Fudge Farm - Waterfront

I love coming into Fudge Farm and getting the chocolate covered Oreos and turtles! They always taste fresh and hit the spot! The menu includes plenty of other chocolatey and sweet items, but I'm a creature of habit. There are some swings outside for a cute photo opportunity. Most of the time, I'm in and out.

Let me say that this is a hidden gem ! It is incredible for those with the sweet tooth. I have been there twice so far. Each experience has been plentiful. It's a tiny little place with various options and good service with a great appeal. The shakes are much better than the Milkshake Factory but be warned, bring a partner with you to share the goodies with !!! I ordered 1 scoop of the banana cream pie and 1 scoop of the graham cracker. It is so filling!!

The prices were higher than I wanted to pay. Looked tasty though. The employees were nice and patient. I did not feel obligated to buy something.

Very solid spot to get some tasty treats, and the location is pretty cool as well. They have homemade fudge, chocolate, and milkshakes. They have 2 categories of milkshakes: essentially, the classics (vanilla, peanut butter, chocolate, etc) and 'Mania' shakes (that are...extreme). I tried a Mania shake called the Double Wide.The Double Wide comes with peanut butter ice cream, a chocolate chip cookie, and a brownie. It's extravagant to say the least. Price wise, I thought it was okay, but a tad expensive. Portion was about average.The milkshake itself wasn't anything all that special. I didn't really taste much peanut butter in the ice cream to be honest. The brownie and chocolate chip cookie were thrown into the ice cream...the brownie was kind of dry and not the best, but the chocolate chip cookie had lots of chocolate and was delicious.All in all, a pretty solid spot to get dessert. They have a cool menu with unique creations and the location is pretty nice, too.

Great time grabbing dessert at fudge farm in the waterfront. It was busy when we stopped by over the weekend in the evening. The line to order was out the door. There was still plenty of seating outside and the staff were very friendly despite the crowd. The ambience was nice and I enjoyed the swings outside the shop as well. They had displays with all the fudge and other sweets. There were lots of dessert options and we decided to get the Finn McCool mania milkshake. It's very fun how all the milkshakes are named after local Pittsburgh businesses. The milkshake was very delicious and filling. It had a whole brownie on top and lots of chocolate chips inside. The amount of chocolate was a little overwhelming but still delicious. Overall a great place for a nice dessert!

My girlfriend and I were roaming around waterfront and we were craving something sweet, so we stopped into fudge farm to grab a milkshake to share! I forgot which one we got, but whatever the specialty topping was they were out of it, so they let us pick one! We chose the peppermint fudge which was delicious! The ice cream tasted a little weird tho, and I'm not sure if it was old or if our tastebuds were just off tonight, but something didn't taste completely right! Definitely will be back for more though, as I know fudge farm has some of the best milkshakes in the Pittsburgh area!

This is a good little place to get some ice cream or a milkshake. My littlest and I were shopping so we stopped for a sweet treat. We tried their chocolate ice cream. It was really good. The store was nice and clean also.

Came in today with a couple friends who hadn't tried Fudge Farm yet. The four of us got The Flats, Smiling Moose, and Jaggerbush. Everybody really enjoyed what they got but these shakes can be a bit of sugar overload! I definitely recommend sharing a shake if you can. Price is fair, service is reasonably quick, and the storefront and establishment are clean :) this is the second location I've been to and I'd definitely come back.

Stopped here for the first time to try some of their fudge and chocolates, and was surprised by the offerings for the milkshakes. We didn't try a milkshake, but plan to stop again and try one! We bought a few different types of the fudge, and we were very impressed with the quality and how good it was. The taste was perfect. Some of the best fudge we've had. We also tried some of their chocolates. I was slightly less impressed with these, as the chocolate was not the quality I expected it to be with how good the fudge was! Not that I wouldn't get it, I just expected the chocolate to be better. But, still good! Can't wait to go back to get more fudge, and to try one of the milkshake creations!

It appears they have closed down :( My partner and I planned our entire Valentines day around getting our favorite milkshakes ever. We love the taste, its our favorite. The South Side location was the closest to us and after that shut down we have to make a trip out of it because the Waterfront location is so far. I love all of the little shops and other eateries, its a fun environment.When we walked up to where the store used to be, the glass is painted in a winter landscape, the sign was ripped down and the swing outside, gone. Their social media says absolutely nothing about their closing (and it looks like their facebook was hacked by another company?) Im so SO sad. Leaving 5 stars because I loved this place...but very disappointed its gone.