Front entrance
Deep Fried, Baked, Mashed Potatoes, Stewed Tomatoes.
We are open 6 days a week!
Liver & Onions served with 2 sides. Thursday's all you can eat.
Nautical feel with no bodies of water anywhere nearby
Merry Christmas from Key Largo's!
All you can eat in house Baked Haddock fish with Homemade Mac & Cheese and stewed tomatoes. Served on Wednesday's & Fridays from 11am-close.
All you can eat in house Deep Fried Haddock with Homemade parsley potatoes & stewed tomatoes. Served on Wed and Fri from 11am-close.
BLT with French Fries
a plate of food
10oz Pub Steak served with 2 sides of your choice.
Don't even think about it!
interior
Lunch/Dinner menu Page 5
Appetizer Sampler
Cheese Steak Sub with French Fries
All you can eat Hand dipped Beer Battered Haddock with baked potato. Served Wed and Fri from 11am-Close.
Located along Route 53 we are 1.5 miles off of the Interstate 80 exit.
Mushroom Swiss & Buffalo Cottage fries. 10/10
Grilled Hamburger Steak served how you like and with 2 sides of your choice. Served daily from 11am to close.
Chicken sandwich
Grilled chicken salad loaded with veggies, French fries, & Cheese. Served daily from 11am to close.
12oz Delmonico Steak served with any 2 sides of your choice. Served daily from 11am to close.
Grilled Salmon served with any 2 sides of your choice. Served daily from 11am to close.
Larry M.
Aug 23, 2024
Long road trip pit stop just off I-80 found this cozy cabin posing as a seafood shack in western PA. We lucked out and landed on Friday for their all you can eat ("refills" available on fish and sides) Friday fish fry, available all year long and Wednesdays. Terrific price, tasty everything (we had beer battered and Italian fish (haddock only option) plus Mac n cheese, salad, an avalanche of waffle fries, and stewed tomatoes (with Italian baked fish (really). Topped it off with a $3.99 slab of coconut cream pie. Plenty of other options too.
Read More
DV H.
Apr 10, 2024
This place could have major potential but simply doesn't put it together. The food is mediocre at best. Rather than freshly made meals, you get processed frozen and heated up Sysco stuff. When in a group of 4 or more, meals come out piecemeal and not all together. The wait staff is the best part of the restaurant. Great crew. Rather than doing many things in a subpar way, pare down the menu and do things great.
Read More
Scott L.
Sep 19, 2020
Hands down the best fish dinners around. All you can eat Wednesday and Friday haddock prepared in four styles. I prefer to get half portions and make my way through all of them. Even the half portions are larger thank you think, so go hungry!My favorite is the baked Italian, which is topped with sauce, onions, and cheese. My second choice is the deep fried and a delicious cup of tarter sauce that goes with it. The Mac & cheese is very creamy, not runny at all. This will stick to your rib cage for a while. I am not normally a fan of stewed tomatoes, but I can't get enough of these. I mentioned to the server they were my favorite and she brought me a bowl on the side. Thank you!!It does get busy during the fish special nights, so go early. There is a lot of decor to keep you entertained if you have to wait for a table, true both both the kids and adults. I've been here twice and enjoyed both times.
Read More
Jenny T.
May 5, 2019
Thanks to other Yelp reviews leading me to this traditional American diner. This place deserves good reviews.You would think a small diner that has no other restaurant nearby can't be good because no competition. Not this diner. The coleslaw was delicious and refreshing. The cabbage was completed drained before putting the mayo so the flavor was rich, cabbage texture was crunchy and no liquid leftover after the dish was finished. Back of my mind I was happy whoever made this coleslaw knew the art of "wait for it!"We had a bowl of mushrooms cream with bacon soup and it was very thick and yummy. Main course we had cheese steak burger, the melted cheese with tomato and fried onion was very tasty, and we ordered sweet potato fries. They are wonderful combination for satisfaction guarantee!I would come back on my return trip.
Read More
Richard M.
Aug 20, 2010
Only minutes from I-80 (Exit 133) just south on Rt 53, in an old log structure with lots of character. It can get packed on Fridays, and it's a local favorite. Nice people, honest fare at great prices.Great fish fry on Fridays and Wednesdays. All you can eat for 10 bucks. Haddock, beer battered, deep fried, baked or Italian style, our group tried them all and everyone was very happy. Delicious! But you must save room for dessert. Heavenly pies. Coconut cream! And "meltaway" chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting. We bought more to take home to share. You'll thank me later.
Read More
Stephanie H.
Nov 28, 2024
great food and service &i always with a smile on my face. specials daily... clean restaurant and restrooms !
Read More
Mary A.
Oct 22, 2023
Food was decent for a roadside restaurant. The servers were friendly and the place was clean.
Read More
Lucy K.
Apr 21, 2023
Our neighbor was raving about this fantastic fish dinner he had at Key Largo so my husband and I drove an hour to give it a try. We arrived at 4 pm on a Friday to beat the dinner rush. The baked fish and parsley potatoes were tepid at best and looked like they were left from the lunch service. The tartar sauce was warmer than the fish. The only thing that was hot was the stewed tomatoes which were delicious. None of the food was over salted which was wonderful.Then there was the price! The online menu listed the all you can eat fish dinner at $12.99. The menu priced it at $16.99. We were charged $17.99. In addition the two fish dinner options were Fish dinner with refills and Half Fish dinner with no refills. Guess which one we got charged for even tho we didn't get any refills. Surprise! Apparently the half fish dinner is a child size 2x3 inches! Not worth the hour drive.
Read More
Stacey G.
May 15, 2020
Fantastic salmon dinner tonight - lovely hometown restaurant!Salmon with vegetable medley and cottage cheese
Read More
Michael W.
Sep 24, 2022
The food is good, there are all you can eat menu selections, service is fine. Nice atmosphere.
Read More