Kopicko’s Pizza

Am in town for the next few weeks and was feeling some pizza and wings. After perusing Yelp and checking photos, this spot seemed to be the pick.I'll be trying elsewhere rather than going back, unless I want a calzone.Ordered their Sicilian pizza, which I did see them request to give it an hour for it to be made. Alright cool. Added some boneless wings and a calzone too.They must have made the boneless wings right when the order came in, yknow along with that 60min+ pizza? The "boneless wings" appeared to be two chicken tenders they tenderized to the thickness of a fried pickle, dusted with shake and bake, left in the over too long, and then kept it in the warming area/wherever they keep hot food hot, as the "wings" were bereft, the sauced baked on, and horrendously unappetizing. We each took a bit and threw them away - worst boneless wings I've ever had. Completely ruined the impression for us.Moving onto better , the Sicilian pizza was alright. Biased due the pizzas I can make, and for the wait time and price.. eh. Have had better. Wasn't bad, just have had better. A solid 3.5/5.Their meaty calzone? That was great tho. Loved that it wasn't overstuffed with meat and cheese, was a nice clean calzone. Well done.would return but ONLY FOR A CALZONE. I do not trust them to execute fried food/whatever those boneless wings were.. had to be baked and sat in the window for over half an hour. If you're considering picking up, advise a second thought about ordering an app with your pizza!! They won't time it right and you'll get subpar food for the 10.99$/whatever you pay.

I go by this place about three times a day, always seeing people inside. Then I read the reviews... thus, we had to have a Saturday road trip to New Brighton to check out Kopickos!Love the interior which is pizzeria cozy with the tin tile ceilings and exposed brick walls. Good location on the corner of NB's Main Street to boot. We ordered the XL Pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni, and instantly when it came out we knew we had a new favorite place to go. And as good as the pizza looked, it tasted even ten times better! Superb crisp crust, mouth watering pepperoni, and the sauce on the pizza is amazing. Met the owner who is a great guy and proud to make his product part of the valley. I'm sure the rest of the menu is just as good, so we will definitely be back, and so should everyone else in Beaver County and surrounding areas.

This restaurant quaint restaurant on the corner of Third Avenue in downtown New Brighton. The owner makes everything from scratch with only the finest ingredients which comes out in the food that is served.The pepperoni rolls are delicious and enormous! There is no shame if one person can't eat the entire thing in one sitting. The Italian hoagie is loaded with meat and fresh veggies. The French fries are delicious and crispy. The Lenten special fish sandwich, Codzilla, is absolutely ENORMOUS! The breading on the fish is crispy and flavorful, the tartar sauce is out of this world, and you should bring a friend (or two) to share!

The four stars are because I have only had the pizza from here which is 100% amazingly amazing! Everyone likes the way cheese, sauce, or crust is made and tastes on their pizza. My favorite is how the sauce is made and they do it with perfection. If you have not heard of or been to this pizza shop then I highly recommend while you're coming through New Brighton stop and try it yourself. I can assure you won't be disappointed.

Great pizza and the crust was amazing! We have family coming into town and will definitely be ordering again.

Only do take out, but the order is always ready on time and the pizza is great. I highly recommend this business.

Good pizza but a little overpriced right now. The pizza was 8/10. Cheese was good, crust was very crispy and the people were very nice.

5 onion rings for $6.49. I have been a fan and cheerleader for this place on account of the top notch pies, but really. That's nearly $1.30 per ring, and two of them were in pieces. Good value is every bit the element of success as good food. Please help me to understand.

The wings were pretty good, The pizza was very good. Not overly greasy either. The pizza was delivered on time and hot. Will be ordering from here again.

Ordered a large pepperoni and large cheese pizza. Both were excellent. The fact that my phone order was taken at 10am when they weren't open till 11am was amazing! There are a few good Patriots left in this world. Bravo!!!