Hugger-Mugger Tasty Recipes

Fresh Baked Subs Special

BBQ Ranch Sub

Crispy Cajun seasoned chicken tenders topped with bacon, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, BBQ and ranch dressing. *Served with one side.
$9.00
Ham and Cheese Sub

Served with lettuce and tomatoes. *Includes one side.
$9.00
Meatball Sub

*Served with one side.
$9.00
Philly Steak Sub

Thinly sliced ribeye smothered with melted mozzarella, onions and green peppers. *Served with one side.
$9.00
Combo Club

Ham, homey turkey, bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing. Served cold or toasted on a fresh hoagie roll. *Includes one side.
$9.00
Turkey Bacon Swiss

Served with lettuce and tomatoes. *Includes one side.
$9.00
Tuna Sub

Toasted with lettuce and tomatoes. *Includes one side.
$9.00

Appetizers

Cheezee Fries - Regular

A large order of lightly seasoned French fries topped with real crumbled bacon and cheddar cheese.
$7.50
Cheezee Fries - Large

A large order of lightly seasoned French fries topped with real crumbled bacon and cheddar cheese.
$11.00
Small Naked Wings

Grilled Chicken Breast with your choice wing sauce
$12.25
Medium Naked Wings

Grilled Chicken Breast with your choice wing sauce
$16.25
Large Naked Wings

Grilled Chicken Breast with your choice wing sauce
$20.25
Large Traditional Wings

20 wings with your choice of sauce!
$20.25
Small Wings

10 Wings with your choice wing sauce
$12.25
Tater Wedges - Regular

Flash fried skins lightly seasoned and topped with real crumbled bacon, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses. Served with sour cream.
$5.75
Tater Wedges - Large

Flash fried skins lightly seasoned and topped with real crumbled bacon, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses. Served with sour cream.
$9.50
12 oz Cup of Ranch
$4.99
Onion Rings - Regular

Sweet, thick-cut Spanish onion rings battered and deep fried to a golden brown.
$4.50
Onion Rings - Large

Sweet, thick-cut Spanish onion rings battered and deep fried to a golden brown.
$6.00
Large Boneless Wings

(20) boneless wings with your choice of sauce!
$20.25
Medium Boneless Wings

(15) boneless wings with your choice of sauce!
$16.25
Small Boneless Wings

(10) boneless wings with your choice of sauce!
$12.25
Medium Wings

15 wings with your choice wing sauce
$16.25
Chicken Fingers

Homestyle breaded chicken tenders fried until golden brow, Served with dipping sauce.
$7.00
Combo Platter

Combination of chicken fingers, tater skins, mozzarella sticks and onion rings.
$11.99
Mozzarella Sticks - Regular

Breaded mozzarella sticks flash fried and served with dipping sauce.
$7.50
Mozzarella Sticks - Large

Breaded mozzarella sticks flash fried and served with dipping sauce.
$11.00

Clubs

All American Club

An 8 oz burger and Ham with american cheese. Lettuce Tomato and Onion on 3 pieces of choice thick bread. *Includes one side.
$11.00
Ham, Egg & Cheese Club

Grilled slices of smoked ham, scrambled eggs and American cheese. *Includes one side.
$10.50
Ham, Turkey & Cheese Club

Thinly sliced honey baked turkey, slices of smoked ham and Swiss cheese. *Includes one side.
$11.50
Turkey Bacon Club

Thinly sliced honey baked turkey and crisp bacon. *Includes one side.
$10.00
Chicken Pita

Tender grilled marinated chicken with lettuce and tomatoes.
$9.00
Gyro Pita

An authentic blend of lamb and beef with lettuce, onions and tomatoes on a grilled pita with cucumber sauce on the side.
$9.50

Garden Fresh Salad

Bacon Cheeseburger Salad - Regular

1/2 lb of ground Angus, crispy bacon, hard boiled egg, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses and steak fries.
$11.00
Bacon Cheeseburger Salad - Mini

1/2 lb of ground Angus, crispy bacon, hard boiled egg, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses and steak fries.
$9.50
BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad - Regular

Tender strips of Cajun seasoned chicken breast, crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses with steak fries. Served with BBQ and ranch dressing. What a treat!
$11.00
BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad - Mini

Tender strips of Cajun seasoned chicken breast, crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses with steak fries. Served with BBQ and ranch dressing. What a treat!
$9.50
Buffalo Chicken Salad - Regular

Crispy pieces of chicken coated in Buffalo sauce, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses and steak fries.
$11.00
Buffalo Chicken Salad - Mini

