Maggies Magic Muffins

Stopped by because it looked cute while in Youngstown. Liked the idea of a small business making awesome muffins and breads.Unfortunately, Maggie has no clue what she's doing. Egg sandwich is an abomination. Flavorless. Muffins are insanely sugary and plastic tasting. Literally threw away the food :( Don't make the same mistake as us -- keep driving.

Once again the greatest muffins We have ever had. The staff is always happy to assist and hreat to offer suggestions. It was late Saturday and the selection was still plentiful. I watched a Beautiful basket being set up for delivery.

Incredible. Impeccable. Outstanding. The best muffins you'll ever have.The pistachio muffin had a lot of actual pistachios in it which gave it a wonderful texture. Coconut almond muffin was to die for, a heavier emphasis on the almond than the coconut. Cinnamon muffin was 10/10 as well, would pair well with coffee. Not quite as sweet as the others which was good too. Blueberry muffin had a cheesecake filling which yes, you guessed it, was incredible.Highly recommend this place.

Delicious Large muffin and several flavors To choose from. Carrot and Banana or Peanut Butter and my favorites.

Muffins are huge and so tasty. The case is filled with 40+ different flavors. One muffin is $2.75. A lot of flavors are names after Beatles songs. They have just about every combination you could think of.Today we tried apricot, strawberry streusel, all shook up, cinnamon girl and sugar cookie. Each one was delicious!

The absolute best muffins! Always baked fresh with a very very large variety of flavors. The muffins are huge. Such a hidden gem and a cozy little atmosphere. Weekly customer for many years! Get there early because they sell fast

Such a cute tucked away bakery with AMAZING looking muffins! Theyre HUGE and we'll worth the cost!! I stopped by to get a half a dozen to take home for family to try and there were so many amazing flavors to pick from! The shop itself is so unique and cute! Highly recommend to try!

It's creepy, smells like old people and the muffins aren't very magical, making me put 85 characters is dumb

Absolutely fantastic, Maggie's Magic Muffins is a truly magical little hole in the wall in Boardman. Unfortunately its operation seems to be in a hiatus right now - very much hoping maggie's magic muffins comes back to us soon!

The biggest muffins I have ever eaten! My kids love going here too. There are so many fresh baked varieties.