Fellinis Pizzeria

It was our first time visiting Fellini's. I grew up eating at a place very similar to their pizza. When you walk into the pizzeria it's like stepping back in time. I absolutely LOVE it! The smell transported me to my favorite pizza joint that I would go to after swim practice. The way the pepperoni curls brings a smile to your face as you think of times past. The first date when you're in middle school while your mom sits 3 tables away as the chaperone. That first delicious bite takes you back to the days of your swimming WPIAL practices as a celebration dinner before the big day.The late night greasy fix after the school dance with your friends while playing the pac man table top game. (I wish Fellini's had one of those!)The steak hoagie is by far the better of the steak hoagies that I've had recently. It's seasoned well and they actually put the mayo on the hoagie! It starts to liquify and just soaks all through the sandwich the way it should!The provolone sticks are incredible! I don't know if they're homemade, but they sure taste it.And the breadsticks! The breadsticks are just leftover dough covered in delicious butter garlic sauce. PERFECTION!I could just sit in Fellini's all day smelling the wonderful smells and talking about growing up in the 90's.

2 weeks ago I ordered a pizza delivered. It was delivered in their usual timely fashion hot and,,,,, OMG this pizza is fabulous, unlike the last time, it has ample toppings and is fully cheesed. I cannot believe the change.This shop has great cooks. This is the four time in 2 weeks. Used to be only once a month. They have earned me as a customer. PS I Ordered a Steak sub that was hot, juicy, fully of goodness5 STARS *****

I am appalled by this place!! Ordered a pizza online and when I got there all the guy at the counter said was "we don't have it". Even when I told him I had the order number he offered no help. He did not even take the number to try and find out what happened to my order. Thankfully I at least did not pay online so I was not out any money. But that was only because I had this same probably last time with their online ordering system. Also. I had to use their online ordering system because the phone line was constantly busy even though the guy running the store was just sitting there when I arrived.

We ordered two medium pizzas for pickup tonight and asked for no onions on one of them (my boyfriends allergic). We got home and unfortunately there was onions. We called and explained the situation and the man on the phone was SO NICE, and they ended up having someone drive it out to us AND they gave us a large. Talk about going above and beyond! This is my favorite pizza place in Pittsburgh (the crust is INCREDIBLE!) If you haven't tried them, you must check them out! :)

Honestly I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of this place. I'd never heard of it, and they came through! Just did a cheese pizza, whole wings, and cheese sticks. The wings were fantastic. A tad over seasoned but I really didn't mind. I'd definitely get food from here again.

Great pizza joint in Monroeville. Classic pizza taste, great sauce, plenty of toppings, nice crispy crust. If you love pizza, you'll love Fellinis. Today was meat lovers, and one half cheese, half black olives.

3.5 stars... This is one of the only pizza spots in town we hadn't tried out, so we ordered a mushroom, olive, and onion white pizza with a side of the hot cheddar balls and breaded mushrooms.We requested delivery for 8pm and the (super kind and apologetic) delivery lady brought our order around 8:20ish. She explained there were only 2 drivers and they were extremely busy that evening. I honestly didn't mind, but might have, had I been hungrier. Her sincerity made all the difference. The pizza was very good and I'd say the best part about it was the generous toppings. They were easily spread around and slices weren't cut completely even, but again, the toppings made up for it. One thing I noted about the taste was it seemed like they use a lot of herbs like Rosemary or oregano on their crust. It helped to bring out the flavor, although the dough was not the best I ever had. It reminded me slightly of Pizza Hut crust, and was just a tad too oily for my personal liking. Breaded mushrooms and cheese balls were good and served with a marinara(?) sauce that was sweeter in taste than most I've had. I thought the cheese poppers were a little scarce both in quantity and quality (not the best I've tasted) for the 5.50 price. Mushrooms were decent and again, came with dipping sauce. I would order again from here, but wouldn't be my number one choice. I think it has potential to get better, though. Bonus point for coupons that are offered via text, which we did not take advantage of on this occasion.

Yes, its pizza is amazing love the Sicilian style pizza is crunchy toast and fluffy. Just like I like it. It pleases my stomach and I will go back to have some more yummy pizza. My favorite pizza is .

Melissa and Matt are so extremely helpful and made sure I knew the specials happening when I stopped in. They were very patient with me even though it was a busy day for Fellini's due to a football game going on! The store was very clean and well kept, and I was pleased with everything about the service that is why I'm giving a 5 star review!!

I ordered a steak wedgie, it came with no steak when i called the first time she said she watched him make it and he put steak on it then i called again because i was upset with how they acted & the owner said "even though it's a busy friday night i will send you a new one and take the old back" very rudely & when they got here they would not give us the new one or take the old one back. so we will never be ordering from there again we normally order from there like 2x a week.