Crispy pieces of chicken coated in Buffalo sauce, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses and steak fries.
$9.50
Chef Salad - Regular

Smoked ham, honey turkey, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
$11.00
Chef Salad - Mini

Smoked ham, honey turkey, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
$9.50
Grilled Chicken Salad Supreme - Regular

Tender strips of grilled chicken breast, crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses and curly fries.
$11.00
Grilled Chicken Salad Supreme - Mini

Tender strips of grilled chicken breast, crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses and curly fries.
$9.50
Gyro Salad - Regular

Specially blended beef and lamb, hard boiled egg, curly fires and mozzarella cheese tops a mountain of fresh salad greens.
$11.00
Gyro Salad - Mini

Specially blended beef and lamb, hard boiled egg, curly fires and mozzarella cheese tops a mountain of fresh salad greens.
$9.50
House Salad

Our fresh salad greens and your choice of dressing.
$4.79
Soup of the Day
$3.79
Steak Salad - Regular

Seasoned steak, hard boiled egg, mozzarella cheese and steak fries.
$11.00
Steak Salad - Mini

Seasoned steak, hard boiled egg, mozzarella cheese and steak fries.
$9.50
Tuna Salad - Regular

Topped with fresh tuna salad, hard boiled egg, onion, tomato, cucumber and peppers on fresh crisp lettuce.
$11.00
Tuna Salad - Mini

Topped with fresh tuna salad, hard boiled egg, onion, tomato, cucumber and peppers on fresh crisp lettuce.
$9.50
Quesadilla Salad - Regular
$11.50
Quesadilla Salad - Mini
$9.75

Little Italy

Chicken Alfredo

Tender strips of grilled chicken breast a top a bed of pasta sauteed in a rich and creamy Alfredo sauce. *Served with a hearty portion of your choice of spaghetti or pasta of the day, a house salad and a bread stick.
$11.49
Crusted Chicken Parmesan

Grilled boneless chicken breast atop pasta, topped with toasted Parmesan cheese. *Served with a hearty portion of your choice of spaghetti, Pasta of the day, or Ravioli. A house salad and a bread stick.
$11.49
Italian Sausage Casserole

Italian sausage served with sauteed pasta, rich marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. *Served with a hearty portion of your choice of spaghetti or pasta of the day, a house salad and a bread stick.
$10.99
Spaghetti Dinner - Regular

Two homestyle meatballs with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. *Served with a hearty portion of your choice of spaghetti or pasta of the day, a house salad and a breadstick.
$10.99
Spaghetti Dinner - Seniors

Two homestyle meatballs with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. *Served with a hearty portion of your choice of spaghetti or pasta of the day, a house salad and a breadstick.
$7.99
Veal Parmesan

Beaded veal patty flash fried to perfection over a bed of pasta, covered in marinara sauce then topped with mozzarella cheese. *Served with a hearty portion of your choice of spaghetti, Pasta of the day, or Ravioli. A house salad and a bread stick.
$11.49

Dockside Specials

Clam Basket

A boat load of tender clams. *Served with choice of two sides.
$10.00
Baked Boston Cod

A large fillet of Atlantic cod seasoned with a garlic herb butter topped with breadcrumbs. Baked to a flaky and delicate perfection. *Served with choice of two sides.
$12.00
Hand Breaded Cod Fillet

A large white fillet of cod breaded in our seasonings and fried. *Served with choice of two sides.
$12.00
Popcorn Shrimp Basket

Breaded shrimp, fried to a golden brown. *Served with choice of two sides.
$11.00
Maryland Crab Cakes

A special blend of lump crab meat and seasonings hand formed and grilled. *Served with choice of two sides.
$12.99
Seafood Platter

Breaded cod, a Maryland crab cake, shrimp and clams with your choice of potato, a house salad and a breadstick. *Served with choice of two sides.
$15.99

Dinner Time

Open Face Pot Roast Sandwich

Smothered in gravy. *Served with your choice of potato.
$8.99
Country Fried Steak

Country Seasoned beef patty breaded, flash fried and covered with pepper gravy. *Served with your choice of two sides.
$9.99
Liver & Onions

Tender beef liver smothered in grilled onions. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$9.99
Marinated Chicken Fillets - Regular

Tender chicken breast seasoned and grilled to perfection. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$9.99
Marinated Chicken Fillets - Seniors

Tender chicken breast seasoned and grilled to perfection. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$7.49
Smothered Chicken - Regular

