Keedy's Pizzeria

My favorite place to eat on the GAP trail. First off, the waiter was extremely friendly, despite doing double duty as the cook and somehow managed to fill all our water bottles in between. Party of 8 with all sorts of seperate check combinations, and she didn't miss a beat. Second off, the food was amazing. The menu offered all sorts of both pizza and non-pizza things, and everything was delicious. Wings - few of us ordered all combinations of sweet, sour, spicy and garlicky wings. They were perfectly crunched and packed with flavor. "Finger licking good" is very appropriate here.Paninis - few of us also found our special someone on the sandwich menu, and was thrilled to find evenly toasted flatbreads with some great tastes inside. My turkey provolone was nothing short of magical. and BONUS seasoned fries that everyone actually wanted to finish.Pizza - some of us actually ordered what the restaraunt was known for, and I heard lots of good compliments coming from the other side of the table. All you can eat pizza too! I could not recommend this place more. Fried comfort food done right, fuel for the next leg of the uphill battle.

Good pizza at a good price. It is a great spot to stop for lunch while riding the GAP. We got two slices of freshly made pizza with one topping and a drink for only $3.99! I would've given 5 stars but the bathroom wasn't cleaned!

Food's pretty good. The girl on the phone misheard our order and gave us an extra two dozen wings we didn't order, and then told us in order to rectify her mistake that we'd have to drive back into town and return all 20 wings. She specified it must be all 20. Thanks for that doll.

My parents ordered 2 pizzas from keedys pizza in connelsville they got home and no sauce!! They called right away and were told a manager would be in touch.No calls I messaged on Facebook and nothing. So I finally called today and asked if they plan on making it right and they DONT!! Please take your Business elsewhere NewYork pizza by Martin's is My all time fav. Also great Customer service !

I've never stepped foot in Keedy's restaurant - yet. But I *have* ordered delivery many, many times. For starters, getting food delivered out here in the countryside is difficult, so kudos to them for servicing us. I don't particularly like paying $3 extra on top of my order because of where I live, but some restaurants charge extra just to deliver, period, so this isn't an out-of-the-ordinary charge, just an annoyance.The food is pretty good. I've had a sampling of most of the menu, from appetizers to desserts, and I can honestly say that the items I've eaten have been worth what I paid. The appetizers are all fried, as are all the desserts. Their fries are very tasty for a pizza place, as are the wings. The very first item I ordered was a regular stromboli, and I really liked it. Their sandwiches - hamburgers and subs - are generous, on good bread, and depending on what you order, range from okay to very good. I'm a picky eater, and I never found anything to be inedible. The pizza doesn't stand out, but that's okay - being just as good as your competition in this area is a compliment, as far as I'm concerned. All in all, my experience with Keedy's restaurant has been very positive. The only time I felt the need to complain was when a pizza was delivered with most of the toppings on one side, because the driver set it crooked on the way to my house. But otherwise, they do a great job, even when I make strange requests, like when I ask them to put lettuce & onions for my subs on the side so they'll be crisp when they get here and when I warm up leftovers, or when I make substitutions on the appetizer sampler. I'm not a big spender, either, being on a fixed income right now, but unlike other places that deliver, they don't have a minimum. I appreciate that they have Lunch Specials, Daily Specials, and other specials. Mondays, for instance, if you place your order via Facebook, you get a discount up to $10 off your order.With worthwhile food, reliable delivery, and meaningful specials, Keedy's Pizzeria gets 4 stars from me.

Best wings in the area hands down. Everything else I've had from their menu has been bomb, but their wings are what I go for. Best sauces, super meaty and perfect crispiness.

Their food is amazing. I would say that the service is a bit long but it's worth the wait! The ambiance there is great, everyone was happy. I would recommend this restaurant 100%

I used to love ordering here when visiting my mother. A while back I ordered sandwiches and kept getting these really sharp black pieces in every bite . When I took my sandwich apart it looked like what could be burned scraped pieces of the grill. I called for refund and explained what happened. They took no accountability and refused my refund. Instead, they offered to make another like that would help alleviate it

Last night i got the Falcon Deluxe pizza. It was the best pizza I've had in a very long time. The buffalo chicken salad was good also. I will definitely order from here again.

Keedy's never disappoints! I have never had a bad experience there! The food is always phenomenal & the staff is excellent.