service can't be better. Menu has slot of options. Stuff that was supposed to be hot was hot.
Read MoreMelville P.
Mar 17, 2021
If I was writing this review based solely on the food I've tasted, they'd get a 4. The Pierogi pizza is incredible. They also have beautiful Jumbo full chicken wings. However, the place doesn't look clean, there's nowhere to stand and wait for your food, and when I arrived to get my food ten minutes after they said it'd be ready, I had to wait another twenty minutes...so thirty beyond the 25 minutes they originally told me. Furthermore, in that small space were 5-6 workers, all with masks around their necks, yet no one actually wearing them over their noses and mouths. Without proper mask hygiene while making food and handling customers, I'm done. I'll miss that pierogi pizza.
Read MoreJuliette M.
Jun 14, 2020
We came to get dinner while we were biking. Just a little place, hardly any place to park, and no place to wait while they prepare your order. It was literally so busy, the phone was ringing constantly. That to me is a good sign that this place is popular. We got gyros because we had a coupon and they were really good! Simple toppings, but very full and tasty! We also got a side of cheese sticks and they were great. We ate at one of the picnic tables by the GAP trail visitors center and we really enjoyed everything. We will definitely try the pizza sometime. The staff at this shop are very nice, but they are busy, so we tried to make our order as quickly as possible. Final thought: a pretty good little pizza shop!
Read MoreNick K.
Feb 25, 2020
Great pizza and friendly service. The steak salads is huge and delicious. Try it you will love this place.
Read MoreSam T.
Oct 11, 2024
20 years ago I use to get the pepperoni rolls. I am still craving them today. I must make a trip to West Newton soon just to get them. Just know, you are a lucky duck if you live close enough to get them at any time.
Read MoreHawkeye P.
May 22, 2024
order all the time for small birthdays and get togethers . fantastic sauce on the pizza , i mean i really like their sauce and they're not shy with the the toppings. the wings are so good too , the whole wing , flat and drum combo also good camaraderie in the kitchen with all them , haven't ever left that joint not smiling
Read MoreAlexis n.
Apr 23, 2023
gave me food poisoning! the service was taking forever. it's just bad! i got the ham and cheese hoagie and it didn't taste right. i came home from the drive and i threw up many of times
Read MoreErika W.
Feb 20, 2022
OMG!!! The Steak & Cheese Pizza is AMAZING!!! They even have French fries on it!! Porky knows what he's doing!!!
Read MoreMatt R.
Oct 2, 2021
By far my favorite pizza in the area. It is now our 'go to' for take out. Staff is super friendly. Also excellent customer service. Recently I went there and there was a mixup with my order. They really went out of their way to fix it.
Read More