Grilled marinated chicken breast smothered with fresh sauteed onion, mushroom, mozzarella cheese, zesty Italian sauce and peppers. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$10.29
Smothered Chicken - Seniors

Grilled marinated chicken breast smothered with fresh sauteed onion, mushroom, mozzarella cheese, zesty Italian sauce and peppers. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$7.69
Southwest Chicken - Regular

Grilled BBQ chicken breast topped with real crumbled bacon, cheddar cheese and diced tomatoes. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$10.29
Southwest Chicken - Seniors

Grilled BBQ chicken breast topped with real crumbled bacon, cheddar cheese and diced tomatoes. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$7.69
Ham Steak Dinner

A jumbo honey glazed ham steak. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$10.49
Homemade Meatloaf Dinner - Regular

Our own freshly made meatloaf covered in your choice of zesty Italian sauce or a rich dark gravy. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$9.79
Homemade Meatloaf Dinner - Senior

Our own freshly made meatloaf covered in your choice of zesty Italian sauce or a rich dark gravy. *Served with you choice of two sides.
$7.79
Open Face Meatloaf Sandwich

Smothered in gravy or marinara. *Served with your choice of potato.
$8.50
Stir-Fried Chicken

A combination of grilled chicken, lightly seasoned vegetables and rice pilaf. Served with one side.
$10.99
Stir-Fried Vegetables

A blend of crisp lightly seasoned vegetables atop a bed of rice pilaf. Served with one side.
$10.99
Chicken Plank Dinner - Regular

Tender strips of white chicken breast breaded and flash fried to a golden brown. *Served with your choice of two sides.
$9.99
Chicken Plank Dinner - Senior

Tender strips of white chicken breast breaded and flash fried to a golden brown. *Served with your choice of two sides.
$7.99
Open Face Turkey Sandwich

Smothered in gravy. *Served with your choice of potato.
$8.75

Sandwiches

A Burgh Thing N'at

Choose your meat. Served with coleslaw, crispy French fries, Swiss cheese and tomatoes piled high on our thick cut Italian bread.
$10.99
Bacon Chicken Ranch

Boneless breaded chicken breast flash fried to a golden brown and topped with bacon strips and ranch dressing. Served on a kaiser bun with lettuce and tomatoes. *Served with one side.
$9.99
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

A grilled marinated breast of chicken topped with mayo, lettuce and tomatoes. *Served with one side.
$9.00
Ham & Cheese Melt

Thinly sliced smoked ham piled high with mayo, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomatoes. *Served with one side.
$9.50
Our Famous Reuben

Tender corned beef sliced thin and smothered with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and Thousand Island dressing, grilled on rye bread. *Includes one side.
$9.75
Southwest Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast topped with crumbled bacon, BBQ sauce and melted cheddar cheese. *Served with one side.
$9.25
Spicy Chicken Club

Boneless spicy breaded chicken breast flash fried to a golden brown and topped with bacon strips, Swiss cheese, mayo, lettuce and tomatoes. Served on a kaiser bun. *Served with one side.
$9.99
The Country Cut BLT

A country favorite. Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo on your choice of thick cut white, wheat,rye, or toast. *Served with one side.
$8.75
Turkey Melt

Thinly sliced turkey piled high with, Swiss cheese, and tomatoes. *Served with one side.
$9.50
Jumbo Battered Cod Sandwich

fried white fish fillet on a toasted bun with tartar sauce and lettuce. *Served with one side.
$11.99
Gyro Sandwich

Authentic blend of lab and beef topped with , lettuce, onion and tomatoes. Served with cucumber sauce on the side *Served with one side.
$9.50
Grilled Tuna Melt

Our own homestyle tuna salad with American cheese and tomatoes. *Served with one side.
$9.50

Burger Time

Bacon Cheeseburger

Two strips of bacon and choice of cheese on a kaiser bun. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$10.50
BBQ Ranch Burger

Topped with bacon, cheddar, mozzarella, BBQ sauce and ranch. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$10.50
Beefy BLT

Take a classic BLT with bacon, mayo, lettuce and tomatoes and add big beefy layers of Angus beef on Texas toast. *100% Angus beef. *Includes one side.
$11.50
Breakfast Cheeseburger

Bacon and an over hard egg with choice of cheese. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$11.00
Classic Burger

An 8 oz. patty topped with lettuce, tomato, pickle and onions. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$9.50
Dante's Inferno Burger

Cajun seasonings, smothered in our hot wing sauce and topped with grilled jalapeno peppers and cheddar cheese on a kaiser bun. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$10.50
Deluxe Cheeseburger

