Painkiller
drink
All of the award-winning rums!
a drink on the bar
Hot Buttered Rum
two bottles of pumpkin spiced coffee
three bottles of rum
Zombie
Hot Buttered Rum - dark rum/house-made butter batter *contains dairy
three bottles of rum and a drink
Bottles For sale
Rum old fashioned
Maggie's Farm Rum bottle selection.
Shamrock
interior
Nice summer beer
interior
drink
interior
drink
interior
interior
The Zombie
Painkiller with Falernum Float
Amanda B.
Jan 7, 2025
Maggie's is definitely one of my favorite cocktail bars in the city!For starters, I love the location - it fits the neighborhood so perfectly (it's in an old warehouse) and it's really cozy/inviting inside.Most importantly, the drinks themselves are delicious - my favorite is the painkiller, but you can't go wrong with anything on their menu. Their rum is so good and they do a great job of showing it off via the different cocktail options they offer. I also appreciate that most drinks are around ~$10 in the age of $15+ craft cocktails. The staff is super friendly too, and overall, it's a great bar that I couldn't recommend more if you enjoy rum and/or great cocktails!
Read More
beth h.
Feb 3, 2025
Maggie's Farm is such a great cocktail bar. Hidden inside a discretely marked building on Smallman, this place serves up delicious tiki drinks as well as traditional & creative cocktails all made with a variety of their rums and liqueurs. They make the best Pain Killer around! Plan on making a stop if you are in the Strip District.
Read More
Melissa N.
Dec 11, 2024
Maggie's Farm Rum is one of my favorite stops for happy hour. I look forward to trying their new cocktails each month. Every drink is handcrafted and I haven't had one I didn't like yet. The eggnog is the best around. The painkiller will make you forget your worries. I love that you can make the painkiller non-alcoholic or as they call it pain free. Super dog friendly and able to bring outside food in.
Read More
Jason W.
Dec 31, 2024
You'd never expect this place just by looking at it from the outside. Good service. Scratch made egg nog was fantastic. Old fashioned, I'm not quite sure on. As I brought it I the drink to my nose, it had an overpowering orange smell - maybe the rum is too mellow and it needs something harsher to balance the sweetness of the citrus peel. The drink itself was not bad, but I think the rum didn't have enough flavor to balance the sugar.
Read More
Xin F.
Nov 16, 2023
Was introduced Falernum while I was at PA Libations looking to get a locally produced alcohol. Instantly became a huge hit among my family and friends. Decided to check out their distillery and try other cocktails with my friends. Absolutely love every drink I've tried. The staff were so friendly and nice. Can't wait to be back for a drink or two!
Read More
Mark V.
Jan 9, 2025
It's up to five. Friendly service means so much, and my sister and I have had it on our ritual visits here. Great product. Fun place to hang out.
Read More
Julia B.
Feb 26, 2024
If you didn't know what you were looking for, you'd walk right by this spot on the street! The nondescript outside hides an intimate tropical cocktail bar inside! The vibes are great, and the drinks are delicious. Every single cocktail that we tried made me feel like I should be on a beach somewhere (instead of in Pittsburgh in February). While there isn't table service, the bartenders are pretty quick at making the cocktails. I can't believe it took me so long to discover this hidden gem - I'll definitely be back!Food: N/ADrinks: AService: BAmbiance: A-
Read More
Karen H.
Sep 8, 2023
I went to Maggie's Farm Rum for the first time on Friday of Labor Day weekend around 6pm with a few friends. It's a small spot that's easily missable if you don't know what you're looking for. There's a fairly big bar inside with bar seating as well as a handful of high top tables and a couple of bigger regular tables.I was blown away by the cocktails. The presentation is beautiful and they all tasted amazing. I thought the prices were extremely reasonable for what we got.You have to go to the bar to get service but they're super friendly and speedy! Overall, an excellent experience and I 100% want to go back, especially once they change up their cocktail menu!
Read More
Todd R.
Sep 7, 2023
So I had some time to kill this evening and looked up rum bars. And for all my Houston friends, I'm in Pittsburgh, PA. Anyway, Yelp led me to Maggie's. And I will say, not easy to find. The Lyft driver and I scratched our heads for a minute. Anyway, a true hole in the wall and when you walk in, it looks like an old school no frills bar. Whisky barrels everywhere filled with various versions of their rums. And it's a rum bar that serves only what they make. And the make several varieties of rum - strait rum, light, dark, pineapple, spiced, an old fashion version- just add an orange wedge, several variations of aged. They got rum. The owner or manager was tending bar and working the phone so getting his attention was a task, but as he explained, hiring people now days is hard. So I had a few tastings of the dark, light and his favorite, the Sherry cask. All good, but the Sherry cask was pretty damn good. I tried the Old Fashioned which has all the flavorings added. Pretty good, a bit sweet. But good. Then I had him pour me his favorite drink - his go to. It's was a variation of an old fashion with different rums. Better than the last.So, if you are in the the Pittsburgh area and a rum drinker, you gotta try this place. Amazing rums. You won't be disappointed.
Read More
Jayme B.
Aug 9, 2023
Finally made it to Maggie's! We stopped in here for a nightcap recently. The bartender was funny and welcoming even though it was towards the end of the night. This place is such a cool hidden gem in the strip! I definitely want to come back and try more drinks when we have more time! I also loved the presentations of the drinks. Such a fun place!
Read More