Forgotten Taste Pierogies

4.5 stars overall. Forgotten Taste Pierogies restaurant sells pierogies and some other foods that are mostly Eastern European.Flavors of pierogies include potato, potato cheese, potato bacon, potato sauerkraut, sauerkraut, lekvar prune, potato cheese jalapeno, cottage cheese, spinach ricotta, spinach feta, roast beef, sausage, cheese pepperoni, buffalo chicken, and some seasonal flavors.Other foods include stuffed cabbage, stuffed pepper, kielbasa, haluski, goulash, borsch, some desserts, etcetera. Many of the foods are available as either hot/ready-to-eat for dine-in or cold/frozen for takeout.For about a decade, I have bought foods from this restaurant. During my most recent visit, two employees promptly and politely served me.The restaurant contained some tables and chairs, but I always eat my foods at home. I rate the potato pierogies, potato-cheese pierogies, sauerkraut pierogies, and red borsch as 5 stars. I rate the potato-sauerkraut pierogies, haluski, stuffed peppers, stuffed cabbage, and kielbasa as 4 stars.

This place has excellent pierogies and classic Polish favorites like stuffed cabbage and halushki. I got a combo meal that included 4 pierogies, stuffed cabbage, and green beans. I also tried a small side of the halushki. The pierogies were outstanding, definitely my favorite part of the meal. They are boiled, rather than sautéed, so they are soft outside and fluffy inside. The restaurant is clean and neat with a small, casual seating area. Everyone lines up at the counter to order and there was a line with a few people when I went on a Friday evening around 7:00 PM. The ladies working behind the counter were friendly and attentive. I will definitely be back for the pierogies in the near future.

This place is fantastic! The food is authentic and they have the best pierogis in town. We've tried almost everything and we keep coming back for more. Great service too!

I love this place! The goulash, pierogies and kielbasa are my favorites. The ladies that work there are very nice and helpful. The dining area is small and cozy. It's mostly a takeout restaurant.

Delicious classic Polish food!The menu is reasonably priced with generous portions and a wide selection of Polish food to choose from. The meal combinations typically include a vegetable, starch (mashed potatoes, pierogies or noodles) and protein (like stuffed cabbage, meatballs or kielbasa sausage). You can even order individual sides!If meal platters aren't what you are looking for, they have a vast selection of pierogies! Flavors like potato and cheese to blueberry to bbq pulled pork!I adore their stuffed cabbage smothered in tomato sauce. The cabbage is filled with a blend of rice and ground beef. The restaurant has plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. It is clean and there is lots of parking in the plaza. tldr;food 5/5service 5/5interior 4/5

Wow!!! Better than Baba's pierogis! Worth the drive. The ratio of potato/cheese is the perfect filling. Super fresh and tender. They tasted like they were knead that very same morning. Don't forget to ask for the sour cream/onions. Really, they're the best pierogis I ever tried.

I've only done takeouts (buying Frozen ones) from here. Never been here until my friend from Colorado were requesting for them. I was skeptical at first but decided to give them a try. Since then, this is the only place I get Pierogies. Very simple set up inside. Staff are always very friendly and helpful. I think their food is worth the price. You have the options to buy the Pierogies frozen or for a couple more bucks, cooked for you. Now if they only offer interstate shipping. It would make my friend a happy person! I bought a whopping 15 dozen of Pierogies at a go.Their #1 is Potato Cheese. It's one of my favorites for sure. Next would be their roast beef and cabbage. Not forgetting their Buffalo chicken as well!

I finally found borsch! It is delicious! They have it frozen in quarts to go and I can't say enough about what a treat this new discovery is. I shared quarts with vegan friends and we all served it for Christmas dinner this year. (And I drive over an hour to pick this up). Lekvar is another first time trying. Sooo good. I'll be stocking up on these also. Don't be afraid to try new foods. My next one to try is the sauerkraut pierogi.Megan Meridew

I ordered food to takeout and when I wanted to add to my order the owner YELD at me that I " waited until she put everything away " !!!! so I said no problem I will just take whatever she wanted to sell me and she said no. I insisted with one of her employees to allow me to just pay and leave. I will never go back. No food is that good to be screamed at in public!!!! Stay away!!!

I found this place on yelp. I liked the reviews and what people said. The pierogies were yummy. We got some meatballs too, and they were OK. The pierogies were the best I've had with the exception of my godparent's mother.