*100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$10.00
Grilled Cheezzzzy Melt

Two American classics brought together. Our Angus burger sandwiched between two grilled cheese sandwiches then topped with lettuce, tomato, pickles and onion. *100% Angus beef. *Includes one side.
$12.50
Mother Ship Gut Buster

Two patties piled a mile high with lettuce, tomato, pickles and onions. Served with your choice of cheese on a kaiser bun. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$13.50
Mushroom & Mozzarella Burger

Mozzarella cheese and mushrooms on a kaiser bun. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$10.50
Reuben Burger

Our classic 1/2 lb. burger smothered in sauerkraut, Thousand Island dressing and Swiss cheese on grilled rye bread. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$11.00
County Line Burger

Topped with ham, BBQ sauce and choice of cheese on a kaiser bun. *100% Angus beef burgers. *Includes one side.
$10.75

Side Items

Apple Sauce
$2.79
Baked Potato
$2.79
Cole Slaw
$2.79
Cottage Cheese
$2.79
Curly Fries - Regular
$2.79
Curly Fries - Large
$4.29
French Fries - Regular
$2.79
French Fries - Large
$4.29
Mashed Potatoes
$2.79
Rice Pilaf
$2.79
Side Salad
$4.79
* Pita Bread
$2.19
Bread Stick
$0.55

Kids Meals

Jr. Cheeseburger
$5.50
Jr. Hot Dog
$5.50
Jr. Pizza
$5.50
Jr. Spaghetti and Meatball
$5.50
Jr. Fish Dinner
$5.99
Jr. Ham Dinner
$5.50
Jr. Grilled Cheese
$5.50
Jr. Grilled Chicken
$5.50
Jr. Meatloaf Dinner
$5.50
Jr. Corn Dog
$5.50
Jr. Chick Strips
$5.50

Gift Card

Gift Card - 10$

Add a gift card to your order and we will have it ready for you. Also for a fee we can ship one to the address you provide in the description below!
$10.00
Gift Card - 25$

Add a gift card to your order and we will have it ready for you. Also for a fee we can ship one to the address you provide in the description below!
$25.00
Gift Card - 50$

Add a gift card to your order and we will have it ready for you. Also for a fee we can ship one to the address you provide in the description below!
$50.00
Gift Card - 100$

Add a gift card to your order and we will have it ready for you. Also for a fee we can ship one to the address you provide in the description below!
$100.00

The Butcher Block

Steak & Chicken Combo

Best of both worlds! 6 oz. of choice cut sirloin and a marinated chicken breast. *Includes your choice of two sides and bread.
$13.50
USDA Choice Sirloin

Fire Grilled, seasoned and tenderized sirloin. *Includes your choice of two sides and bread.
$13.50
Pork Chops - Regular

Two 6 oz. boneless pork chops fresh cut in house with choice of BBQ sauce or simply lightly seasoned. *Includes your choice of two sides and bread.
$10.99
Pork Chops - Senior

Two 6 oz. boneless pork chops fresh cut in house with choice of BBQ sauce or simply lightly seasoned. *Includes your choice of two sides and bread.
$8.99

Family Meal Deals

Steak & Chicken Feast

5 - 6oz Sirloins, 5 Grilled Chicken Breasts, Mashed Potatoes, Gravy, Family sized Salad and 6 Bread sticks.
$70.00
Stuffed Chicken Breast Feast

6 Stuffed chickens, Mashed potatoes w/ gravy, Green beans, Salad and bread sticks. Please allow 2 hrs for prep time and cook time.
$70.00

Lewis L.

★★★★★

Feb 7, 2025

Food is very tasty. My girlfriend had an open faced turkey sandwich, I had the meatloaf and mashed potatoes. Good comfort food and the service was very good. Would definitely recommend this place.

Cookie S.

★★★★★

Dec 23, 2023

This is the hidden gem in a small town. Ambiance is very, very clean. Old fashioned feel with a modern stroke. Metal ceiling shows the cleanliness. Food was homemade. Stuffed pepper soup was very good. Cherry pie a la mode was incredible. Prices are incredibly reasonable. Server was very prompt and nice.

Peyton C.

★☆☆☆☆

Jun 16, 2024

I ate here with my dad as part of the county burger trail. (Note I'm not officially doing the trail just trying all the places on it and doing it in my own way as I judge a restaurant experience off of everything as opposed to one singular menu item.) Anyways, the server was extremely rude and cold. The burger was thin and tasteless not smash burger thin, like no taller than a nickel. It was served on a massive thick doughy bun that was like chewing gum. The fries tasted like they got cheap frozen fries from Giant Eagle and they didn't even properly cook them, they were ice cold and frozen. They don't give you a ketchup bottle or even little cups of ketchup just packets.My dad got some pasta dish and it was like they just dumped out a can of chef boyardee, it was degusting. Will not be back!

Justin J.

★★★★★

Aug 4, 2022

Hugger Mugger is my favorite place in New Castle to get breakfast! The hometown legend is your best option! The waitress' are all very nice! I always enjoy going there for breakfast.

Amanda H.

★☆☆☆☆

Jun 26, 2023

I ordered a salad and got a couple of pieces of chicken, 2 tomatoes, and 4 pieces of cucumber on top of wilted lettuce. My son got pancakes and the cook made them look like Mickey Mouse, which was cute, but the server never refilled our drinks or brought our syrup for the pancakes. Overpriced for the low quality and quantity of food.

Michael M.

★★★★★

Feb 15, 2025

I love the breakfast food! We go with grandkids and we all enjoy the fast and friendly service

Gerald L.

★☆☆☆☆

Dec 30, 2023

got dinner there last night but thought it was the worse dinner i ever had.Man was I wrong went there again thinking maybe they were having a bad last night they seem to not worry about how the plate looks but when you order a hot turkey sandwich and the turkey seemed like it was microwaved and the bread was as tough enough that you needed a knife to cut it then I ordered 2 sides of green beans and guess what happened.They were probably the best you could ever have but never got them.they really need to hire someone with a little pride that cares what they serve.really loved to eat there but I think Im done with themcan't wait for Coney Island to open

Alex S.

★★★★★

Feb 5, 2024

I love this place. They even have tablets for kids. For five people I spend less then 50 and it was a lot of food. The waiters there are also super friendly and they work so hard

Lyrical N.

★★★★☆

Sep 8, 2023

Wide selection of pretty good food. Breakfast has gone downhill but Salads/Burgers/Boneless Wings are all good. Service is usually so so, never really bad but never that good. Usually packed in there so must be doin something right.

Jennifer ..

★★★★☆

Aug 8, 2023

Friendly service and good food with generous serving sizes. Very reasonable prices. Would definitely eat here again if we visit the area.

Hugger-Mugger Tasty Recipes

Menu

ADD FOR CURB SIDE PICKUP

Add to order for FREE Curb Side Pickup

Fresh Baked Subs Special

BBQ Ranch Sub

Ham and Cheese Sub

Meatball Sub

Philly Steak Sub

Combo Club

Turkey Bacon Swiss

Tuna Sub

Appetizers

Cheezee Fries - Regular

Cheezee Fries - Large

Small Naked Wings

Medium Naked Wings

Large Naked Wings

Large Traditional Wings

Small Wings

Tater Wedges - Regular

Tater Wedges - Large

12 oz Cup of Ranch

Onion Rings - Regular

Onion Rings - Large

Large Boneless Wings

Medium Boneless Wings

Small Boneless Wings

Medium Wings

Chicken Fingers

Combo Platter

Mozzarella Sticks - Regular

Mozzarella Sticks - Large

Clubs

All American Club

Ham, Egg & Cheese Club

Ham, Turkey & Cheese Club

Turkey Bacon Club

Chicken Pita

Gyro Pita

Garden Fresh Salad

Bacon Cheeseburger Salad - Regular

Bacon Cheeseburger Salad - Mini

BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad - Regular

BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad - Mini

Buffalo Chicken Salad - Regular

Buffalo Chicken Salad - Mini

Chef Salad - Regular

Chef Salad - Mini

Grilled Chicken Salad Supreme - Regular

Grilled Chicken Salad Supreme - Mini

Gyro Salad - Regular

Gyro Salad - Mini

House Salad

Soup of the Day

Steak Salad - Regular

Steak Salad - Mini

Tuna Salad - Regular

Tuna Salad - Mini

Quesadilla Salad - Regular

Quesadilla Salad - Mini

Little Italy

Chicken Alfredo

Crusted Chicken Parmesan

Italian Sausage Casserole

Spaghetti Dinner - Regular

Spaghetti Dinner - Seniors

Veal Parmesan

Dockside Specials

Clam Basket

Baked Boston Cod

Hand Breaded Cod Fillet

Popcorn Shrimp Basket

Maryland Crab Cakes

Seafood Platter

Dinner Time

Open Face Pot Roast Sandwich

Country Fried Steak

Liver & Onions

Marinated Chicken Fillets - Regular